Loteenie

Even though this is about the dazzlings, I think if they weren't there and the school decided to have a battle of the bands with the Rainbooms not having any magic, that Trixie would have one fair and square without Siren influence. She did make it to the semi finals without magic and, if the sirens aren't there to ruin everything, she would have made it to the finals too and probably won because the rainbooms were having issues, which only got sorted because Sunset Shimmer noticed the Sirens were feeding of there magic. But if there's no dazzlings, that means friendship issues, which means bad performance which means Trixie wins. Also they only beat the Dazzlings thanks to Sunset Shimmer, if there's no dazzlings to beat then Sunset wouldn't have joined there band which also means not a good performance. I do agree the Dazzlings music was way better, and if they could sing naturally without there magic necklaces, they would have one easily. But we have to come to terms with they cheated, and that they can't sing. If they entered the competition with bad voices, they would have lost, unless they were good and weren't hungry for magic, they could have practiced became, good singers without magic and win. (It's possible) but that's only if they had weeks to prepare and didn't come up with idea, which they did. The Sirens didn't want to win or we don't think they do. They just wanted there magic back and doing the Battle of the Bands, at the school, with all the magic, was the only good excuse to get it and it was a good one. They only made it to the finals because they were "great singers" (totally not cheating and mind controlling everyone so they could get to the Rainbooms). Then, they would battle said rainbooms, win, take all there magic and ditch that school to rule the world probably, I mean they didn't care about anyone there, not even each other, only working together to get the magic they deserved while manipulating and using people on the way. They probably planned after they got there magic to get there revenge on Equestria. Or, maybe that's would have happened if Sunset Shimmer left or was expelled for her behaviour. Which is more realistic actually, considering she wanted to make an army of her own and destroy Equestria) Long story short: the battle of the band song and stuff was decoy to get there magic back. They didn't need anyone, just needed everyone to fight for it so they could buy themselves time and to do that they had to praise them, calling them stars when they probably didn't give a damn. Too bad they were foiled by the people they tried to steal from lol. But they probably should have thought since Sunset lost to them, they should run too because they would get there butt's wooped, too bad they had such big egos to think about it. The Dazzlings were just to proud. I wonder if they got there magic they would have betrayed each other. Though considering they've been together as a group for over 100 years. Maybe not. I also wondered if they went there separate ways since they lost. Rainbow Rocks certainly left alot of questions. No the whole series did, especially since it didn't get finished. (I'm not gonna name any of the questions it will just cause me to think of more from the ones already there and the theories and headcanons and there's too many already it will already cause me to rant more than I already am lol.) Why do I always do this? Make long comments for Jo reason on a short topic. Maybe because I'm weird but seriously.. I have no idea.

I honestly don't know what her element of harmony would be, but if I were to rate empathy, forgiveness and redemption one by one, I'd say... 1. Forgiveness because as someone said before me, a friendship without forgiveness everytime someone makes a mistake won't last very long, plus, it seems to fit Sunset more, as she has her experiences with making a mistake and having to earn peoples forgiveness and trust, so it think she will learn that and forgive anyone who has gone through the same rough patch as her, just to make there trust process a little bit easier for them like with human Twilight. 2. Empathy; because unlike forgiveness, do you really need to be empathetic to have a good friendship? I mean, some people are just naturally not empathetic but they can have true friends, I mean I guess you could need empathy if your friend is struggling so you can comfort them, and they have someone to lean on; but sometimes, as friend, you have to let your other friend fight there own battles, and again, as someone also said before me: empathetic people normally empathize with anyone no matter there situation, unlike things they themselves have gone through, which is what Sunset Shimmer's empathy is about. So even if the staff or creators or whatever said if she had an element it would have been empathy, I'm just gonna go against the canon for this one.. and put it at number 2. Finally number 3. Redemption. Honestly, I don't think redemption is a recurring quality you need in Friendship, if not at all. It just doesn't make sense to me.. isn't redemption doing something bad and then doing something good to show you've changed. Yeah it works for Sunset Shimmer for the first movie and maybe the second but from Everfree, and the series, why would she need to redeem herself again when she doesn't need to? Again like someone else already said: if someone needs to redeem themselves over and over again in a friendship; it's not a good friendship anymore if there not learning from there mistake, even after giving that person a second chance, just proving it's not a friendship sort of trait. Like Sunset Shimmer said herself In rainbow rocks "I do know that if you don't sort out your problems right at the start, the magic of friendship can be turned into something else." Are you sure that this site everyone's getting this from is actually trust worthy, no offense, but I don't think the person who made that site has the right facts, or doesn't know what there doing and has made a mistake. (I guess another to thing to back up empathy is her power to tap into people's minds and I guess that kinda links way better than super speed for loyalty and super strength for honesty, and more powers among the mane 7. Or mane 8? There's to many of them! I think they only did this because they ran out of ideas on what to put so just based it on what there pony versions strengths were. Like Rainbow Dash is a fast flyer and Fluttershy has tons of pets and Apple Jack is strong to get trees from apples. Thank you again for someone pointing it out). Thank you to all the people before me who pointed these things out, those were very valid points, which backed me up with evidence and helped me make this and explain my reason for putting the 3 ideas where I would personally put them. People might disagree with me, but that's my personal opinion. (I had my own evidence by the way, they just came from what people before me had said, which caused me to think of more ideas to back up my point). Also I didn't mean to make it so long, it was only supposed to make it like a few sentences lol. (hopefully it's not too long) Because it's long, I won't be surprised if people don't read this. Anyway, thanks for reading. Just wanted to share my opinion on the topic. 😄 Feel free to reply or whatever, I'm new to this "mlp forums." And where did you get this site from? It seems untrustworthy.