Jump to content
  • entries
    363
  • comments
    1,100
  • views
    270,700

We Bronies Dissect the Show, and It's Grrrreat!


Dark Qiviut

1,896 views

One of the hearts of the brony community is the thinkers. The people who behave like scientists and analyze every facet about the show: the characters, atmosphere, episodes, and little references in each episode. Compared to other fandoms (the lone exceptions being possibly Sonic and Harry Potter), this fandom tends to review things from an extremely critical perspective, whether it's positive, neutral, or negative. Sometimes, we do this to a fault where we may occasionally think too much. But knowing us scientists, we like to take the information, break it down, and then reassemble it. It's as if we're taking a physics class 24/7, except it's more fun, and we don't have to take an academic exam for it. laugh.png

Now, there has some rather loud dissent of the thinking, part of it when some bronies have been rather critical of Rainbow Dash's character as of late. I've seen one loud fan call the (perhaps overly) critical dissent as (in his exact words) "Over-analyzing at it's best here people." Well, it's time to respond back and why thinking this critically is one of the greatest things in this fandom, even to a so-called "nitpick."

Early in the brony fandom, one of the most popular and biggest pieces was a physics presentation, the one that basically exposed the brony community to the Internet and its potential to reflect intelligently and critically. Taking the show, this person then showed a complex presentation of the way the show's physics work with its universe. Here is the video.

It's rich. It's deep. It's smart. It's informative. Even almost two years later, I'm still wowed by it. If you haven't watched it, please do.

Afterwards, the brony fandom has begun looking at the show from an extremely critical view. We take a close look at everything we see and hear from the show, from the episode itself down to its little detail in Rarity's shopping bag. Currently, we have a plethora of rich analyzers here: myself, Chaotic Discord, Kyronea, Scootacool, Alfonzo Dennard, and so on. We review the show inside and out so we can fully comprehend its premise, characters, and whether they make sense. But around the brony fandom, there have been a lot of deep analyses. Several months ago, one user broke down Twilight Sparkle's cutie mark and what it truly stands for. If anyone wants to read it, click here. It's very good and extremely informative.

Sometimes we take such a close look that we tend to overthink or think the wrong stuff. For instance, some of the fanon like Lyra's interest in humans. Sometimes, it results in us getting a bit too far in ourselves. In other words, we tend to analyze to a fault occasionally.

But this flaw is also such a great strength in the community.

For one, these moments of really thinking about the show shows a completely fresh perspective of we watch and hear. My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic is the most intelligent family-friendly episodic animation since Avatar: The Last Airbender, and it isn't done by accident. When we view the show from its exterior only, then we just see the animation, characters, beginning/middle/end. End of the episode. Going back to analyze the episode little by little gives the mind such a fresh look on the episode, be it positive or negative. For example, when I watched Magic Duel for the first time, it was great with well-done characterizations, plot, and ending. Then I rewatched it, and I gained a much more thorough, fresh perspective on it.

Here are my consecutive analyses of the episode (either via the links or the "spoilered" em-dashed passages below):

———

 

This was a really great episode initially. After rewatching it a second time, it's become even better. Hilarious usage of references that only teens and adults would catch, and great usage of using the "six" but not resort to the Elements of Harmony. Twilight has the strength and tenacity to not just outdo someone in magic, but outwit someone. She's a very smart unicorn, and the way she and her friends helped team up to beat Trixie in her game was priceless. She really put that intelligence into good use throughout this episode, and she learned valuable wisdom from Zecora, whose character is severely underused.

As for the criticism of Trixie's apology being rushed, not true at all. There was a little moment that foreshadows Trixie's humbleness: her embarrassment, confusion, and creeping away while the other ponies gathered around Twilight. The lesson of friendship was how Twilight gained not only her physical strength, but emotional strength, too. So far, Twilight's magic seems to be influenced by those around her. When her friends support her, she succeeds. When they're not, it doesn't have as much luster. Her faith and trust with her friends is why she's such a great unicorn. She can learn all the magic, but without friendship, she can't develop at all, hence her cutie mark. It was evident throughout this episode and one key reason why Trixie was beaten in round two.

