Which looks better?

[PonyEcho 1,610]

so Iv'e been working on redesigning my OC Whirlwind just because I felt like it but all i've rely done it change his color scheme and I would like peoples opinion on which looks better.

also these are all new drawing apart from the very first one so feel free to give me you opinion on them as well

Light blue mane

 

 

 

 

 

 

Gray Mane

 

Whirlwind needs a drinking buddy

 

sorry for the bad drawing near the end I kinda rushed as my sholder pain started to come back.

 

so let me know which one you like best . I'm now gonna gonna wait for these pain killers to kick in.

Edited October 21, 2012 by PonyEcho

[Motion Spark 7,807]

I definitely prefer the light blue mane, it fits better his name "Whirlwind". Lol at the pic when he's playing with the twilight sparkle toy, so cute

[PonyEcho 1,610]

I definitely prefer the light blue mane, it fits better his name "Whirlwind". Lol at the pic when he's playing with the twilight sparkle toy, so cute

 

glad you like it, I always take a toy with me when i go out drinking because I know that my sound sad but i get board and it makes me stand out more and it does get girls coming to me (Twilight is best wingman ) so i though i'd make my OC the same.

[Twilight_Scratch 13]

Both excellent but i prefer number 2. The different colours add depth to the work. I like the pencil crayon look. Heres my 100 characters

[Appleja©k 31]

I think that the light blue mane is better. Unlike the gray mane, which sticks out, the blue one blends in and looks pretty cool.

[PonyEcho 1,610]

thanks for you're opinions so far.

also iv'e kinda made it easy for you to make the 100 character limit because you can voice you opinion on the color then criticize each image if you like.

this is why i have a rule to post five images whenever i make one of these threads, just saying.

[PoisonClaw 8,166]

I'd say the gray mane is better. The blue one almost seems to blend in to the point of being indistinguishable from his coat color, while the gray one has the opposite effect.

[BronyDerp117 113]

I like the gray mane better. It seems to give it more depth, or I dunno, I guess I just think it looks better. The grey against the blue looks good.

[Ghosted 18]

Of course both of these drawing are AMAZING (And better than anything I could even imagine doing), but if I had to choose, I would go with the light blue mane one. It fits the character as a younger colt or something. If you were to use the grey mane, you could make it an elderly one (not elderly as much as has-years-under-his-belt, you know?) Just some ideas and my honest thoughts!

 

Keep up the fantastic work!