Jump to content
Banner by ~ Ice Princess Silky

Them's Seeing Ponies

User
  • Posts

    223
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Status Replies posted by Them's Seeing Ponies

  1. Five years ago Cutie Remark aired

    Five years later it still sucks

    1. Them's Seeing Ponies

      Them's Seeing Ponies

      Amen. In particular, the episode's dour tone always came off as absurd and credibility-undermining to me in light of the fundamentally fanservice-laden nature of the plot (given that over two-thirds of the runtime is essentially consumed by Twilight and Spike visiting 'parallel universes' resembling lame fanfiction over progressing any form of point beyond the bizarrely deterministic focus on the M6's ability to effectively weaponize their friendship, which is oddly equated to a generic 'friendship is necessary' moral) essentially embodying the worst aspects of Meghan McCarthy's otherwise variably decent-to-good tenure.

    2. (See 8 other replies to this status update)

  2. Why do people pretend the original Thundercats and She-Ra were masterpieces? They were always mediocre toy commercials disguised as cartoons.

    Let's be real here: You only liked the original She-Ra, Thundercats, and all the other 80s toy commercial cartoons because you were a kid and didn't know any better.

    1. Them's Seeing Ponies

      Them's Seeing Ponies

      You're speaking as if these opinions are objective - while a number of 'fans' of both shows may be largely dictated by their own nostalgia in 'positively' reviewing the show, I wouldn't automatically assume that this indicates a dearth of people who enjoy them on their own terms, which both shows, given their relatively low narrative ambitions, actually achieve reasonably well (particularly given that both shows, if you've seen enough '80s animation, were far from the worst in the toyline-plugging category - Charmkins? Potato Head Kids? MoonDreamers? That weird Ruby-Spears show about the Rubiks Cube?), although the proportion is likely numerically lower than the fanbase for the more recent show.

    2. (See 1 other reply to this status update)

  3. Apparently (Scoob spoilers)…

    Spoiler

    the movie tried to be this starter for a mass Warner Bros/Hanna Barbera universe, but ultimately failed in doing it without trying to be lazy.

     

    1. Them's Seeing Ponies

      Them's Seeing Ponies

      An Avengers rip-off featuring the Flintstones in particular would be golden for all the wrong reasons.

    2. (See 4 other replies to this status update)

  4. Apparently (Scoob spoilers)…

    Spoiler

    the movie tried to be this starter for a mass Warner Bros/Hanna Barbera universe, but ultimately failed in doing it without trying to be lazy.

     

    1. Them's Seeing Ponies

      Them's Seeing Ponies

      The conceit of a 'Hanna-Barbera expanded universe' itself evokes more the air of a deliberately absurd parody of a cash-in on the success of Marvel than a legitimate film series which WB have presumably invested millions into. Definitely anticipating "Jabberjaw: Endgame" in ten years!

    2. (See 4 other replies to this status update)

  5. Some parts of Thomas & Friends/The Railway Series haven’t aged very well. One of them is how mean The Fat Controller was to James early in the series. James had an accident on his first day of the job, leading to a need to be repaired. Then when he came back, he accidentally let off a steam fart on TFC’s top hat and accidentally chugged with Edward too far off the platform. Mistakes like these do NOT warrant a threat to paint his proud red coat blue!

    1. Them's Seeing Ponies

      Them's Seeing Ponies

      I'm able to grant the Railway Series a degree of lenience in regards to TFC's sternness - if one considers the context that the earliest books were published during the mid-40s (when the UK were a leading imperial power which promoted order and authority of a stricter ilk than today, presumably in light of the harsh, winding road that was early 20th-century society), his behaviour was basically a product of its time; I can only assume it wasn't penned in a consistently critical light but as merely a 'fact of life' ("my doctor has forbidden me to push" notwithstanding), regardless of the unfortunate implications this dredges up seven decades in hindsight (and most likely beyond Awdry or the '40s readership's intent). In regards to flanderizing the motives for Henry's iconic tunnel fiasco into a legitimate phobia of rain merely in a desperate attempt to market him simplistically as 'the nervous one', however... I can't exactly forgive that with the same ease. 

