Punishing Starlight Glimmer

[Ring Team 123]

On 2015-04-12 at 8:24 PM, Red Cedar said:

Trixie took an entire town hostage. If anyone should have a cell next to Tirek, it's her, but did she get any sort of punishment? Nope.

 

Nothing significant will happen to Starlight, beyond petty personal humiliation.

Unfortunately, this aged well, both Starlight and Trixie.

[Storm Fizz 1]

On 2015-04-11 at 11:01 AM, Grtxkkyz said:

Since Starlight will perhaps come back (according to Jim Miller) to try and get her revenge on the Mane Six for bringing down her equalist dystopia, if she is defeated for good this time, what could be the most fitting comeuppance for her? She's way eviler than Sunset Shimmer in the first EG movie, so, do you think she should be:

*Banished to the moon

*Imprisoned as a stone statue

*Thrown into jail

*Sent to Tartarus

*A complete trial with Equestrian laws (would end with her sent into jail anyway)

*Another kind of punishment

I’d say Starlight was sent to a dimension of nothing but shapes, endless void, and black and white with not another living soul in it .

 

Like i said: black and white void, nothing but floating shapes and floor. 

[Megas 27,699]

I think this obsession over punishment is pretty ridiculous. I also think the the show handled her really stupidly and should have let her face the consequences of her actions, to give her something to work towards 

Edited July 20, 2023 by Megas