Can you help with choosing an idea?

[Scootadress 361]

I'm making comics for Halloween and the upcoming season of MLP and Walking Dead. I wanted to sort of make a cross over between the two in some way, shape, or form. I really held these ideas since August, but wasn't sure I had the talent at the moment to go through with it.

 

One is more ''game like'', where the main character has to go through the process of turning from human to pony in a stunning way.

Nut shell:Basically, a human named Cassiopeia (directly named after the constellation) winds up in Equestria, and for the moment, only knows that she wasn't always a pony. All she remembers is running from a horde, scooter, sister, and 'baby' in tow. Struggling with her new life, she needs to find her purpose and stop her own world from shattering. Under the guise of Scootaloo, she faces choices and challenges she never expected to make.

 

That's a mixture of mythology, MLP and Walking Dead. One could only wonder why she chose Scootaloo as a name and not stick to Cassiopeia. (Though...she wouldn't already be well liked...)

 

The other is a mixture of game like and manga. Same main character (Scootaloo) totally different situation. Scoots ends up in the human world during the dead plague through a stunt Diamond does to her that totally goes wrong. As they (Ponyville) watches, they have to sit back in horror as she embarks a life of being a human-hard style. Who knew finding new things could be deadly? She runs and finds a few survivors along the way, one sounding similar suit to Rainbow Dash. (Hetalia and MLP mashed)

 

I just need to choose which to do this month..any help?

[duidamasterXD 9,627]

@Scootadress, since you seem to be asking for input on artistic ideas and for something you plan to create, I've moved your thread to Creative Resources since it has more to do with getting feedback than the brony fandom. Just letting you know

[Slice0Pie 815]

I sadly don't know which to choose since I am making a animated youtube series called My Little Zombie lol, sorta like what your thinking except different

But I say choose the first idea it sounds pretty cool what your planning on making and I hope to see it

Edited October 9, 2013 by CadenceDerp

[rainbowdashbrony1 130]

Hello, scootadress  here's my suggestion if you want a crossover with The Walking Dead and MLP FIM maybe try a gothic look like make the ponies more menacing or evil scary like Queen Chrysalis hope that helps ?