    2. (See 4 other replies to this status update)

  6. image.png.b2c939c24a9031c3f7a0b0cf0e72252e.png

    1. Them's Seeing Ponies

      Them's Seeing Ponies

       I guess Hank's now fighting evil by moonlight and selling propane and propane accessories by daylight.

      You gotta hand it to Sailor...uh, Hill, though, he works for a livin', and I don't mean sittin' down writin' gobbledegook. 

    2. (See 1 other reply to this status update)

  7. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/trump-says-he-is-taking-hydroxychloroquine/

    For the love of christ I can't stress this enough. Please don't even think about taking medicine you don't need

  8. Some people are saying the new She-Ra, a show with actual character development, disrespects the legacy of the original She-Ra, which was a glorified toy commercial with bad animation.

    Nostalgia is a helluva drug.

    1. Them's Seeing Ponies

      Them's Seeing Ponies

      Because the new show has its own noticeable set of prominent faults (irritating characterization and garish anime-ersatz aesthetic among them) as well? It may feature more genuine narrative development and ambition than its toyetic predecessor, but I can understand why some may see it as such.

    2. (See 1 other reply to this status update)

  9. O_CUbUNWp-LpR_VzR3NV7tOGMf4=.gif

    1. Them's Seeing Ponies

      Them's Seeing Ponies

      Honestly, both the prequels and sequels fall short in different ways. The prequels contain far more compelling and ambitious themes and concepts enclosed in (almost laughably at times) incompetent filmmaking and lacklustre scripting (to the point of obstructing characterization), whereas the sequels are slicker and more structurally competent at executing filmmaking basics (such as recognizable plot structure, at least mostly) but feel homogenized (see also the extraneous fanservice in VII and IX and the overly obvious comedy than begins to eventually rear its head) and poorly planned - it's more watchable than the prequels, but somehow also more insidious. 

      C.E.D'oh was also... not good, but the Carl/Lenny gag in the gif above, while kind of overly illogical and easy, was easily one of the most memorable tidbits.

    2. (See 14 other replies to this status update)

  10. Looking at the scores for Rise of Skywalker.

    Star Wars is dead. Disney had the chance to revive the franchise after the prequels, and they blew it.

    1. Them's Seeing Ponies

      Them's Seeing Ponies

      Although I typically refrain from supporting judgement of a film based wholly upon word of mouth, I agree that the sequel trilogy in general has been a disappointing experience - they generally don't flounder with the basics of filmmaking to the extent of the prequels (which were often deeply inept in that regard, almost to a laughable extent at times) but feel far more soulless in the ilk of a McDonald's product - an entity with basic external competence but dominated by both corporate compromise and a lack of tangible desire to posit a genuine creative expression (Rian Johnson definitely appears enthusiastic in the behind-the-scenes footage, yet this only occasionally registers in the finished film, and is often poorly conceived atop this) so much as scrounge the maximum volume of cash from the audience - than even the prequels (which contained their own fair share of blatant marketing), hence the sequel trilogy's noticeable lack of worldbuilding comparable to its predecessors (yes, avoiding the politic-laden focus of the prequels was a valid move, but ignoring the background of the setting altogether (particularly when establishing the formation and position of the First Order, which the trilogy neglects visibly) is simply an exchange of one issue for another), lack of a clear through-line plot (the cause of the two films of radically differing setups we received) and fanservice (the majority of which is little more than a desperate plea to appease established fans regardless of how much the films attempt to masquerade them as 'symbolism' or some greater thematic cog). 

      I'm not claiming that the sequels lack redeeming value - both films contain a number of compelling isolated ideas and I understand aspects of Rian Johnson's intent in Last Jedi (despite his use of this ideology coming off as more of an excuse to dismantle the sequel hooks in Force Awakens and thus appear 'subversive' as opposed to fully convey the disappointment and smaller redeeming facets of warfare) but neither of the existing films work subjectively as more than fun one-time viewing (before you begin to realize their fatal flaws, whereas the prequels, while almost entirely unconcerned with plot structure or characterization over Lucas spontaneously dumping his ideas onto the screen in a confusing and convoluted mess, contain a far more interesting and ambitious set of themes which become more apparent outside the proximity of the subpar dialogue and oversaturated CGI). I can't say I have much hope for Rise of Skywalker either.

