What if... Twilight turned evil and became Sombra's Queen

[GreyScholar 1,584]

Taking the idea of this video and going a different direction with it:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5_HQSue9ze0

 

What if Sombra, either by convincing her or by force, made Twilight his queen. If Twilight Sparkle became a villian, became evil, and threatened all of Equestria.

 

Putting aside Discord and the royal sisters (having them be unavaliable or unable to help), what would need to be done to fight and defeat 'Queen' Twilight Sparkle?

 

Do you believe her friends eould have a chance in defeating het? If allowed all their strengths, skills, and abilities as given on the show? Counting Pinkie Pie being Pinkie Pie with the strange abilities she seems to possesses.

 

What of use of stratagy and tactics, her friends using her known flaws and wraknesses. Using what the known of the pne that had once been a dear friend.

Edited June 15, 2014 by EquestrianScholar

[Pinkamena-Pills 6,839]

I feel that if this happens,Equestria is doomed....

 

*rereads and notices you're allowing Pinkie's broken abilities*

 

Pinkie Defeats Evil Twilight with hugs that cures evil..just because she can. 

 

Edited June 15, 2014 by Pinkamena-Pills

[Arctic Night 884]

Vote not fair. Twilight would win. PRAISE TWILIGHT.

[GreyScholar 1,584]

I feel that if this happens,Equestria is doomed....

Really, you believe the situation to be that hopeless? That Good could not defeat Evil and Friendship again prove to be the greatest power in Equestria? That Twilight's friends would not have a chance in defeating her?

Vote not fair. Twilight would win. PRAISE TWILIGHT.

You not going to even try to figure out an answer?

Edited June 15, 2014 by EquestrianScholar

[Scootalove 10,689]

They could try to defeat Twilight, it won't be easy to defeat her though. Sombra could help Twilight to take on her friends, so we could see the demise of the Mane 6. I know they would not go down without a fight.

[Pinkamena-Pills 6,839]

 

 

Really, you believe the situation to be that hopeless? That Good could not defeat Evil and Friendship again prove to be the greatest power in Equestria? That Twilight's friends would not have a chance in defeating her?

 

Well im just considering how powerful Twilight is by default and that adding the possible(and probable) power boost she would get by being evil(no longer caring to hold back,lack of empathy ect).

 

W/o Royal Sisters and Discord,i don't see how anyone beats a Evil alicorn with a op cutie mark(magic)...

 

Im not saying i can't see a possible victory for good,but i wouldn't bank on it   

[GreyScholar 1,584]

*rereads and notices you're allowing Pinkie's broken abilities*

 

Pinkie Defeats Evil Twilight with hugs that cures evil..just because she can.

 

... that is not what I meant when putting that in. I mean the fact that I feel Pinkie Pie could use stuff like her Pinkie Sense, ability to appear anywhere, and her 'silly' behavior to confuse, out maneuver, and counter what Twilight could throw at her. Doing stuff like she did during the Goof Off in Pinkie Pie, her antics in Griffin the Brushoff, even the Mysterious Mare-do-well.

 

Well im just considering how powerful Twilight is by default and that adding the possible(and probable) power boost she would get by being evil(no longer caring to hold back,lack of empathy ect).

 

W/o Royal Sisters and Discord,i don't see how anyone beats a Evil alicorn with a op cutie mark(magic)...

 

Im not saying i can't see a possible victory for good,but i wouldn't bank on it

 

Well that would only be the case if you believe becoming an alicorn boosted Twilight's magic/power or that Twilight is OP.

 

Myself, I believe the only time Twilight has proven herself OP was when she was given the power boost of three other alicorns, two of which are seemingly immortal 1000+ year old rulers of Equestria.

Edited June 15, 2014 by EquestrianScholar

[Pinkamena-Pills 6,839]

... that is not what I meant when putting that in. I mean the fact that I feel Pinkie Pie could use stuff like her Pinkie Sense, ability to appear anywhere, and her 'silly' behavior to confuse, out maneuver, and counter what Twilight could throw at her. Doing stuff like she did during the Goof Off in Pinkie Pie, her antics in Griffin the Brushoff, even the Mysterious Mare-do-well.

