SunsetShimmerStan

Spring Breakdown: Hold the phone!

What made the first movie the only one that worked? What about Sunset's reformation arc after that (the real hook of the franchise)?

Relax, I'm not asking for a fanfiction, just a basic outline is all. Like summing up how Sunset would see Sci-Twi any differently than Pony Twilight (if you were a shipper, what reason would there be on how to choose to ship Sunset with Pony or Human Twilight if they're 100% the same). And a nuance on how to write Sci-Twi being 100% like her pony counterpart, but also not being the leader of the group (Sunset has that role). And no, but it is harder to try to fix certain things than just "make Sci-Twi exactly like her pony counterpart" and "make Sunset's reunion with Celestia a different special" and "give Sunset more personality", considering how they effect the plot. And what is your stance on Discord, Trixie, and Luna after they reformed? Were they any better at giving them quirks and more personality (outside relying on just "I'm reformed" all the time as their main hook) than Sunset and Starlight and why?

So how should they have gone about characterizing Sci-Twi and her story arc throughout Friendship Games and Legend of Everfree? There does need to be some way of distinguishing her from her pony counterpart. Otherwise, what would be the point of Sci-Twi existing if she's gonna be 100% the same as her pony counterpart that was major in the first two films? Plus in having to avoid the implication on whether or not Sunset and the Humane 5 only like her because she's exactly like the pony counterpart (which they spend the first two movies bonding with) and only accepted her because she's a replacement and nothing more, plus if they'd still be friends with her even if they didn't meet her pony counterpart first.

How would you have done Diamond Tiara's arc better then?

So if you were given a chance, how would you have characterized Sunset post-Friendship Games? Like, how would you have gone about still making her fun to watch, keeping her interests more relevant, and giving her flaws in a way that doesn't cause one to question why the Rainbooms are still friends with her? Plus in writing her friendship with Sci-Twi, considering it's a pretty important friendship in the spin off (Sci-Twi arguably being Sunset's best and closest friend). How do you think Sunset and Sci-Twi's friendship could've been better written in Legend of Everfree that brought out the best in both of them? Plus, are there any reformed characters either on MLP or other shows that genuinely were still fun to watch and having solid characterization post-redemption arc?

Yeah, but what if they went with the mother/son dynamic instead? Given it took until season 9 for the sibling thing to be mentioned and been then, it was only 1 episode, what if they went with mother/son instead? By that logic, what makes Amending Fences work better in putting Twilight in a similar scenario of making amends with someone she hurt in the past (Moondancer like how Sunset had with Wallflower)? Considering she basically proved herself already for 4 seasons by that point, what made Amending Fences more meaningful to Twilight than Forgotten Friendship is to Sunset? And how is it that far fetched that someone still has a grudge against Sunset? It's not as if Rainbow Rocks shows every single student interacting one on one with Sunset outside the Rainbooms. Like, it is more complicated than just mob mentality of everyone forgiving Sunset at the same time. What moments in Rainbow Rocks and other stuff show Sunset making it up to people she bullied in the past one on one (saving the school from the Dazzlings leans more on mob mentality of a crowd forgiving her at the same time rather than any specific one on one moments)?

This has been a nagging question for a while, would one prefer to theorize that Sunset would return to Equestria or live out the rest of her life in the human world? Personally, I theorize she'd live the rest of her life in the human world considering the close bonds she has with the Rainbooms and everyone in the human world and it'd be pretty disappointing and sad if she ended up leaving them in the end for Equestria. Especially considering she didn't really have much a connection to anyone in Equestria aside from Princess Twilight and Princess Celestia (and later Starlight Glimmer in Movie Magic) so it feels like it'd make more sense for her to live out the rest of her human life in the human world, occasionally using the portal to visit Equestria once in a while and communicating to Princess Twilight via the journal. As for what she'd do for a living as an adult, maybe she'd eventually become the principal of Canterlot High after Celestia retires (paralleling Princess Twilight succeeding Princess Celestia as ruler of Equestria), inspiring students into their own friendships for the next generations. I personally doubt they would've actually had Sunset leave the human world for good and cut off all contact with her human friends if they had gotten Equestria Girls a proper finale. I doubt they'd spend several movies, specials, and shorts focusing on the girls' friendship if Sunset did get permanent separation. Heck, Forgotten Friendship even has Sunset get her memories of the human world back immediately after they're removed so that does imply to me that they wouldn't go for her cutting contact with the human world. Especially when we have pony Twilight still being in contact with the rest of the Mane 6 even when moving to Canterlot as princess. The deleted homesick plot in Friendship Games also ended with Sunset choosing the human world over Equestria. I think even one of the writers mentioned Sunset's true home is the human world, so I'm positive she'd spend the rest of her days there (maybe becomes a teacher at Canterlot High) with occasional visits to Equestria and using the journals to message Twilight and Celestia.