Who would win in a fight between the Mane Six? (without using magic!)

[Lumena Sparkle 30]

So come on guys,who would emerge victorious?

[Manman20x6 359]

Rainbow Dash can accelerate to Mach 1 in two seconds while going upwards, and can punch with the power of an atomic bomb. She could literally blow up everyone else in ten seconds flat.

[FeatherNight 35]

Between applejack and rainbowdash, I couldn't decide.

 

Applejack has physical strength and Rainbow has speed.

 

You never know, Fluttershy might have developed an even scarier stare.

[FlutterForever 330]

I feel like people are forgetting that Pinkie can break the forth wall, which would give her a huge advantage. Also, I honestly feel Fluttershy is dangerous when angry, even her flying becomes really good.

[Manman20x6 359]

I feel like people are forgetting that Pinkie can break the forth wall, which would give her a huge advantage.

 

She doesn't really "break the fourth wall" that much. The only time I can recall where the fourth wall was clearly broken (which is the ending of "Magic Duel"), Twilight was also breaking the fourth wall just as much as Pinkie, so it isn't something that's specific to her.

 

Usually, she just makes comments and acts in ways that suggest medium awareness, for comedic purposes, which wouldn't be of much help in a fight. It's mostly fanart that depicts her as an omnipotent reality warper who directly communicates with the audience while ignoring the laws of physics.

[Pastel 7,630]

Oh, another fight topic...

 

Rainbow Dash can accelerate to Mach 1 in two seconds while going upwards, and can punch with the power of an atomic bomb. She could literally blow up everyone else in ten seconds flat.

Yeah, I agree:

[FlutterForever 330]

She doesn't really "break the fourth wall" that much. The only time I can recall where the fourth wall was clearly broken (which is the ending of "Magic Duel"), Twilight was also breaking the fourth wall just as much as Pinkie, so it isn't something that's specific to her.

 

Usually, she just makes comments and acts in ways that suggest medium awareness, for comedic purposes, which wouldn't be of much help in a fight. It's mostly fanart that depicts her as an omnipotent reality warper who directly communicates with the audience while ignoring the laws of physics.

 

What you say is true but there have been a few cases of her breaking the forth wall, but most are minor and made for comedic reasons like you said. However, one does stand out a lot and that is when RD is trying to run away from her but somehow Pinkie always beats her and even seemed to know where RD was going.

 

If we take things from a serious point of view then (and I hate that this is the case) RD would win because of the speed in which she can move at.

[CheeryFox 23,821]

RD and AJ are both King Kongs. RD has a few monstrous advantages over AJ. 

Remember, Pinkie is somepony to really worry about.   

[Fractured 2,684]

The main issue in this fight is that most of the Mane Six are never fully realized. In other words, not aware of their powers, Pinkie can't control her fourth wall abilities, and Fluttershy can't tap into... whatever she taps into when she gets angry.

Having said that, @, starting distance(how far they start away from each other), location, and the maximum limits of said location(How far can they go from start?) are pretty much essential to determine who'd win. You may also want to note whether they're in-character(that is, willing to kill each other), and whether outside (non-pony) help is allowed, because suddenly... Fluttershy at least gets a lot more dangerous.

Edited January 16, 2015 by Shimmer5000

[spade 88]

Flutershy took on a dragon. JS

Pinkie Pie is unpredictable tho, it's hard to beat that.

[Fractured 2,684]

...It would be better to just answer the question in my previous post, instead of adding stipulations where they're unnecessary. I can give a coherent answer, but by removing magic entirely, you're unfairly shifting the fight too heavily to one side.

Also, I hate to play semantics, but Earth pony magic is their strength, pegasi their flight. Removing it would obviously make this a really dull and pointless fight.

Although diamond butt wins in that case, so this has it's upisdes.

[spade 88]

...It would be better to just answer the question in my previous post, instead of adding stipulations where they're unnecessary. I can give a coherent answer, but by removing magic entirely, you're unfairly shifting the fight too heavily to one side.

Also, I hate to play semantics, but Earth pony magic is their strength, pegasi their flight. Removing it would obviously make this a really dull and pointless fight.

Although diamond butt wins in that case, so this has it's upisdes.

81784 - artist-GlancoJusticar rarity scarf wallpaper wet_hairity.jpg

This reminds me:

if this was a battle royal Rarity would win because she'd not let her mane get bloody so as everypony else was finnishing eachother off Rarity would refuse to fight and emerge victorious with nought but a scratch.