       

    2. (See 4 other replies to this status update)

  11. *chomps on E-carrot* Eeeeh, what’s up, doc?

    1. Them's Seeing Ponies

      Them's Seeing Ponies

      I'm honestly surprised that no one has compiled the full set of appearances of Bugs' idiosyncratic catchphrase in video form at this point. Understandably, watching the full filmography of 164 (I believe?) shorts in addition to the various modern reincarnations WB has attempted is no lean feat, but I assume it wouldn't be entirely un-enjoyable either. 

      Having viewed all 1000 of the original LT shorts as of this September (what has my life come to...?), Bugs' finest moments in general tend to stem from the mid-late '40s shorts, most notably gems such as "Easter Yeggs" ("it's the suspense that gets me!"), "Long-Haired Hare" and the 'all-out job' scatting dance from "Hot Cross Bunny" (not to mention the immortal "what a maroon!" retort, which has stuck with me through the years for some obscure reason). Ah yes, good times... contemplating on the 473 shorts remaining until the end of four long years. 

    2. (See 5 other replies to this status update)

  12. I'm not even into Fairly Odd Parents, and it boggles my mind just how BAD "It's a Wishful Life" truly is.

    1. Them's Seeing Ponies

      Them's Seeing Ponies

      FOP in general was begin to pass its prime by season 6, but the ultimate killing blows were personally the loss of Steve Marmel (in turn costing the show much of the sharper comedy of its earlier seasons, eventually culminating in... whatever the *** "Certified Super Sitter" was) and the ceaseless addition of new characters regardless of need or context (Sparky, anyone?), which, as one would expect, eventually leading to "It's a Wishful Life" almost seeming solid compared to the staggeringly incompetent final batch of episodes produced.

    2. (See 4 other replies to this status update)

  13. If you think about it, the concept of a pinata is horrifying. You beat an animal with a stick until its organs come out, and then you eat its organs.

    1. Them's Seeing Ponies

      Them's Seeing Ponies

      So we can then assume that Viva Pinata is basically a video game about maintaining your own inhumane animal plantation? 

    2. (See 1 other reply to this status update)

  14. Season 3 actually had quite a few episodes planned for Rarity, not just Spike At Your Service

    Spoiler

    Speaking of which, the original version with Rarity was there. And yeah, most of it would be spent on her being jealous that Spike is helping AJ and constantly tries to get him to do stuff for her as well. The rest of the stuff with Spike and AJ are there, but instead of the mane 6 trying to help AJ, it's just Rarity being mean to him

    We really did get the best version of that episode

    1. Them's Seeing Ponies

      Them's Seeing Ponies

      Spoiler

      Having read the premise as well... it basically did just sound akin to a prototypical version of Dragon Dropped  (although we would've at least been spared from the obnoxious meme faces of the latter episode) - I concur that the episode we received, while clunky in multiple ways, was an improvement (personally, I've never fully disliked SaYS in itself - it's a heavily flawed episode (particularly regarding Spike's characterization), yet the M6 themselves are well-characterized and resultantly receive some memorable comedic moments (Dash's fanfiction and the reactions to the rock tower in particular are golden)). As for the writers' preference towards Rarity, I suspect that their more stringent quality control towards her episodes (at least within the context of the show's initial crew) stemmed from her relatively subversive nature for a show of FiM's demographic in the early 2010s - prior to FiM, the majority of 'feminine' fashionista characters within girls' media tended to be shallow, unlikable archetypes, whereas Rarity is presented in a far stronger, more dignified and well-rounded way (at least once the crew finally determined how to use her character effectively circa Suited for Success) and I believe the crew themselves may have recognized (and acknowledged via their more 'regulated' treatment of her character premise-wise) this bucking of convention as a result. 

