Help with casting Hamilton MLP cast

[darkwingmare 1,320]

Not sure if this is the right thread for cast advice, move it if needed.

I'm planning on doing a animatics to some of the songs from Hamilton the Musical with an MLP cast. Much like Ink Potts have done, they inspire me a lot to do this to begin with. Seems fun!
I'll be focusing on shorts of the following songs:
Helpless
Satisfied

That Would be Enough
Non-Stop

Say no to this
Burn
Congratulations

Meaning, mostly concerning the sisters love for Alexander.


Anyway, my thought was something like..
Twilight Sparkle as Alexander Hamilton. She is most likely to fit Alexander's character traits in my opinion. She writes a lot and she could have been the political historical type. She'd also look nice with her hair tied up like Hamilton himself.

Applejack as Burr is a pretty obvious choice for me so no question about that one.

Fluttershy or Rarity as Maria Reynolds.

Then.. The thing I'm most uncertain about is the Schuyler sisters. My thought was.. Pinkie as Angelica and Marble Pie as Eliza, but I'm not sure. Any suggestions?
I'd love to hear what you guys would prefer for the cast.

Edited January 15, 2017 by darkwingmare

[StarNote 231]

@@darkwingmare,

 

well i am a big hamilton fan and i will  say i do fell like it is right that

 

twilight should be hamilton

 

and burr as apple jack 

 

and rarity as Maria Reynolds

 

and maud  pie as angelica for many reasons because she would do anything for her sisters 

 

eliza as pinkie pie 

 

and limestone pie as peggy 

 

and i think George washing ton as shining armor

 

and lee as derpy 

or Washington as rainbow dash and i have no idea for flutter shy  Mabey she should be lee insted of derpy (i dont even know if you need these characters but whatever )

[darkwingmare 1,320]

@@darkwingmare, well i am a big hamilton fan and i will  say i do fell like it is right that twilight should be hamilton and burr as apple jack  and rarity as Maria Reynolds and maud  pie as angelica for many reasons because she would do anything for her sisters  eliza as pinkie pie  and limestone pie as peggy  and i think George washing ton as shining armor and lee as derpy or Washington as rainbow dash and i have no idea for flutter shy  Mabey she should be lee insted of derpy (i dont even know if you need these characters but whatever )

Good point! I like the thought of Maud as Angelica.

And yes indeed, my thought was that Rainbow Dash would suit as Washington.

 

Thank you for the help and suggestions! Much appreciated!

[StarNote 231]

Good point! I like the thought of Maud as Angelica.

And yes indeed, my thought was that Rainbow Dash would suit as Washington.

 

Thank you for the help and suggestions! Much appreciated!

no problem from a hamilton fan to another 

[Cherry Bomb 51]

I'd love to do Pinkie as Angelica. Both are two of my fav characters in the show and play.I can send a voice of Pinkie if needed and satisfied or congratulations of needed.