MLP Forums Best Fan Tournament - Mane 6 (Results)

[XUNUSEDXXX 3,459]

@@Champion RD92, 

 

Can you make the tournament so that if someone votes for a fan, they have to give 1-3 reasons for why he/she is superior in fan-ness over the others? I'm fine if people nominate Spazzy or someone else with a good reason, but if they only nominate the other fans because they knew them longer or better or because they're friends, it's blatant favoritism and I wouldn't really appreciate that. 

 

I agree with derpyfan for once O_o

 

I would love it if this happened so people don't blindly vote for certain people.

 

Possible no pole, but have the votes based on how many post votes the person gets?

 

The only problem I see with this is that people would be typing WAY too much for one post since they have to gives reasons as to why they voted for EACH person for EACH pony.

[Wubsie 1,123]

@@Champion RD92, 

 

Can you make the tournament so that if someone votes for a fan, they have to give 1-3 reasons for why he/she is superior in fan-ness over the others? I'm fine if people nominate Spazzy or someone else with a good reason, but if they only nominate the other fans because they knew them longer or better or because they're friends, it's blatant favoritism and I wouldn't really appreciate that. 

I agree with this.

But I don't think we should write an essay on why it's our opinion. Just a short summary.

Ex: I nominate Clarity for best AJ fan because she is loyal and shows her love about AJ all over the forums, defending her until the very end. 

Something short and simple like that. Just my two cents. c:

EDIT: I'm going to now copy that reason and put it into my earlier post now...

Edited January 18, 2013 by ~Wubs~

[Gone Airbourne 21,977]

Yeah I agree too it is hard to just narrow it down to just certain users.... These kinds of tournaments are fun and all but tough at deciding. xD I usually count myself out of these kinds of things . 

Edited January 18, 2013 by Gone ϟ Airbourne

[Bari 7,023]

I would like to nominate myself for best Bon Bon fan. I can do that, right? Cause that would be swell. I'm basically the only one who cares about her, yet she is a popular pony I'd say.

 

Derpy: Haven

 

I honestly can't think of anyone else to pick. I'm drawing a blank here....

 

Edit: I reevaluated my choices.

Edited January 18, 2013 by Bari

[Otter 1,942]

I'm giving Clarity a nomination along with Spazzy because she's a whiny baby because they're both amazing fans of AJ, and it wouldn't be fair to exclude either of them.

[Starshine 16,333]

Hm... So I get to nominate one person for each poni?

 

Rainbow Dash > DashForever (He likes Rainbow Dash way too much)

 

Twilight Sparkle > Twiliscael (He is the one our Purple Smart deserves)

 

Pinkie Pie > Urdnot Pinkie Pie (He is often seen going around to defend his love to the Party Pink, that alone is enough reason for this)

 

Rarity > Lady Rarity Pony (nuff said)

 

Fluttershy > Zoop (all hail the master fan! (╯°□°）╯)

 

Applejack > null, I think I'll go abstain on this one

 

Luna > Thereisnospoon330 (or is it 303? I forgot. Either way, this guy can use some moonbutt)

 

Discord > That new admin guy (do you really need a freakin reason?)

 

Derpy > TGAP Haven (The only thing that prevents him from going all fanatic on derpy is because he's not crazy)

 

Lyra > Jinx (Lyra avatar and everything!)

 

Bon Bon > Bari (He is the only one here with Bonnie as an avatar!)

 

Scootaloo > Scootabloom (Everything about him radiates Scootaloo)

 

Trixie > Tom the Rock (Was there ever any doubt?)

Edited January 18, 2013 by Starshine

[XUNUSEDXXX 3,459]

I would like to nominate SBB64 for best Rarity fan and/or Sweetie Belle fan.

 

Also, I nominate Alfonzo Dennard for best Pinkie Pie fan.

Trixie > Tom the Rock (Was there ever any doubt?)

Brohoof for the fact that you mentioned me as best Scoots fan, but even more so of a brohoof for almost making me spit out my water in laughter!

