Which Pony can live up to another Element of Harmony best?

[Xievie 498]

Well, I was thinking about this just now, but I was wondering on what you guys thought about this.

 

Well, as the name asks, "Which Pony can live up to another Element of Harmony best?" who do you think could for EACH element.

 

Try not to be bias on this. You may like one pony better, but try to look into their personality before voting, and comparing it with other personalities.

 

Also, for Magic, assume they all had horns. Who would be using it the most, be the most knowledgable, etc?

[Zerul 554]

Kindness-Pinkie easily.She pretty much spends all her earnings on her friends without thinking twice about it.

Generosity- Pinkie/AJ

Loyalty-AJ

Magic- Only Reality warper.Take a guess

This is all IMO of course

Edited July 23, 2012 by OdinForced

[Half-Note 273]

Kindness: Applejack- She always steps up to help everypony.

 

Honesty: Twilight Sparkle- Rarely has she ever lied.

 

Generosity: Fluttershy- Generosity is hoof in hoof with kindness.

 

Loyalty: Applejack- She never betrayed anypony.

 

Laughter: Rainbow Dash- She loves pranks just like Pinkie.

 

Magic: Pinkie Pie- 4th wall magic.

Edited July 23, 2012 by Half-Note

[Doctor XFizzle 8,669]

The only one that was a no-brainer for me was Applejack -> Loyalty. Sure she ditched Ponyville when she didn't win the rodeo, but she is incredibly trustworthy and reliable and an anchor for her friends.

[Xievie 498]

I like how everypony is voting Twilight over Pinkie Pie and Fluttershy for Honesty.

She broke her normal promise with Spike. The orther two don't seem to have personalities to break a promise, and have never done it yet! And Rainbow Dash... I think i'll pass on her being the first to trust. To keep a secret or tell me the truth.

 

Pinkie Pie is also too silly to take a promise seriously to care about telling anypony. She even MADE the Pinkie Pie Promise. Yeah.

 

Then Fluttershy would die at the thought of being dishonest to her very best friends.

Edited July 23, 2012 by Suskel

[Pegasistersincethe80s 126]

Applejack and loyalty:

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7nVjxIKgaGc

[Half-Note 273]

I like how everypony is voting Twilight over Pinkie Pie and Fluttershy for Honesty.

She broke her normal promise with Spike. The orther two don't seem to have personalities to break a promise, and have never done it yet! And Rainbow Dash... I think i'll pass on her being the first to trust. To keep a secret or tell me the truth.

 

Pinkie Pie is also too silly to take a promise seriously to care about telling anypony. She even MADE the Pinkie Pie Promise. Yeah.

 

Then Fluttershy would die at the thought of being dishonest to her very best friends.

 

Fluttershy lied to everyone when she had the Phoenix.

 

As for TS. Failing to keep a promise due to inability to do so is different from lying.

[Xievie 498]

 

 

Fluttershy lied to everyone when she had the Phoenix.

 

As for TS. Failing to keep a promise due to inability to do so is different from lying.

 

Both Fluttershy and AppleJack have lied for good reasons, so I respect that.

Twilight however, lied because she.. Err, I guess she WANTED to tell somepony then.

 

I guess everypony has to lie under pressure SOME TIME, but Twilight really blew that one.

[Dundermiffly 27]

Out of all of these, I would say that Applejack/loyalty and Fluttershy/generosity are the most prominent

[ZStrike37 107]

Applejack is the most dependable and LOYAL of ponies. She says it herself. And since she's the Element of Honesty, that's not a lie. Therefore, Applejack would be Loyalty.

 

Not to mention Generosity. Why did all of them want to go to the Gala at the end of Season 1? Twilight wanted to spend time with Celestia, Pinkie wanted to be at a huge shindig, RD wanted to impress the Wonderbolts, Rarity wanted to meet her fantasty Prince Charming, and Flutters wanted to meet new animals. AJ however, wanted to earn money for HER FAMILY. Oh yeah, and GIVE all her winnings from the Equestrian Rodeo to help fix up Town Hall.

 

And maybe even Kindness. I mean, she had a WHOLE orchard to harvest and she still manages to take time out of her schedule to help her friends with tasks they've asked of her. Now that was some intense kindness.

[Xievie 498]

Generosity is really hard.

 

We have Twilight, all around great friend. She wanted everpony to be at the gala, and let EVERYONE come. If one doesn't get ticket, forget it, not even going herself.

Applejack is also generally an all around good friend. Can't see her not generous.

Pinkie is, well... Pinkie. Can't ever catch her mean, now can you? She even sung a song about sharing!

Fluttershy is VERY generous. Cares for a bunch of animals day to day for mothing in return. She's so kind... Kindness also bleed into generosity, too.

 

My vote was Fluttershy because of her personality, she just can't be selfish. CAN'T.

[FinalGamer 192]

Alright, that's actually a pretty good question! Lemme think.

 

Rarity would do Kindness easily since it comes hand in hand with her Generosity. It also explains why her and Fluttershy are very close friends since their elements compliment each other greatly.

 

Pinkie Pie I see as being the most Honest because she is the least likely to lie for any vindictive reasons. Even then she's a terrible liar and cracks easily under pressure from such. Even if she's legendary for her secrets and promises, that is still a facet of honesty since honesty is not just about being true. It is also about GAINING trust from others.

 

Fluttershy can easily do Generosity because again, it comes hand in hand with Kindness usually. We've already seen her try to help others out, as well as nursing animals back to health.

 

Applejack already contains some facets of Loyalty. She's already deeply loyal to her friends, INCREDIBLY loyal to her family despite her misguided venture in The Last Roundup since it was all for their sakes, and also, Loyalty retains a similar facet with Honesty in that they are both about gaining the trust of others.

