Jump to content
Banner by ~ Wizard
Guidelines
  • entries
    363
  • comments
    1,100
  • views
    271,024

"MLP Forums" logo review

Dark Qiviut

Entry posted by Dark Qiviut

4,168 views

 Share

mlp-forums-logo_zpsda8b6991.png

 

When entering the MLP Forums, one of the first things you see is the logo on top. The rounded letters, playful positioning of the typeface, and quirkiness of how the logo is placed and played with. Every banner has the MLP Forums logo somewhere, and it easily makes the MLP Forums look recognizable not merely as a forum, but as a brand. Feld0 has stated occasionally here that he treats this forum as such because the way the forum is designed and the thread titles are typed. But the logo itself is the centerpiece of the brand. Logos give a first impression to the audience what the atmosphere of the brand is; the MLP Forums logo is the leading, and personally most important, piece of the forum's brand.

 

The MLP Forums logo, given by the typefaces themselves, represent relaxation, casualness, and fun. "MLP" in the MLP Forums is the Cheeseburger typeface. My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic succeeds in capturing the whimsical, fun atmosphere and colors of the animation. The background designs aren't always organic. They're crazy and fun. Cheeseburger's anatomy is playful and casual, just like the show itself. In addition, the approach to reading it is comfortable. However, the kerning (the space in between tow characters) in between the "L" and "P" is a little too tight; look at the closest space between the "M" and "L" and compare it to the "L" and "P." You'll notice that the "M" and "L" are a little tighter. A recommendation is to nudge the "L" to the right slightly to make the kerning more optically even.

 

"Forums" is typed in the typeface called "Gilligan's Island." Just like "MLP" in the "MLP Forums," the font is playful and casual despite its usages of serifs (which translates into a level of elegance on impression).

 

But while it supposed to come across as playful, it doesn't mean that's what the results translate to. There are three big problems with it that bog down its message.

  • The kerning is lousy. While the kerning in "MLP" merely needs some adjusting, "Forums" is overlooked, particularly two places.
    • The first location is the space between the "o" and "r." Compared to the other subsequent pairs, the spacing is too tight, almost touching.
    • The spacing between the "F" and "o" are completely the opposite. There's WAY too much space between the two letters. If you put "MLP Forums" side by side, then instead of "MLP Forums," the kerning between the "F" and "o" makes the logo read as"MLP F Orums." The "F" is stranded on an island, and that's NOT how good logos make.

    [*]The font is fighting with the "MLP" half. As a logo designer, it's important that you want to send an impression to your audience. Sometimes, you want to incorporate as many messages as you can. Truly successful logos do NOT do that. They take one central idea and go along with it; extra smaller messages come naturally. Simplicity is key. Based on the weight of the CheeseBurger typeface and positioning of the stacked logo, it's obvious that "MLP" is the main focus and "Forums" is secondary. But both fonts are trying to carry the same message regarding in how the typefaces are designed, and that's too much. This is why I have the MLP Forums logo on top in black rather than fuchsia; it forces you to review the logo from a design perspective.

    [*]The font, Gilligan's Island, is a very poor typeface of choice. The first time I saw the "Forums" part of that logo, I seriously compared it to this typeface.

     

    ComicSans.gif

     

    Many of you might recognize it, but for those who don't, this is Comic Sans, a sans-serif computer typeface designed to replicate the casual, fun, comic-like personality of childlike typefaces. However, this font isn't very good for several reasons.

     

    1. It comes across as forced. Instead of playful, it's mechanical and dull.

     

    2. It's extremely difficult to borderline-impossible to adjust the kerning and tracking of the characters to make the text comfortable to read. The characters and numbers are designed so poorly that no matter how much you try to adjust the spacing, characters tend to stick out on an island.

     

    3. The structure of the letterforms are inconsistent. No two are ever the same, and that makes the font an even bigger pain to read.

     

    4. It's easily recognizable based off its anatomy and shape. This is completely opposite to what typefaces should do. A typeface's purpose is to make the font look comfortable, quiet, and blended in. Stick out, and it makes people question your design skills.

     

    5. There are too many little pieces of detail in the typeface. Keep the font simple; too much is overkill.

     

    Compared to Cheeseburger, Gilligan's Island has little consistent structure in both the uppercase and lowercase characters. It tries to come off as playful and fun, but the poor anatomy of the characters is forced. It's inorganic. Take a look at the font page, and you'll see how some of the uppercase letters are also used as lowercase.

