"I practically am Pinkie Pie.
But Pinkie Pie claims she is Pinkie Pie."

If you practically are Pinkie PIe, but PINKIE PIE claims she is Pinkie Pie, then Pinkie Pie is Pinkie Pie.

I hope I made sense.

"I practically am Pinkie Pie.

But Pinkie Pie claims she is Pinkie Pie."

 

If you practically are Pinkie PIe, but PINKIE PIE claims she is Pinkie Pie, then Pinkie Pie is Pinkie Pie.

 

I hope I made sense.

...because Pinkie Pie is me? Indeed, that would make a lot of fun. ... I mean sense. Thanks for clearing that up. So this is just a case of multiple body disorder.

P.S.: I love pineapples.

I REALLY do.