      Speaking of which, you may have also uncovered Merriwether William's dropped outline for a musical episode involving Twilight temporarily assuming Mayor Mare's place (the leaks actually indicate multiple episodes (including one planned for season 6 where, bizarrely, she rigged a general election to enable Discord to become the mayor of Ponyville, which ultimately leads him to plunge Equestria into eternal darkness... because someone asked for it) were planned for MM, all of which were canned early in production), with its rejection presumably explaining why she was reassigned to write SaYS's script - while the outline itself does contain some overly cheesy/obvious elements, it arguably would have enabled S3 to more effectively build towards placing Twilight in a permanent leadership capacity (and highlights the 'leadership qualities' Celestia claims her to have developed in MMC). 

       

    2. (See 3 other replies to this status update)

  15. Came out of work the other day to find this shit on my car. What the hell is this yellow gunk?

    8182FDEE-4C5D-460C-AABA-E781CDB5EFD5.jpeg

    1. Them's Seeing Ponies

      Them's Seeing Ponies

      Isn't bird urine typically gaseous? I doubt it would register on car paint as a result, although it's entirely possible it condensed upon the car's body if the surface was a lower temperature than the surrounding air. 

    2. (See 6 other replies to this status update)

  16. The one thing I can say for sure deserves hate in the 5th gen anime would be Ash's traveling companions Cilen and Iris.  They're so annoying! :yeahno:

    1. Them's Seeing Ponies

      Them's Seeing Ponies

      iris and Cilan were effectively poor-man's renditions of Misty and Brock whom the writers mistakenly married to irritating running gags (Iris's repetitious reactions to Ash being "such a kid", which reached a saturation point ten episodes into the Best Wishes run, and Cilan inexplicably qualifying as the connoisseur of numerous mundane items despite the show never pushing the gag far enough to hit a comedic sweet spot (they should've simply rolled with him declaring himself the connoisseur of dryer lint or mud, which would have subjectively been more successfully amusing)) to the effect of costing them more well-rounded individual characters. Of course, there are definitely other aspects of BW deserving of disdain personally (Ash being reset to an incompetent novice, the overload of underdeveloped 'mons, Meowth briefly travelling with the protagonist and introducing a unique and interesting group chemistry only to drop the conceit a mere four episodes later, Ash, a trainer of technically extensive experience/achievement, being defeated by a moronic plot utility in the regional league, Team Plasma being watered down, the Team Rocket trio being surgically stripped of their individual personalities in 'compensation' for their initial increased competence, Charizard serving minimal purpose other than shallow fanservice and the wasteful Decolora arc) but I fully understand your opinion.  

  17. A rejected episode for S4

    Spoiler

    Season 4 really wanted to use Rainbow Falls a lot. Rainbow Falls was supposed to be the source of rainbows in Cloudsdale and there's a crystal that makes it produce the colors, and it's running out and a new crystal is available in the Crystal Empire. There's a special way to handle the crystal, but Rainbow/Twilight(either or, the premise and outline features one or the other) get excited and simply skim everything. Of course this goes wrong and de-rainbows their friends and makes them extreme versions of themselves. And Twilight/Rainbow would have had to find a way to make everything right

    This sounds like it could have been fun, but there were some weird things happening that would need to be reworked

    1. Them's Seeing Ponies

      Them's Seeing Ponies

      Spoiler

      This definitely sounds akin to an interesting premise, particularly through its expansion of Rainbow Falls itself beyond an aesthetically pleasing backdrop for several lower-quality episodes and the concept of the 'extreme' M6 (which I guess could be some form of commentary on flanderization, although I somehow suspect that the writers were more concerned with the similarities to other 'corrupted/reworked M6' plotlines (such as Return of Harmony or MMC), although somehow the conceit of Twilight (in the outline version, I recall) screwing this kind of task up seems kind of contrived given the 'mentor' characterization they attempted to push throughout the season otherwise. 