And apparently, this lesson isn't forgotten by Trixie. She still has that boast, but she now understands how to be cocky and not use it out of anger and revenge. The Alicorn Amulet used her thirst for being the best, and it corrupted her. It fed off her negative emotions, turning her into someone she doesn't want nor need. After what happened following her initial humiliation, she has developed her character. Maybe now she can channel those emotions into something more positive. She's got the talent to be that magical nomadic showmare, and there's hope that she can finally put this into good use and actually be Great and Powerful rather than Angry and Bloodthirsty.

———

 

Just watched the episode for a third time, and I love it more and more. And this time, I'm by looking at a few extra things.

  1. The contrast in atmospheres throughout the episode. The beginning was extremely moody with the tavern, rain, and muted colors. Then the brightness of Ponyville followed by the cloud cover later that day. And finally the beautiful nighttime sky.
  2. As always, the production stands out so well and gives Adobe Flash the respect this underrated medium deserves. MLP:FIM showed us what Flash can do, but the later seasons demonstrated the extra details, such as the smooth visual animation, colors, the moving around the mouth, and camera angles.
  3. Spike's rise as an important character. For most of the previous two seasons, Spike was a secondary character. In Season 3, though, he garnered three crucial roles already: being one of the main rescuers of the Crystal Heart in The Crystal Empire, finding the book that describes the Mirror Pond, and now being the one responsible for keeping the team together in One Magic Duel (although Fluttershy found the book discovering the powers and consequences of donning the Alicorn Amulet tongue.png ).
  4. Some overlooked genfic material: a possible exploration of Snips and Snails being loyal to Trixie even though she horridly treated them throughout the episode while under control of the Alicorn Amulet. I'm unsure if the writers will ever explore it, but there's a lot of room for developing the friendship between them in many angles: trust, fear, guidance, loyalty, redemption, and even their talents/pursued interests (which for Trixie, it's to perform in front of an audience).

 ———

I followed this same pattern with "Sleepless in Ponyville" here.

When we deeply review episodes, we can analyze them inside and out instead of just its dress. It makes us appreciate the overall production of the episode and show. Whether it makes you like the episode or not, and whether it determines whether that specific episode is good, average, or bad is up to you.

And to go even further in its intelligence, the staff always adds in some references here or there (say, they may add them anywhere! laugh.png). These references play a little game for the viewer to spot, find, smile, laugh, and appreciate.

Secondly, we analyze the episodes this deeply because the staff WANTS this. When we analyze, we create rich communication between the professionals and the bronies. The bronies see all this rich information beyond the dress, and we relay this back to the professionals either intentionally or accidentally. They see it themselves and appreciate how much we like to see the episodes and overall show beyond the veil.

This communication also results in the staff appreciating not just the audience, but their overall product more. When you work on your product, you tend to see this from tunnel vision. In other words, your world, your vision. The animators and storyboards take the ideas and script to give it more life. But the viewers then take what they see and pick it apart. They see what's so great about it, what's not so great, and how they can make the product even better. When they see us reviewing it from a more critical, microscopic perspective, it gives the team a much fresher, prouder, more concrete view on their product.

When the staff notices this fresh viewpoint, then they play some games on how to make themselves appreciate the quality they display on screen for millions of people. These games, normally in the form of newer references (sometimes subtle to only the bronies) give us a bigger and better opportunity to review a more revised and better product and then see the results of this communication. The bronies and professionals have an extremely close relationship. The richness in these analyses are one of the key reasons why.

Finally, these rich analyses show us that we care. The brony community is so invested to the show, that we review the product deeply to prove it. Sometimes our analyses result to the point in disliking the episode. In Sleepless of Ponyville, one person couldn't like it as much as the others mainly because he considered dreams and nightmares to be a very private matter, and he didn't appreciate how Luna got involved in Scootaloo's nightmares. (A rather refreshing point, which I disagree with, but a pretty good point nonetheless.)

We love this product sometimes to a fault, and these analyses show how much we adore it, even if we tend to think too far to the point where we get a splitting migraine. But after leaving and then going back to review what we wrote, all it does is show how much we just love to see the product and want to nurture it. When we analyze this deeply, we want the show to grow beyond its potential. My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic is such a great show, but we're not satisfied, and nor we should. Being satisfied means accepting the quality we have. The analyses are an underlying message that we want it to grow in its intelligence, world, characters, atmosphere, and overall production.