Edited January 16, 2015 by spade

[Fractured 2,684]

This reminds me:

if this was a battle royal Rarity would win because she'd not let her mane get bloody so as everypony else was finnishing eachother off Rarity would refuse to fight and emerge victorious with nought but a scratch.

Rarity's reaction to being asked to a life or death battle:

"Me, fight? I absolutely will not partake in such brutish behavior. You guys can have your little spat, but i'm hoing home. Some of us have too many customers to deal with blood and dirt and broken bones."

Edited January 16, 2015 by Shimmer5000

[VitalSpark 1,830]

I think what we've seen of Pinkie's powers is merely the tip of the iceberg.

 

I would not want to get into a fight with her.

[Fractured 2,684]

I think what we've seen of Pinkie's powers is merely the tip of the iceberg.

 

I would not want to get into a fight with her.

Too be fair, none of the Mane Six are anything to sneeze at, which is why I wish  would make this battle more concise. I'd love to delve into specifics, such as what would happen should Fluttershy make it to the everfree forest and start calling in favors. Like from a certain manticore?

[Lumena Sparkle 30]

Too be fair, none of the Mane Six are anything to sneeze at, which is why I wish  would make this battle more concise. I'd love to delve into specifics, such as what would happen should Fluttershy make it to the everfree forest and start calling in favors. Like from a certain manticore?

Okay then, a straight forward hooves-for-hooves battle, no flying, no breaking the fourth wall, no extra strength and no calling for animal backup!

Oh yeah, my money is on Rarity, as she does know kung fu....

[Gary S. 102]

If magic isn't allowed, dive-bombing shouldn't be either lol

 

I think it's either Applejack or Rainbow Dash, because they're in good shape.

I'm not sure about the others. I wouldn't write off Fluttershy as weakest after some outbursts of violence. The same for Rarity, because....

 

 

 

 

Edited January 16, 2015 by Gary S.

[Lumena Sparkle 30]

If magic isn't allowed, dive-bombing shouldn't be either lol

 

I think it's either Applejack or Rainbow Dash, because they're in good shape.

I'm not sure about the other ones. I wouldn't write off Fluttershy as weakest after some outbursts of violence. The same for Rarity, because....

 

 

 

 

I refer you to my last post....

and I have to agree, Rarity would win this bitch fight!

[CC_Maud_Pie 6,431]

I would say Fluttershy in assertive and fight mode can harm the rest of the Mane 6 both physically and mentally.

[RainbowTashie 378]

Rainbow Dash can accelerate to Mach 1 in two seconds while going upwards, and can punch with the power of an atomic bomb. She could literally blow up everyone else in ten seconds flat.

erm nuff said i think. any other argument is invalid

[Fractured 2,684]

erm nuff said i think. any other argument is invalid

OP was edited; she can't fly...

[FlutterForever 330]

I would say Fluttershy in assertive and fight mode can harm the rest of the Mane 6 both physically and mentally.

 

What you said has been proven by the show as well; since she made Rarity and Pinkie run away crying really easily and in that episode she showed the strength and influence she can have on everypony else if they ever annoyed her.

[Cwanky 17,579]

She doesn't really "break the fourth wall" that much. The only time I can recall where the fourth wall was clearly broken (which is the ending of "Magic Duel"), Twilight was also breaking the fourth wall just as much as Pinkie, so it isn't something that's specific to her.

 

Usually, she just makes comments and acts in ways that suggest medium awareness, for comedic purposes, which wouldn't be of much help in a fight. It's mostly fanart that depicts her as an omnipotent reality warper who directly communicates with the audience while ignoring the laws of physics.

Well Pinkie does do it consistently enough that its attributed to her character. These are just 2 instances of her outracing Rainbow for instance:

 

 

 

 

If was more serious and actually had dark intentions, I dare not imagine how scary Pinkie Pie could be. 

 

She's just a notch below Discord.  Beware the Pink Peril.  :okiedokielokie:

[Fractured 2,684]

Okay then, a straight forward hooves-for-hooves battle, no flying, no breaking the fourth wall, no extra strength and no calling for animal backup!

Oh yeah, my money is on Rarity, as she does know kung fu....

Not to be rude, but you just ruined this thread...

 

Which is funny, considering that magic is what makes this fight balanced, not broken. I'm assuming you banned it because you though Twilight would ROFLstomp, but she's actually very unlikely to be the winner, all things considered.

[CheeryFox 23,821]

If Flutters went crazy, maybe she could beat both AJ and RD. However there's still Pinkie and her unknowns. I believe both Twilight and Rarity would leave their respective fights. RD and AJ would be some hardcore shit, lel.