      On a related note, season 4 appears to mark an interesting divergence in the way the show's episodes were composed if the leaks are anything to reference - note that the premises and outlines in S1 and S2 were written by Faust and Renzetti, with Meghan assuming control of this in S3, yet every season following this appears to feature the premise/outlines for (almost) every episode written by its respective writer (or another writer, hence AKR's credit on the outline of the musical version of Bats!) as opposed to a single showrunner(s). Regardless of one's opinion on the later seasons, I suspect this was a contributory factor in their less cohesive/consistent tone and characterization (particularly from S6 onwards). Similarly, the production for S4 in general seems weirdly uneven, with a number of premises in S5's earlier half seemingly formulated approximately a year prior to actual production (check the 'Episodic Brainstorm' folder in the S4 file, which contains a number of S5 episode premises and the entire (noticeably different, particularly in regards to most of act 1, Starlight being referred to as 'Aurora Glimmer' and lack of Larson-esque comedic touches) first draft of part 1 of The Cutie Map ), which may explain the elongated hiatus between S4 and S5 as a result of either Meghan attempting to greenlight the MLP Movie (in its early form at least) or the crew anticipating some form of cancellation (a less likely possibility). 

       

    2. (See 1 other reply to this status update)

  18. From an early version of Rarity Investigates when MA Larson was writing it

    Spoiler

    The prisoners walk in a circle to get some exercise. Rarity tells her client all she’s learned and it doesn’t look good. Dash has no alibi, there is strong evidence against her, and dozens of witnesses will testify that she all but confessed in advance. Dash says somepony must be trying to frame her, somepony who is carrying a grudge. “Gilda might still be a little peeved with me. Then there’s Lightning Dust...oh, and that guy I headbutted at the Gala, check him out. I bet a few ponies at the Gala weren’t too happy with me...

    ” TIMELAPSE “...and then there’s that falcon from my pet contest. Lots of ponies from flight camp. The delegates from the cities that lost the Games to the Crystal Empire...

    ” TIMELAPSE “...and I scared Pip so badly he never even came back to Ponyville.” Rarity looks haggard: “Anypony else?” Rainbow Dash thinks, then says, “Discord, that guy never liked me. The entire town of Appleoosa. The guy from the train station yesterday. Oh, and Sweetie Belle.” Rarity is overwhelmed by the task ahead.

    I loved the episode we got, but I kinda wish this scene made it in, it sounded hilarious :dash:

     

    1. Them's Seeing Ponies

      Them's Seeing Ponies

      Spoiler

      I know what you mean regarding season 6 - judging from both the modifications made to numerous episode scripts (to the extent of the final/aired versions of multiple episodes ironically exuding a more unfinished feel than their outlines, such as AJ's Day Off and The Cart Before the Ponies) and the production notes exchanged between the staff (one email from Jim Miller on The Crystalling admits that, while the episode itself was 'always going to be a difficult script to crack', the draft 'still wasn't working' after multiple revisions due to lack of necessary exposition, which may explain the awkward and exposition-heavy dialogue in the final episode itself), numerous episodes appear to have been edited hastily (or outright wrongheadedly) by Haber and co. despite a few internal objections (the email actually acknowledging the dicey affair that is Newbie Dash's moral), in turn leading to a downturn in finished episode quality (particularly as Haber seems to struggle in integrating plot exposition naturally, thus leading to him seemingly applying much of the resulting clunky dialogue across the season as a 'quick fix' and ultimately explaining one of my most major issues with the season overall).

      That being said, while the dropped premises for S6 are generally less well-written/cohesive with FiM's spirit than the preceding five seasons (as one would expect), Nick Confalone's treatment for a Guinness World Records episode with Dash and Pinkie is surprisingly amusing - I'm not a huge fan of the comedy in Confalone's finished episodes, but it comes out arguably more effectively in written form - his scripts (particularly his first drafts) in general tend to be hilarious, such as the dropped scene in Party Pooped :

      PINKIE PIE (V.O.) (German accent) And so my quest begins.

      As she narrates, dissolve through different angles of her standing there, looking super-intense and serious.

      PINKIE PIE (V.O.) The journey will be fraught with peril, yet if I am to entertain our guests, the noble yaks, I must learn about them, study them, and live amongst them. And I must do it all this afternoon. Nothing will stop me. Nothing will distract me.

      EPIC MUSIC screeches to a halt as--

      PINKIE PIE (normal voice) AIEEE LOOK AT THAT LEAF! Yes! Yes! It looks like a cupcake!

      ANGLE ON - a leaf that does, in fact, look like a cupcake.

