Would you like to see an AU short with Sunset and Nightmare Star?

[ManaMinori 4,146]

I know there's already been an established AU named Equestria Girls, and AU's in FiM, through a result of messing with Starswirl's spell, thanks to Starlight.....but what if there was a "what if" short, maybe 11 minutes or so, like the old g1 episodes, that featured Sunset Shimmer- again, as Sunbutt's apprentice, but it was Sunbutt who turned evil, into Nightmare Star/ Solar Flare, and it was Sunset's job to stop her? How do you think these events would impact FIM or EqG's AU, since it has been established that both parallel worlds have impacted each other (Starswirl's banishment of the Sirens out of FIM and into EQG, Sunset's leaving FiM for EQG, to help and bring magic over there, and vice versa- Midnight Sparkle's influence of ripping holes in FiM's AU causing the result of the deserted wasteland seeing in Starlight Glimmer's alternate timeline loop)

[cmarston1 5,960]

An two part episode focusing on Nightmare Star would be something I would like to see. Whether it be in an AU, or in the show prior, or that AU crossover with the Canon Equestria.

[Swifty 249]

Only if you are gonna hate the hay out of this AU.

 

Turning Sunset Shimmer dumb and bad. Making Nightmare Star cool and great.

[Steve Piranha 29,453]

You know? There's an upcoming series of pony comics dealing with What If?s scenarios, like Blueblood taking the place of Twi, perhaps they'll make that plot on it