[Starshine 16,333]

Say, will there be a Diamond Tiara fan or maybe Blueblood fan?

 

Brohoof for the fact that you mentioned me as best Scoots fan, but even more so of a brohoof for almost making me spit out my water in laughter!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2hsx9xGY9bc

 

He deserves to be called Trixie's biggest fan. Well, after Sethisto maybe.

[~Lawful Sturdy Wing~ 522]

I would like to nominate Eljordo for the best Rainbow Dash fan, seeing as he IS president of the Rainbow Dash fanclub and all.

[Lightning Fluttershy 1,844]

Well, I'm going to out on a limb here and nominate Harmonic Revelations for best Celestia fan and Clarity for best Derpy fan.

 

EDIT: didn't realize HR had already been nominated.

Edited January 18, 2013 by Lightning Fluttershy

[spas-ticShotty 3,584]

Hm... So I get to nominate one person for each poni?

 

Rainbow Dash > DashForever (He likes Rainbow Dash way too much)

 

Twilight Sparkle > Twiliscael (He is the one our Purple Smart deserves)

 

Pinkie Pie > Urdnot Pinkie Pie (He is often seen going around to defend his love to the Party Pink, that alone is enough reason for this)

 

Rarity > Lady Rarity Pony (nuff said)

 

Fluttershy > Zoop (all hail the master fan! (╯°□°）╯)

 

Applejack > null, I think I'll go abstain on this one

 

Luna > Thereisnospoon330 (or is it 303? I forgot. Either way, this guy can use some moonbutt)

 

Discord > That new admin guy (do you really need a freakin reason?)

 

Derpy > TGAP Haven (The only thing that prevents him from going all fanatic on derpy is because he's not crazy)

 

Lyra > Jinx (Lyra avatar and everything!)

 

Bon Bon > Bari (He is the only one here with Bonnie as an avatar!)

 

Scootaloo > Scootabloom (Everything about him radiates Scootaloo)

 

Trixie > Tom the Rock (Was there ever any doubt?)

Good call .

 

 

Well, I'm going to out on a limb here and nominate Harmonic Revelations for best Celestia fan and Clarity for best Derpy fan.

 

EDIT: didn't realize HR had already been nominated.

.........you don't want her to bring on the rain to you. The shotgun rain. It's gonna hurt :s.

 

I dunno who else to nominate. I'm just gonna sit back and watch everything from the sidlines.....

[Champion RD92 8,658]

Guys, a lot of you are nominating people who are already nominated. Make sure you look at who's nominated already.

 

 

 

@@Champion RD92,

 

We going to have an end date? Dates for when the nominees get voted on, and ultimately decide who is best fan for each character?

 

I tend to temporarily pin tournament topics made for the community so that they get their required attention to the utmost, but I also want to make sure this thing is all set on it's way ^^ I didn't see the OP containing that information. Unless I missed it.

 

I'm not sure when exactly I want to start the voting. I want to make sure each pony has at least a couple nominees first.

 

@@Champion RD92, 

 

Can you make the tournament so that if someone votes for a fan, they have to give 1-3 reasons for why he/she is superior in fan-ness over the others? I'm fine if people nominate Spazzy or someone else with a good reason, but if they only nominate the other fans because they knew them longer or better or because they're friends, it's blatant favoritism and I wouldn't really appreciate that. 

 

Do you mean for nominating people or for the actual voting?

 

I agree with derpyfan for once O_o

 

I would love it if this happened so people don't blindly vote for certain people.

 

Possible no pole, but have the votes based on how many post votes the person gets?

 

The only problem I see with this is that people would be typing WAY too much for one post since they have to gives reasons as to why they voted for EACH person for EACH pony.

 

I am planning on using a poll for voting. Having it based on "post votes" seems like too much work for the voters because they would have to type out posts for everyone they want to vote for.

[XUNUSEDXXX 3,459]

I am planning on using a poll for voting. Having it based on "post votes" seems like too much work for the voters because they would have to type out posts for everyone they want to vote for.

