Jump to content
Banner by ~ Ice Princess Silky
  • entries
    55
  • comments
    207
  • views
    26,370

Keeping Calm: Fluttershy, Discord, and Q


Wingnut

1,428 views

Now that I've had a week to reflect on Keep Calm and Flutter On, I have a few more things to say. Fluttershy was truly amazing. She was already my favorite pony, but she showed faith and perseverance I didn't think she was capable of. Keep Calm and Flutter On is the first time I have seen Princess Celestia give a Mane 6 pony besides Twilight a major individual assignment. Fluttershy didn't let her down either by displaying a Twilight Sparkle-like diligence and commitment to carrying out her task. The quiet pegasus wasn't born yesterday and she knows all along what Discord is up to. She pulls off the acting job of the series, fooling Discord and own her friends, by pretending she's gullible and naive. The best part comes near the end. Attempting to turn Discord good appears to be a lost cause and Fluttershy has every reason to blast Discord back into stone. She's angry, miserable, and so sick of his shenanigans. Discord is just begging for it, but at the moment of truth she throws her element away. Without a doubt, Fluttershy is the most stubborn persistent pony I have seen since...Applejack! Three seasons in, we're beginning to see some of the ponies' best traits rub off on each other. smile.png

 

Nonetheless, it was a huge gamble by Fluttershy. If Discord didn't have a change of heart, she would've taken the blame for allowing him to go and spread chaos all over Equestria. But speaking of Discord, I still don't totally understand him. He's loosely based on Q from Star Trek: The Next Generation. Q is just one member of a body called the Continuum which has a serious purpose for maintaining balance in the universe. Q also seems omnipotent except for whatever restrictions the Continuum is placing on him at the moment. He has potentially limitless power over space, time, and matter. But one thing I don't think Q has ever done is read somebody's mind. He can see the synapses firing and even the molecules that make up an organism's brain, but he lacks the ability to interpret that information. This allows the Star Trek crew to outwit him. I personally think this is a restriction imposed by the Continuum.

 

I get the reason for Discord's existence: You can't have light without darkness, order without chaos, harmony without discord. Discord was the best villain of the series even though he lacks the heart of an evildoer. He is more like a force of nature. But he's not a “balanced” force like Q is due to Continuum policies. His innate predisposition is to create disorder and the only clear counterweight to that is the embodiment of harmony, the Mane 6. Time will tell whether that is enough to keep him out of trouble. Curiously, like Q, Discord can't read minds. Otherwise, he would have known the "kindness" Fluttershy was giving him wasn't totally sincere. I get why some people are opposed to Discord losing his villain status and I imagine some Trekkies didn't like it at the time when Q ceased being a clear cut threat. Q, and John de Lancie himself, have gone on to become legends in the Star Trek fandom. So I will give the MLP crew a chance to play this story out before passing judgment.

 

A funny footnote: The brief episode description provided by my digital cable box says “Princess Celestia wants the ponies to tame Discord but Fluttershy is opposed.” Where did they get the idea Fluttershy was against it? tongue.png

  • Brohoof 3

5 Comments


Recommended Comments

Keep Calm And Flutter On was an episode I felt... meh about, but you provide an interesting perspective on it, albeit one that makes Fluttershy sound kind of insincere and cold. I thought that it was her idealism and hope for Discord that kept her still working to be his friend; she storms away from Discord because he just kept abusing her kindness over and over and over again.

 

She succeeded in the end because, despite all of the absolutely terrible treatment that Discord gave her, she still tried to make him comfortable and keep her promises for him even when she really didn't want to ("I guess when you're friends, you can't always have things exactly your way all the time").

 

That's why Princess Celestia believed that it was Fluttershy, element of kindness, who could do the job, because only Fluttershy would really be able to show Discord kindness at his worst. 

 

...Wow, I think I like this episode more now.

  • Brohoof 1
Link to comment

 

but you provide an interesting perspective on it, albeit one that makes Fluttershy sound kind of insincere and cold.

 

Hmm.  I'm starting to second guess how I wrote that.  It's hard for me to believe that Fluttershy could give Discord 100% of her sincere kindness while being aware in the back of her mind he's a "big dumb meanie" who wants to plunge Equestria into total turmoil.  I don't know how both of those could coexist in Fluttershy's head.  But maybe she's the one pony who could pull that off? 

  • Brohoof 1
Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Join the herd!

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...