The Missing link Between MLP FIM Canon and Non-Canon?

[AppleTreeBrony 228]

Suppose there is a missing link between the Canon Universe of MLP:FIM and A Non-Canon Universe.

So here is my Theory

If Twilight were to Fail her entrance exam she would probably leave Canterlot in shame, Which means Spike would have never met Twilight, Which also means Twilight cannot run a Library. She would possibly run to Ponyville were she would go to the School, and Meet Applejack, and Rarity. Applejack would probably become freinds with Twilight first, Then she would do something to help out Rarity, which would make them freinds, Twilight would then meet Pinkie Pie then they would also become freinds. Eventually They would meet Fluttershy, and they Would help her out with her Animals, Or try at least, and they would become freinds. After preforming the Soinc Rainboom Rainbow Dash would have looked for Fluttershy, Considering that she wasn't in Cloudsdale, And found her on Earth, Rainbow would try and Convince Fluttershy to come back up because the Earth is gross and dirty and Full of germs. Fluttershy becomes a neat freak and doesn't let anypony into her house. Twilight discovers that a Pony named Rainbow Dash told her that. Twilight tries to convince Rainbow to Talk to her, But she says that "Pegasus ponies belong in the sky, Not on the ground!". Twilight and Applejack come up with a plan to get Rainbow to apoligize and, Of course, It would work. Rainbow Dash would become freinds with the 5 and then the Original Plot would take place once again. Twilight and the 5 would encounter Nightmare Moon. Twilight and the 5 make a run to Canterlot where they find a Book on Nightmare Moon. They find the Elements of Harmony and Defeat Nightmare Moon. Celestia would arrive and She that Twilight had proven her worth, Twilight's Cutie Mark would appear at that moment, And Celestia would take her as her Apprentice.

No matter what happens, The Mane 6 would meet, and they would defeat Nightmare Moon

 

So what do you guys think?

Edited September 3, 2012 by Scootabelle

[Writer 41]

That... is a long shot.

I mean, considering the conditions that would have to occur for this to happen, I'm not sure.

You see, what if Fluttershy went back to Cloudsale instead of staying there? If Rainbow performed a Sonic Rainboom then, why wasn't she a Wonderbolt in the show?

It's a cool idea and all, but there's just some... Fridge logic, would it be?

[XUNUSEDXXX 3,459]

Yes, and after Twilight fails her entrance exam, she could also give up on life, run away from home, and get eaten by some timberwolves in the Everfree Forest.

 

Sorry, your theory is possible, but definitely not likely.

[Dusty Soul 2,611]

It's not likely, but possible... What seems more possible is that Twilight goes insane and starts going all "Lesson Zero" on everything...

[Regality 233]

If she would've failed her entrance exam, Celestia would probably be doubting herself as a competent leader; as the exam was a setup in the first place, considering ponies know next to nothing about dragons, or their eggs hatching for that matter.

~~

[I used to be a stranger 7,993]

One major flaw, sorry to play the devil's advocate:

 

Twilight Sparkle lives with her parents, who live in Canterlot. If she failed the examination, it would probably mean she would try again at a different point in time, or give up, but either way remain in Canterlot unless her parents were motivated to move.

 

I thought I saw a couple others (Time incongruity for fitting the Rainboom, and Rainbow Dash's apparent prejudice of some kind) but they both came from misreading the description. I had to read it a couple times in order to fully understand it, which indicates that the specific wording needs refinement, or at least better conceptualization of the ideas you've already developed.

{I'm assuming this fan-theory is pretext for a filly-Mane cast fan-fiction.}

[DottyDoo 7]

What about Pinkie Pie? She lived on a Rock Farm. I don't even think she attended the school...This theory is pretty flawed, no offense.

[rainbow_hearts 148]

So how old were they when they defeated Nightmare moon (in your story) If they were the same age that would be pretty weird but Cherilee got hers when she was a teenager (I'm guessing)