      PINKIE PIE (CONT’D) (Singing and dancing) Go cupcake leaf, go Pinkie Pie, go cupcake leaf, go Pinkie Pie.

      Pinkie Pie instantly gets serious again. So does the music.

       PINKIE PIE (V.O.) (German accent) This is no accident. This is a sign.

       She sticks the stem of the cupcake leaf behind her ear.

      PINKIE PIE (V.O.) This leaf will be my companion. And its name shall be... Cupcake Leaf.

      They do kind of milk the gag afterwards (Pinkie monologues to 'Cupcake Leaf' through the remainder of her journey as opposed to the Beatles references in the final episode, which I always suspected to be a Larson-added touch somehow) but the sardonic tone of the text in general is surprisingly well-utilized.

       

    2. (See 3 other replies to this status update)

  19. From an early version of Rarity Investigates when MA Larson was writing it

    Spoiler

    The prisoners walk in a circle to get some exercise. Rarity tells her client all she’s learned and it doesn’t look good. Dash has no alibi, there is strong evidence against her, and dozens of witnesses will testify that she all but confessed in advance. Dash says somepony must be trying to frame her, somepony who is carrying a grudge. “Gilda might still be a little peeved with me. Then there’s Lightning Dust...oh, and that guy I headbutted at the Gala, check him out. I bet a few ponies at the Gala weren’t too happy with me...

    ” TIMELAPSE “...and then there’s that falcon from my pet contest. Lots of ponies from flight camp. The delegates from the cities that lost the Games to the Crystal Empire...

    ” TIMELAPSE “...and I scared Pip so badly he never even came back to Ponyville.” Rarity looks haggard: “Anypony else?” Rainbow Dash thinks, then says, “Discord, that guy never liked me. The entire town of Appleoosa. The guy from the train station yesterday. Oh, and Sweetie Belle.” Rarity is overwhelmed by the task ahead.

    I loved the episode we got, but I kinda wish this scene made it in, it sounded hilarious :dash:

     

    1. Them's Seeing Ponies

      Them's Seeing Ponies

      Spoiler

      On a related note, I assume you've read the script for rejected season 6 outing in which the CMC attempt to educate an implicitly ASD-inflicted foal on social etiquette? It's definitely an odd premise for the show to tackle (particularly given how nakedly presented the autism allegory in question is) but an interesting experiment nonetheless.

       

    2. (See 3 other replies to this status update)

  20. From an early version of Rarity Investigates when MA Larson was writing it

    Spoiler

    The prisoners walk in a circle to get some exercise. Rarity tells her client all she’s learned and it doesn’t look good. Dash has no alibi, there is strong evidence against her, and dozens of witnesses will testify that she all but confessed in advance. Dash says somepony must be trying to frame her, somepony who is carrying a grudge. “Gilda might still be a little peeved with me. Then there’s Lightning Dust...oh, and that guy I headbutted at the Gala, check him out. I bet a few ponies at the Gala weren’t too happy with me...

    ” TIMELAPSE “...and then there’s that falcon from my pet contest. Lots of ponies from flight camp. The delegates from the cities that lost the Games to the Crystal Empire...

    ” TIMELAPSE “...and I scared Pip so badly he never even came back to Ponyville.” Rarity looks haggard: “Anypony else?” Rainbow Dash thinks, then says, “Discord, that guy never liked me. The entire town of Appleoosa. The guy from the train station yesterday. Oh, and Sweetie Belle.” Rarity is overwhelmed by the task ahead.

    I loved the episode we got, but I kinda wish this scene made it in, it sounded hilarious :dash:

     

    1. Them's Seeing Ponies

      Them's Seeing Ponies

      Spoiler

      The script for "Rainbow Confession" in general, whilst relatively similar to the aired version of RI premise-wise, is arguably one of the highlights of the leaked material, particularly the Larson-esque comedic touches ("I have a dress that simply screams justice!") and Legally Blonde references adorning it - RI is one of S5's better episodes nonetheless, but I honestly wish that the Lady Writers had retained more of Larson's plot points/details to an extent (despite the clash of creative tones it could generate), as the prisoner scene evidences well. 