AKA: The ability to do whatever she wants? 

 

I assume you want the 'normal' 'silly' Pinkie and not the 'lol screw logic one',if thats the case then you could have specified that.

 

 

Counting Pinkie Pie being Pinkie Pie with the strange abilities she seems to possesses.

 

 

That was a pretty broad statement,so sorry if i took it the wrong way  

 

If that's the case my previous statement applies: Equestria is doomed.

[GreyScholar 1,584]

AKA: The ability to do whatever she wants?

 

I assume you want the 'normal' 'silly' Pinkie and not the 'lol screw logic one',if thats the case then you could have specified that.

 

That was a pretty broad statement,so sorry if i took it the wrong way

 

If that's the case my previous statement applies: Equestria is doomed.

As in I believe Pinkie can break the 'rules'... to an extent. Such as her slowing her decent when falling into the pool or being inside a mirror, I belief she can actually do that. Edited June 15, 2014 by EquestrianScholar

[Pinkamena-Pills 6,839]

Well that would only be the case if you believe becoming an alicorn boosted Twilight's magic/power or that Twilight is OP.

 

The alicorn statement was just that,i have honestly no idea whether alicorn=powerboost. I was mainly speaking of the extremely convenient cutie mark/talent Twilight has(magic) 

As in I believe Pinkie can break the 'rules'... to an extent. Such as her slowing her decent when falling into the pool or being inside a mirror, I belief she can actually do that.

Fair enough. Still,Equestria is doomed. I honestly think its unfair not include atleast the royal sisters in this,i understand Discord because hes another possible 'insta-win' card(barring he isn't tricked ect into losing his powers/turned to stone) but not including any of the royal sisters is a death sentence to Equestria. 

 

Is Cadance/Sinning Armor combo available in this scenario if no Luna/Celestia?

Edited June 16, 2014 by Pinkamena-Pills

[GreyScholar 1,584]

The alicorn statement was just that,i have honestly no idea whether alicorn=powerboost. I was mainly speaking of the extremely convenient cutie mark/talent Twilight has(magic)

 

Fair enough. Still,Equestria is doomed. I honestly think its unfair not include atleast the royal sisters in this,i understand Discord because hes another possible 'insta-win' card(barring he isn't tricked ect into losing his powers or turn to stone) but not including any of the royal sisters is a death sentence to equestria.

 

Is Cadance/Shining Armor combo available in this scenario if no Luna/Celestia?

Possible the royals sisters, Shining Armour, and Cadance could become involved and help but I want this to be a battle between Twilight and those that had been her dearest friends. Edited June 16, 2014 by EquestrianScholar

[Pinkamena-Pills 6,839]

Possible the royals sisters, Shing Armour, and Cadance could become involved and help but I want this to be a battle between Twilight and those that had been her dearest friends.

Well unless the remaining mane 5+Spike has help from the royals or shining armor/cadence combo,the mane 5+Spike lose,Equestria is done,game over

 

 Hail to the queen of Equestria 

Edited June 16, 2014 by Pinkamena-Pills

[GreyScholar 1,584]

Well unless the remaining mane 5+Spike has help from the royals or shining armor/cadence combo,the mane 5+Spike lose,Equestria is done,game over

 

Hail to the queen of Equestria

 

I disagree they would be required, especially for a show like MLP:FiM. Friendship is th greatest power in Equestria and I believe Twilight's friends have what it takes to defeat her, even save her, without the royal sister directly involved.

Edited June 16, 2014 by EquestrianScholar

[Pinkamena-Pills 6,839]

 

 

Friendship is th greatest power in Equestria

 

 

But remember Twilight is friendship(Element of Friendship). She just happens to be best friends with Sombra now not the mane 5+Spike 

 

But on a serious note: Yes,baring the show,no matter how hopeless it seems(and man does that scenario feel hopeless) good will always triumph..somehow. 