     

    And suffice it to say, the font is out of character of My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic. When looking at the background settings and the way the characters are drawn, they're designed to be simple in shape, but recognizable as those creatures in design. Besides the hair, tail, muzzle, and eyes, a pony's anatomy is consisted of several circles, eight rectangles, one square, and one triangle merging with each other. Zoom in at the actual characters in the Gilligan's Island typeface, and you notice so many extracurricular details in the characters. It contradicts the simplicity of the Friendship Is Magic universe and anatomy of the ponies themselves.

What I suggest to improve the logo are as follows:

 

1. Adjust the kerning in the "L" for "MLP." Nudge the "L" a little to the right to make the space more even proportionally.

 

2. Ditch the Gilligan's Island for a completely new typeface. One that is organic, simple, and conservative. "MLP" is its strong suit, and the current font is fighting with "MLP." You want a balance, yet have "MLP" be its focal point in the logo. My suggestion is to use a typeface that's geometric, simple, and much lighter in weight, either one you can find or self-designed; and several examples are located here. Sans serif or serif is up to you, but I'm more inclined to sans-serif for two reasons:

 

a. This is an Internet-based forum, and studies have shown that people tend to read sans serif on the computer better than serif typefaces.

 

b. We're in an era where simplicity in logo designing is crucial to instant recognition, as the classic logos like the CBS eye, Nike's swoosh, and NBC's peacock. Despite some classic logos like Futura, Univers, and Helvetica being several decades old, sans serif fonts are still relatively new in the world of typography.

The MLP Forums established themselves as not just a forum discussing My Little Pony, but a brand within the fandom, too. Instantly, whenever someone sees this logo, it is instantly recognizable. With refinement, the MLP Forums logo can stand out as an even better brand with an ever greater logo.

  • Brohoof 7
 Share

4 Comments

Recommended Comments

Bohtty

You make some fine points, but you over emphasize how much the "brand" plays into this forum. A brand works as an identity to the outside world, however MLP Forums is mostly contained within this domain. It doesn't visit the outside world much. 

 

Also Comic Sans is a bad font choice because it was over used and used incorrectly. Otherwise the font is fine when used for what it was made for.

 

Also why would you put it in #000 black. You should have put it in #333. Talking about design too, tsk tsk.

  • Brohoof 1
Link to comment
Dark Qiviut

@@Bohtty, Regardless of whether the MLP Forums's audience is targeted or not, the MLP Forums really focuses a lot on the branding aspect. The head staff here really focus a lot on impressions and how they can communicate to bronies who aren't big forum-goers. To people like Scootacool and Feld0, first impressions really mean a lot to them. The logo creates an impression to bronies and non-bronies alike.

 

To call Comic Sans a bad font for that reason isn't very good at all. I'm focusing on the typographical anatomy itself. Comic Sans has no soul and is very difficult to read well with perfect kerning. Unlike fonts like Marker Felt, It has no consistent structure in typographic anatomy.

 

 

Also why would you put it in #000 black.

 

When you have the entire logo in perfect black, it forces you to review the logo's composition, which is the clear foundation to any great logo. If you put it in any other color, it communicates to the designer that you have to alter the chroma, saturation, value, or hue, somewhere to make it more appealing. Black is a perfectly neutral and bold color, so your mind isn't fooled. Once you get the composition down, then add color. It's a huge trick to any logo designing.

Link to comment
  • Founder
Twilight Sparkle ✨
  • Founder

Hey DQ,

 

I just stumbled across this blog entry, and I have to say that I wish I saw it sooner! :o You should've posted it as a feedback topic.

 

Just want to say that I really appreciate your analysis of our logo and I'll definitely bring this entry up internally for review. Incidentally, I've been thinking of getting a new logo designed, because, as you pointed out, branding is pretty important these days - and it's only going to get more important with my upcoming plans to expand the community in the not-too-distant future.

  • Brohoof 2
Link to comment
Unikitty

The only aspect of this logo that I find to be a nuisance is the kerning between the F and O. It does stand out, and is a little bit of an eyesore.
I quite like the font choices.

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Join the herd!

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...