       

    2. (See 3 other replies to this status update)

  21. The original premise for Newbie Dash

    Spoiler

    The episode was actually supposed to be about RD actually getting into the WB, and her learning what it means to be a WB. In the original plan RD was called up not to be a WB(yet) but to see the tasks the Reserves will have for this. Instead of flying with the WBs, she was originally planned for crowd control(which embarrasses her). The impressions scene is still there, as she's hoping to get to fly with the WBs, but fails. During the show, RD avoids being around her friends out of embarrassment, and admits she's not flying, just doing crowd control. In an attempt to raise RD's spirits, Scootaloo decides to cheer from the highest bleachers, but loses her balances and falls off. RD sees this and rushes in as fast as she can to save her, causing a Sonic Rainboom( instinctively performing impressive maneuvers in the process without knowing)  and actually ruining the show. She saved Scootaloo, but now she thinks she's gonna be kicked out, but this was actually enough to impress the Wonderbolts, and the episode ends with her getting in(and Spitfire pulling a Spitfire and has RD getting her ointment for her hooves, which she's proud of)

    I really wish I didn't find out about this. To say I'm livid with this is an understatement. This actually sounds like it could have been amazing.

    On the bright side, I now have a version of the episode I consider the canon one now

    1. Them's Seeing Ponies

      Them's Seeing Ponies

      Spoiler

      While I don't legitimately hate ND, the premise itself definitely indicates a far more substantial and atmospheric (particularly the way that Dave Rapp's initial treatment dedicates time to building the scale of the event, whereas the climax of the finished episode kind of just happens due to its significantly smaller scale and lack of tension) plot against the sloppiness of the episode proper, which is aided by the episode's more unique use of character and location to build a more fully fleshed-out story (whereas the final ND focuses on slamming down Dash at the detriment of everything else (particularly the reactions of the other M6, which are simply kind of glossed over hastily), which always gave the episode an uncomfortable air of being semi-unfinished to me).  

       

    2. (See 6 other replies to this status update)

  22. I need to stop reading the leaks because it's honestly making me sad at some of the things that could have been, but it's just so interesting to read. Some episodes would have turned out a lot better or much differently had they just went with what was originally planned :/

    1. Them's Seeing Ponies

      Them's Seeing Ponies

      Having now turfed through them, I was, as you said, unsurprised. The other files are fascinating as well, particularly the season 1 stuff.

    2. (See 2 other replies to this status update)

  23. I need to stop reading the leaks because it's honestly making me sad at some of the things that could have been, but it's just so interesting to read. Some episodes would have turned out a lot better or much differently had they just went with what was originally planned :/

    1. Them's Seeing Ponies

      Them's Seeing Ponies

      I dare not ask how the original script for Fame and Misfortune  must read considering its infamy as an alleged victim of 'executive meddling', if Larson's later statements were anything to go by. 

    2. (See 2 other replies to this status update)

  24. Quote

    Magic Sheep (would’ve been higher had the moral following Luna’s reveal not be so badly botched.)

     

    "Just stop it." is a great moral, what're you talking about? :orly:

    1. Them's Seeing Ponies

      Them's Seeing Ponies

      I always thought the episode was flawed in other aspects - it seems so insistent on being generically 'awesome' and shoehorning in as many details it believes will impress the fandom (particularly in the final scene) as possible that the entire plot comes off as incoherent and slapdashed akin to a mid-tier fanfiction (which renders the ending's attempt to be a meaningful Aesop yet more insulting) as opposed to an actual episode of FiM, which usually displays far more creative/narrative discipline than this episode does. 

  25. Quote

    The Cutie Pox (one of the blandest episodes of the show)

     

    Having just rewatched this I have to say I agree with you. 

     

    Also, Apple Bloom "Didn't learn anything!" before Applejack did. :-P

    1. Them's Seeing Ponies

      Them's Seeing Ponies

      The Cutie Pox is easily one of the most negligible episodes of the series, with Pinkie's confession in the third act ("oh please make it STOP!") being the sole genuine highlight amidst the immense amounts of padding and the predictable nature of the plot. 

×
×
  • Create New...