What would Assertive Fluttershy say to Twilight, Rainbow and AppleJack

[TheMarkz0ne 962]

What would she say. This is honestly one of the highlights of the series for me. Because Fluttershy ISN'T being manipulated. She is assertive and isn't holding back how she feels her friends are flawed. Flutters is a interesting character. She represents kindness, but clearly is flawed because she isn't being kind to her friends. But I agree with Fluttershy with her opinions on Pinkie and Rarity. Don't get me wrong what Fluttershy did was wrong. But it seems she is speaking the truth.

 

What would she say to the other three. I think this is what would happen

 

Twilight: She would snap at Twilight and ridicule her for being a suck up to Princess Celestia. She would also mock her love of reading books. She would also say that Twilight is unstable and let's her goals cloud her judgement of others. Twilight wouldn't cry, she'd get angry and defensive

 

Rainbow Dash: Would insult her for trying to follow her dreams of becoming a wonder bolt. Flutters seems capable of good vocabulary. She would throw words at Rainbow like..Complacent, calus,one track minded, overly adamant and a show off. She would also say her dream is nothing more than a cry for attention and she would say Rainbow fears not being renowned in society. Rainbow would be shocked, most likely wouldn't say a word. She wouldn't be angry, she be upset that her friend is saying this to her

 

 

Apple Jack: Would say she is to wrapped up into working and is living a life of mediocrity and emptiness. Apple Jack would more angrier than Twilight, most likely try to buck Flutters in the head

Edited May 5, 2013 by TheMarkz0ne

[Somebody 570]

Fortunately it didn't go that far in the show. Granted, her saying all those things would have an element of truth to them, but those words would so broadly encompass everyone, it would probably even hurt the viewer's feelings. I know I would feel that way.
 
Going that far would probably make us lose faith in her, and just change our opinions of her. We might have just considered her nothing more than a repressed bitch after that...
 
...Also this may be relevant:

 

http://dnftt2011.deviantart.com/art/Funny-Fanmade-MLP-gif-346379447

Edited May 5, 2013 by Questio and Ashling

[Winona the Dog 1,984]

I'm pretty sure the mane 6 is aware of each others flaw but they don't go far enough to insult them about it like Fluttershy did here. I think this scene would be more impactful if Fluttershy criticized the rest of them but then again Applejack and Rainbow Dash are known for not standing there and taking that kind of trash talk from Fluttershy. Heck i think RD would've rebuked against Fluttershy or something. 

[Sugar Cube 4,843]

Well, one thing is for sure, whatever nasty thing "New Fluttershy" would say to those three, they wouldn't run off crying like Pinkie Pie and Rarity did. They'd be completely shocked and speechless, but not to the point of crying and running away.

Edited May 5, 2013 by Sugar Cube