 

So i guess due to the shows moral preference of good>evil,Twilight will somehow be beat and saved.

 

But if we throw out the shows preference for good over evil,and just focus on what whats here in this scenario,theres a high chance Equestria is done for imo 

[GreyScholar 1,584]

But remember Twilight is friendship(Element of Friendship). She just happens to be best friends with Sombra now not the mane 5+Spike 

 

But on a serious note: Yes,baring the show,no matter how hopeless it seems(and man does that scenario feel hopeless) good will always triumph..somehow. 

 

So i guess due to the shows moral preference of good>evil,Twilight will somehow be beat and saved.

 

But if we throw out the shows preference for good over evil,and just focus on what whats here in this scenario,theres a high chance Equestria is done for imo 

By chance have you read the Nightmare Rarity arc of the MLP:FiM comic?

 

I do believe, even if Twilight, the rest of the Mane Six could save the day. Again perhaps 'supported' by the royal sisters.

[Pinkamena-Pills 6,839]

By chance have you read the Nightmare Rarity arc of the MLP:FiM comic?

 

I do believe, even if Twilight, the rest of the Mane Six could save the day. Again perhaps 'supported' by the royal sisters.

I haven't read it,but i know where you're getting at,tho Rarity doesn't have a cutie mark/special talent that is pretty ridiculous but i guess that's besides the point now.

 

But ya,i get what you're saying tho and if by some chance this became a story arc in the show,Twilight would be defeated and reformed/redeemed ect. 

[GreyScholar 1,584]

I haven't read it,but i know where you're getting at,tho Rarity doesn't have a cutie mark/special talent that is pretty ridiculous but i guess that's besides the point now.

 

But ya,i get what you're saying tho and if by some chance this became a story arc in the show,Twilight would be defeated and reformed/redeemed ect.

Yet you still believe Twilight would more reasonable defeat her former friends and take over Equestria unless Celestia and Luna found her? That her friends couldn't defeat her? Edited June 16, 2014 by EquestrianScholar

[Pinkamena-Pills 6,839]

Yet you still believe Twilight would more reasonable defeat her former friends and take over Equestria unless Celestia and Luna found her? That her friends couldn't defeat her?

 

 

 

What if Sombra, either by convincing her or by force, made Twilight his queen. If Twilight Sparkle became a villian, became evil, and threatened all of Equestria.

 

 

Baring this yes,unfortunately   

[cuteycindyhoney 13,308]

If Twilight became evil, she would become Nightmare Moon's queen!

(Yes, that's a ship I would gladly sail on!)

[GreyScholar 1,584]

If Twilight became evil, she would become Nightmare Moon's queen!

(Yes, that's a ship I would gladly sail on!)

Too bad Nightmare Moon doesn't exist anymore and was an entity from the moon that manipulated and took control of Luna... and then Rarity.

[cuteycindyhoney 13,308]

Too bad Nightmare Moon doesn't exist anymore and was an entity from the moon that manipulated and took control of Luna... and then Rarity.

Well, Sombra doesn't exist any more either. He was destroyed before twilight became a princess.

[GreyScholar 1,584]

I don't think so, especially since his horn was left behind. Lastly keep in mind he was a shadow, merely being hit by the crystal heart and scattered doesn't/should mean he is gone for good.

 

That and this is a "what if" following the scenario given in the video.

[Darker 1,351]

With her intellect and magic, she'll probably do a lot of harm, but will eventually be defeated.

[CP3_P0n3 170]

Gotta love Яeversed Twilight.

 

Anyway, Equestria is pretty much doomed. Given that the Mane 6 are connected to the elements, Twilight can easily taints hers and the others'. Therefore, she can do what Discord did to them in the maze. She can also taints the tree of harmony with darkness. So yeah, Twilight is OP as it is.

 

If her connection with her element is lost the moment she joins evil, then there's still hope.