Just thought of something from magical mystery cure

[FNGRpony 658]

Star swirl the bearded's spell he never finished.  the one that basically swapped everyone around or rather their cutie marks.

 

I just occured to me imagine the damage that spell did if he never finished how to complete it if he tried using it as twilight had.

I'm assuming this was the 1000 years ago period where all hell has broken lose

discord is possibly lose

sombre is wrecking shop

luna is banished to the moon,

and now star swirl the bearded in all likely hood has just screwed up what i would assume

an elite fallowing of ponies likely near to princess celestail and is unable to fix the problem.

 

oups mis spelled cure in the title sorry about that.

Edited September 19, 2013 by FNGRpony

[Sunny Fox 5,952]

This thread appears to be discussing MLP:FiM in some way, shape or form. Thus, it has been sentenced to Show Discussion.

 

This is an automatically generated message, by the way.

[Planty 1,053]

Hmm, interesting Idea.

 

The only people it could effect are Luna and Celestia as they where the previous owners of the elements, I guess this could be an added reason for Luna's annoyance at the ponies not liking night? (she originally managed the day).

 

Thats presuming, the spell was used.

[Sunny Fox 5,952]

Luna only became Nightmare Moon after Discord was turned to stone ("After discovering the Elements of Harmony, we [Luna and I] combined our powers and rose up against him, turning him to stone.") and Sombra was beaten before NNM too (since we see both Princesses laying the beat down on Sombra)

PS - Fixed the title for you.

Edited September 19, 2013 by Full Spectrum

[FNGRpony 658]

Luna only became Nightmare Moon after Discord was turned to stone ("After discovering the Elements of Harmony, we [Luna and I] combined our powers and rose up against him, turning him to stone.") and Sombra was beaten before NNM too (since we see both Princesses laying the beat down on Sombra)

bscap0151.jpg

PS - Fixed the title for you.

 

 

well i'm not assuming they all happened on the same year (even if that's cannon lol i think that would be strange that so much crap happened in such a short time).

 

i think it's one of the writers nitches to say everything happened "1000 years ago!"

you know.. during the suck age when every thing bad that ever happened, did and often.

[Planty 1,053]

@, I'm not really sure what your saying (you kinda said a fact and didn't state anything :x)

 

I'm not sure if we have an age on Star Swirl, that would allow us to accurately put him in the history but is Luna can remember him then he was before NMM at least so he could have been around any time after that .

[Frith is Magick 1,471]

From what I have seen, we are not give a specific timeline on Star Swirl the Bearded or any of the other villains (except Nightmare Moon). 1000 years could be around 1990 years or even 1010 years rounded for simplicity, giving us 20 (possibly more) years in which these events could have occurred. Secondly, it is never stated that Star Swirl caused unimaginable Chaos, just that he could not get the spell right, meaning he either deduced based on magical theory that it wouldn't work, or simply used a small a small number of test subjects. Seeing as magic is very scientific in Equestria, both of these are possible. Also, this spell only worked among the Mane 6, meaning the spell only works in a small radius or only affects close friends, both of these are reasons that this spell could not have caused any significant chaos. Even if any of Star Swirl's spells went wrong, he strikes me as the type to take damage control measures. I think it is safe to say he was not a contributor to the problems of the Age of Chaos (made that term up on the spot).

 

When I posted this, it had been a while since I had seen the episode, but having just watched it, I would like to add to what I wrote. The spell affected the Elements of Harmony (which were right beside Twilight Sparkle). When Star Swirl was working on the spell, he either would not of had access to the Elements to preform the spell, and even if he did, it wouldn't matter. The spell switched the Elements, but in Star Swirl's time, only two ponies wielded the Elements. Luna and Celestia were not connected to the EoH the way the Mane 6 were, meaning it would have had no serious impact on the world.

Edited September 23, 2013 by Frith is Magik

[FNGRpony 658]

From what I have seen, we are not give a specific timeline on Star Swirl the Bearded or any of the other villains (except Nightmare Moon). 1000 years could be around 1990 years or even 1010 years rounded for simplicity, giving us 20 (possibly more) years in which these events could have occurred. Secondly, it is never stated that Star Swirl caused unimaginable Chaos, just that he could not get the spell right, meaning he either deduced based on magical theory that it wouldn't work, or simply used a small a small number of test subjects. Seeing as magic is very scientific in Equestria, both of these are possible. Also, this spell only worked among the Mane 6, meaning the spell only works in a small radius or only affects close friends, both of these are reasons that this spell could not have caused any significant chaos. Even if any of Star Swirl's spells went wrong, he strikes me as the type to take damage control measures. I think it is safe to say he was not a contributor to the problems of the Age of Chaos (made that term up on the spot).

 

 

Hay age of chaos fits better than "THE SUCK YEARS." as I refer to them lol.

and taking measures  and damage control to a cold hard thinking analytical mind,

you make it sound like your suggesting he did something drastic if he did use the spell.

 

Which gets me even more curious to what that might been ^^