My Favorite Theory About Grogar

[Flash-Magnus 16]

Grogar is my favorite villain in the season 9 or even MLP show but one day in the future i and some fans will see this villain again MLP because remember what i said the story about him is nor really over. When the season 9 and the season 8 start or aired i will show so many fans created the theory but i am more interesting about the theory of Grogar but not all theory i really like it so this is the theory i really like:

1.) Grogar is the father of Discord and even all creature but not the animals and the ponies.
2.) Grogar is one of the Zodiac constellation aka Aries... because this theory i think Grogar still be alive in out there.
3.) Grogar kills or kidnapped Applejack's parents aka Bright Mac and Pear Butter.
4.) Grogar still be alive after the season 9... i really love this theory unlit i really want to know everything about him.
5.) Grogar back to Tambelon... Hmm... maybe he send self to go back because we didn't know who powerful is Grogar? Maybe he is in now is different than he is in the past.

And this is a theory i didn't like it but now this is become real:

Grogar is Discord... this is make me to blame Discord as one of the characters in the MLP... I hate him.

[Latecomer 440]

You probably won't like my old theory either.

Grogar is a fictional character only found in books.

[Hierok 11,833]

I really do not understand what you been trying to say here. What is you favourite theory? 

[Rumpelstiltskin 45]

My personal theory about Grogar is that he's like Discord in that he's a spirit representing an abstract concept. In Grogar's case, it would be fear. I think he could very well have been as powerful as Discord if not more so, because of how his bell was able to withstand the Friendship Beam unharmed, which is something not even Discord could manage. The Friendship Beam couldn't even release the magic inside of the bell like it did with Tirek when he first stole all the magic in Equestria, which leads me to believe that it's similar to Sauron's Ring in that it can't be destroyed except by the powers that made it. 

 

[nightshroud96 124]

10 hours ago, Rumpelstiltskin said:

My personal theory about Grogar is that he's like Discord in that he's a spirit representing an abstract concept. In Grogar's case, it would be fear. I think he could very well have been as powerful as Discord if not more so, because of how his bell was able to withstand the Friendship Beam unharmed, which is something not even Discord could manage. The Friendship Beam couldn't even release the magic inside of the bell like it did with Tirek when he first stole all the magic in Equestria, which leads me to believe that it's similar to Sauron's Ring in that it can't be destroyed except by the powers that made it. 

 

Would be interesting if the only way to destroy it is using powerful dark magic or at least have said dark magic mixed in to some beam to destroy it.
 

[Sunlight Glisten 368]

We know grogar is still alive. Case and point: if a creature possesses enough magic (alicorns, tirek, discord, everything in tartarus) they seem to be able to live for thousands of years if not forever. The only refute could be that he was not powerful and all his power resided in his bell. When gusty the great took the bell she theoretically could have taken his immortality. 

I like to think that maybe he is still out there as discord believed. Biding his time untill the moment is right. Unlike discord he is not powerful. But now that his bell is freed from an impenetrable prison and probably on display in an easy pickings canterlot musium, I can see him making his return. Perhaps as an opener to generation 5....

[nightshroud96 124]

Just now, Sunlight Glisten said:

We know grogar is still alive. Case and point: if a creature possesses enough magic (alicorns, tirek, discord, everything in tartarus) they seem to be able to live for thousands of years if not forever. The only refute could be that he was not powerful and all his power resided in his bell. When gusty the great took the bell she theoretically could have taken his immortality. 

I like to think that maybe he is still out there as discord believed. Biding his time untill the moment is right. Unlike discord he is not powerful. But now that his bell is freed from an impenetrable prison and probably on display in an easy pickings canterlot musium, I can see him making his return. Perhaps as an opener to generation 5....

I think someone mentioned about Luna saying "magic don't just disappear" or something in the season 4 finale. Implying magic can't truly be eliminated, be it good magic or dark magic. 
Perhaps Grogar's magic went back to him upon the trio losing it or said magic is still within the trio(although weakened at the moment) and then the bell just moves on its own to get the magic back. Ending up freeing the trio from stone while seeking out its master and if he happens to be dead, perhaps giving his magic back to his remains ends up reviving him.
I mean, I heard his G1 counterpart was a necromancer so I bet at least his magic can bring him back to life if it returns to him.

[Latecomer 440]

9 hours ago, nightshroud96 said:

I think someone mentioned about Luna saying "magic don't just disappear" or something in the season 4 finale. Implying magic can't truly be eliminated, be it good magic or dark magic. 
Perhaps Grogar's magic went back to him upon the trio losing it or said magic is still within the trio(although weakened at the moment) and then the bell just moves on its own to get the magic back. Ending up freeing the trio from stone while seeking out its master and if he happens to be dead, perhaps giving his magic back to his remains ends up reviving him.
I mean, I heard his G1 counterpart was a necromancer so I bet at least his magic can bring him back to life if it returns to him.

Quote

I mean, I heard his G1 counterpart was a necromancer

Nope - it's just a fanon thing.