 

Fair enough.

 

I think you should start the voting maybe tomorrow or the day after when you've had the chance to get at least 2-3 members for each character.

[Champion RD92 8,658]

 

Fair enough.

 

I think you should start the voting maybe tomorrow or the day after when you've had the chance to get at least 2-3 members for each character.

 

The voting will most likely begin tomorrow. 

 

I will have a poll for each pony with all of the nominees listed, and then people will vote for who they think is best fan.

[Starshine 16,333]

Guys, a lot of you are nominating people who are already nominated. Make sure you look at who's nominated already.

Bari doesn't want to be nominated for Pinkie Pie, he said it himself that he wants the Bon Bon poni. Someone sabotaged him and nominated him to other poni first

[Champion RD92 8,658]

Bari doesn't want to be nominated for Pinkie Pie, he said it himself that he wants the Bon Bon poni. Someone sabotaged him and nominated him to other poni first

 

Unless there are more Bon Bon nominations, I can't have Bari nominated for Bon Bon. Obviously there can't only be one person, because then they would win automatically and there would be no point. I will add Bon Bon though for now.

[XUNUSEDXXX 3,459]

I also nominate EpicMuffinTime for best Derpy fan. Don't know him well personally, but I've seen him with a Derpy avvy and sig.

[Sks_Burns 730]

are we allowed to nominate ourselves, or is this a proper voting system? would there even be anyone to run against me for Flitter's #1? i might not be able to get in on this if thats the case. 

 

im still her self-proclaimed #1 fan though lol. 

[XUNUSEDXXX 3,459]

are we allowed to nominate ourselves, or is this a proper voting system? would there even be anyone to run against me for Flitter's #1? i might not be able to get in on this if thats the case. 

 

im still her self-proclaimed #1 fan though lol. 

 

I don't think that Flitter has a huge fanbase, especially on this forum, so I don't think that RD92 will add Flitter to the list.

[Starshine 16,333]

Unless there are more Bon Bon nominations, I can't have Bari nominated for Bon Bon. Obviously there can't only be one person, because then they would win automatically and there would be no point. I will add Bon Bon though for now.

Aw shucks. I guess the same thing also applies to Spitfire and Spike then?

There is no vocal Bon Bon fan in this forum other than Bari (that I know of)

[Champion RD92 8,658]

All right, I just had an idea.

 

There's going to be 2 rounds of voting. Whichever two people receive the most votes in the first round, will go to the final round.

 

So the final round will be a face-off between the top two contestants for each pony.

 

What do you guys think of this idea?

[XUNUSEDXXX 3,459]

All right, I just had an idea.

 

There's going to be 2 rounds of voting. Whichever two people receive the most votes in the first round, will go to the final round.

 

So the final round will be a face-off between the top two contestants for each pony.

 

What do you guys think of this idea?

 

I guess that would work, similar to a bracket setup.

 

You would have to find at least 3+ fans for each pony to make that work.

 

Also, I nominate MatrixChicken for Scootaloo fan. The more the better. :3

 

EDIT: I actually recall my suggestion. Since this isn't set up as this pony vs this pony or anything, I think one voting in total could do.

Edited January 18, 2013 by Scootabloom

[Lightning Fluttershy 1,844]

All right, I just had an idea.

 

There's going to be 2 rounds of voting. Whichever two people receive the most votes in the first round, will go to the final round.

 

So the final round will be a face-off between the top two contestants for each pony.

 

What do you guys think of this idea?

I like that idea, but what about ponies who say have only 2 or 3 nominees? Would they have only one round of voting or would they simply not be included?

[Wubsie 1,123]

I wonder if enough people vote for me Vinyl will get up there.

My little puppets...dance! DANCE!

Post nao and make me the best Vinyl fan! >:3

[XUNUSEDXXX 3,459]

(Also, you could use Scootacool's original name if you want, but technically his display name ATM is Key Gear, if you want to be official)