My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic is the most intelligent Flash episodic animation and the smartest episodic animation currently airing altogether. There are many layers that help us appreciate how the staff shapes up the episodes. These rich analyses provide such a brand new, rich perspective on how the staff created and executed My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic. But these analyses also give the staff extra appreciation for their own product, creating a multitude of ways to communicate between the intelligent community and the staff. Although we may experience points where we may overthink, dismissing it all as such is a major insult to the show and the brilliance of the staff, bronies, and overall communication between the two. Rather than dismissing it, embrace it. This show is only demonstrating how smart it is, and all of these deep analyses (whether good, bad, concrete, or overthinking) are what help not only strive to create better staff-fandom communication, but a desire to improve the product even further, as well.

  • Brohoof 12

3 Comments


Recommended Comments

I wasn't mentioned as one of the "rich analyzers", because I always have fun bringing science and math into places where it usually isn't :(

I've always thought of myself as one, guess I don't post in Sugarcube often enough :/

  • Brohoof 1
Link to comment

Hey, I happened to see this post in the sidebar and decided to read it. I only joined the forums here relatively recently (last August), but I am one of those who likes to analyze each episode. I tend to focus more on one-time inaccuracies, irrational actions, and intra-episode continuity - perhaps more of the nitpicking side of analysis.

 

I have never really been a big TV watcher, but I (over)analyze almost everything I do watch on TV. For example, my family and I analyzed the Avatar: The Last Airbender and The Legend of Korra series as we watched them, including things like what "bending" actually means and more efficient ways to kill people using bending as well as more nitpicking things in each individual episode. I agree that it is most enjoyable to analyze shows that strive to have internal realism, logic and continuity, as opposed to cartoons that throw these things out the window regularly because of laziness or for the sake of cheap laughs.

 

 

In Sleepless of Ponyville, one person couldn't like it as much as the others mainly because he considered dreams and nightmares to be a very private matter, and he didn't appreciate how Luna got involved in Scootaloo's nightmares. (A rather refreshing point, which I disagree with, but a pretty good point nonetheless.)

 

I'm not sure if this quote was referring to me specifically, but I am at least one of the people who said this. Really, the privacy and abuse of power concerns didn't occur to me as I was watching the episode, but more when I saw people's reactions to Luna's power here on the forums. I have been making an effort over the past months to learn about libertarianism and atheism, and people saying things to the effect of "I love Luna even more now that she has this awesome power and is looking out for everyone" kind of reminded me of both government propaganda - "hand your freedoms/rights over to the government; you can trust it to protect you and look out for you" - and the religious notion that a super-powerful being is watching over everyone and cares so much about every individual that it will intervene personally in individual's lives. I will admit that that is just my somewhat antagonistic view based on what I have learned from these philosophies. If you haven't seen already, I have written a little more in-depth about my issues with Luna's power on the  S03:E06 - Sleepless in Ponyville topic.

 

One of the main reasons, if not the main reason, that I joined the forums here was to find fellow watchers with whom to analyze the episodes and discuss these things which I am trying to learn about. It seems that I haven't yet come across too many people willing to go in-depth on these topics, but hopefully I can continue to find such people here on the forums.

  • Brohoof 1
Link to comment

I wasn't mentioned as one of the "rich analyzers", because I always have fun bringing science and math into places where it usually isn't :(

I've always thought of myself as one, guess I don't post in Sugarcube often enough :/

No, you're definitely one of those rich analyzers. I'm just exemplifying a few people, hence the word "so on." You're still an analyzer even if I don't name you specifically. ;)

 

I'm not sure if this quote was referring to me specifically, but I am at least one of the people who said this.
The person I'm referring to is a user on Equestria Daily called Softy8088. He made this criticism of Luna's appearance on EQD:

 

My biggest complaint is Luna. I'm in the minority that does *not* like the idea of her having the ability to enter dreams, and her saying it was her *duty* just makes it worse. Seriously, dreams are a very private matter. I don't care if you're the Princess of the Night, stay the heck out of my head. 

  • Brohoof 1
Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Join the herd!

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...