I Want Your Feedback!

[Salacberry 90]

Hi everyone!

 

I'm currently in my final year of high school, and one of my subjects is based on design. For our major folio, we have to follow the design process to produce two final presentations for a client, which can be whoever we like. For my client, I chose Hasbro, more specifically My Little Pony. As a part of my project, I'm hypothetically rebooting the brand again, which means new character designs. Part of the criteria for this folio is the use of 'design thinking strategies,' ways in which our work can be evaluated and we can gain feedback. 

 

So where do you guys come in? Well, I have a very short survey about my three possible character design concepts that I'd like to include in my folio as one of my design thinking strategies, and it would be amazing if you guys could help me out by completing it! I thought this would be the perfect place to ask, since this is a MLP forum after all.

 

Keep in mind that the target audience for these designs is young girls aged 4-12.

 

Also, the survey is about the styles of the drawings, not the character that has been drawn in each.

Survey

1. Which of the designs is the most effective?

2. Which of the designs would appeal most to the target audience?

3. Which of the designs would be most successful in the current market?

4. Which of the designs is most appropriate for the My Little Pony brand?

5. Which of the designs is the most aesthetically appealing?

 

All you need to do is answer each question with either '1', '2' or '3.' 1 is the first design, 2 is the middle etc.

 

Thankyou so much for taking the time to read this, and if you'd be willing to help me out that would be absolutely amazing!

[Bucky McGillyCuddy 956]

Each one is good in it's own way. Number two almost looks like it could be a Pokemon haha. In fact I think the second style takes first place in all departments you listed. Good work!

[Mephala 2,633]

This is hard to say because I am not 4-12 years old, but thinking in that mindset, I'll try not to be biased. ^^

 

Which of the designs is the most effective? - Design 2

Which of the designs would appeal most to the target audience? - Design 3

Which of the designs would be most successful in the current market? - Design 3

Which of the designs is most appropriate for the My Little Pony brand? - Design 3

Which of the designs is the most aesthetically appealing? - Design 2

[Salacberry 90]

Each one is good in it's own way. Number two almost looks like it could be a Pokemon haha. In fact I think the second style takes first place in all departments you listed. Good work!

 

Thankyou! Haha, that's definitely the Pokemon fan in me coming through.

[Dovashy 1,734]

In answer to all of the questions, I would have to say Design 2. 

[websterhamster 203]

1. Which of the designs is the most effective?  2 This is a very hard question because it's subjective and vague. Effective for what?

2. Which of the designs would appeal most to the target audience?  2

3. Which of the designs would be most successful in the current market?  2

4. Which of the designs is most appropriate for the My Little Pony brand?  2

5. Which of the designs is the most aesthetically appealing?  1

 

My favorite design is number one, as I appreciate that form of art better than the other two. However, for the purposes of MLP, design 2 wins over the others. Design 3 is left out because the target audience includes 10-12 year olds. Design 3 would be better for a target audience of 3-6.

[Salacberry 90]

 

1. Which of the designs is the most effective?  2 This is a very hard question because it's subjective and vague. Effective for what?

2. Which of the designs would appeal most to the target audience?  2

3. Which of the designs would be most successful in the current market?  2

4. Which of the designs is most appropriate for the My Little Pony brand?  2

5. Which of the designs is the most aesthetically appealing?  1

 

My favorite design is number one, as I appreciate that form of art better than the other two. However, for the purposes of MLP, design 2 wins over the others. Design 3 is left out because the target audience includes 10-12 year olds. Design 3 would be better for a target audience of 3-6.

 

 

Thankyou for filling it out!

 

As for effective.. I didn't really think about that to be honest haha. I guess the other questions elaborate on it.