 

Laughter goes to Rainbow Dash easily, as both a fellow prankster with Pinkie Pie, but also because Laughter seems to be more about boosting the morale of your friends. The Element of Laughter seems to be about keeping others happy, and as such, that means keeping their spirits up i.e their morale. Rainbow Dash does this to some extent even if not always through laughter (and even a few of her pranks are a LITTLE bit mean).

That said, she has the potential for it, if it was her element.

 

And finally for magic...Pinkie Pie. Because, seriously, she is a goddamn reality warper.

 

 

 

...huh, I feel kinda bad that I can't imagine Twilight as being anything BUT the element of Magic. Probably because she represents the best thing of all, the very faith and belief that comes with Magic. And just like with Magic, if you believe in your friends, and have faith in them, then everything will turn out alright. Usually.

Edited July 23, 2012 by FinalGamer

[Leo dash 79]

Alright, that's actually a pretty good question! Lemme think.

 

Rarity would do Kindness easily since it comes hand in hand with her Generosity. It also explains why her and Fluttershy are very close friends since their elements compliment each other greatly.

 

Pinkie Pie I see as being the most Honest because she is the least likely to lie for any vindictive reasons. Even then she's a terrible liar and cracks easily under pressure from such. Even if she's legendary for her secrets and promises, that is still a facet of honesty since honesty is not just about being true. It is also about GAINING trust from others.

 

Fluttershy can easily do Generosity because again, it comes hand in hand with Kindness usually. We've already seen her try to help others out, as well as nursing animals back to health.

 

Applejack already contains some facets of Loyalty. She's already deeply loyal to her friends, INCREDIBLY loyal to her family despite her misguided venture in The Last Roundup since it was all for their sakes, and also, Loyalty retains a similar facet with Honesty in that they are both about gaining the trust of others.

 

Laughter goes to Rainbow Dash easily, as both a fellow prankster with Pinkie Pie, but also because Laughter seems to be more about boosting the morale of your friends. The Element of Laughter seems to be about keeping others happy, and as such, that means keeping their spirits up i.e their morale. Rainbow Dash does this to some extent even if not always through laughter (and even a few of her pranks are a LITTLE bit mean).

That said, she has the potential for it, if it was her element.

 

And finally for magic...Pinkie Pie. Because, seriously, she is a goddamn reality warper.

 

 

 

...huh, I feel kinda bad that I can't imagine Twilight as being anything BUT the element of Magic. Probably because she represents the best thing of all, the very faith and belief that comes with Magic. And just like with Magic, if you believe in your friends, and have faith in them, then everything will turn out alright. Usually.

 

rarity kindness bwahahahah like when she manipulated spike to give her the fire ruby or when she manipulated to get the asparagus from that one pony? i have to go with aj for kindness generosity and loyalty rarity for magic rainbow for laughter and twilight for honesty

[FinalGamer 192]

rarity kindness bwahahahah like when she manipulated spike to give her the fire ruby or when she manipulated to get the asparagus from that one pony? i have to go with aj for kindness generosity and loyalty rarity for magic rainbow for laughter and twilight for honesty

 

Oh snap, good point, she IS a bit of a manipulative witchy-chicky isn't she? XD Weeeeeellllll my vote's stuck now isn't it?

[Midnightive 458]

Kindness i want for AJ Because she's always helping the town.

Honest i went to Pinkiepie because you know... she's always honest about how she feels and stuff

Loyaty i went Twilight Sparkle

Laughter rainbow dah

and then magic i think i want rainbowdash as you know... she's a badass!

[Yellow Diamond 7,569]

As others have already said, AJ acting as the Element of Loyalty (if she were not already the Element of Honesty) makes the most sense. Her steadfast honesty is tied into the loyalty she feels toward her friends and family. It also makes AJ occasionally stubborn, when it comes to family tradition.

 

Pinkie could double for the Element of Kindness, given her willingness to befriend everypony. She has glaring blindspots which Fluttershy does not possess (e.g., not leaving others alone even when they explicitly request privacy), but her end goal is to increase the happiness of her friends and neighbors.

 

Rainbow Dash rather easily fits into the Element of Laughter. Her propensity for pranks (generally good natured ones) and desire to entertain others adapts well to that particular element.

 

Regarding the Element of Generosity, I again went with Pinkie Pie. The primary hiccup is her aforementioned myopia. On the other hoof, throwing parties for everypony, and putting a great deal of effort into said parties, is rather generous---not to mention her desire to see everypony smile.

 

I selected Rarity for the Element of Magic. I am admittedly biased toward selecting another natural unicorn. Rarity's attention to detail and ability to turn the otherwise ordinary into the extraordinary could be liberally described as "magic."

 

The Element of Honesty is a bit tricky, but I went with Twilight. She is the most likely to seek the truth of the matter, even if it may be motivated primarily by personal concerns rather than a more abstract sense of truth (e.g., "A Canterlot Wedding"). Twilight will also readily offer advice to her friends.

 

If I had to swap out one of the ponies to accomodate Fluttershy, it would probably be for the Element of Generosity. The reasons for such a selection should be otherwise obvious.

Edited July 23, 2012 by Thereisnospoon303

[Kalakauer 20]

Mh.. I guess laughter would also fit with Rainbow Dash.

And of course:

Pinkie Pie and Loyalty. It's very easy to say why:

Edited July 23, 2012 by Kalakauer

[pinkiefan1287 610]

For Pinkie Pie it would be kindness.

 

Generosity would be would be a tie for Apple Jack and Fluttershy. Apple Jack would also be good for the element of Loyalty.

 

Rainbow Dash would be good for laughter. Even if it is in her own way.

 

Twilight and Rarity are the hard ones to pick different elements for.

[Archangel 143]

For Kindness I picked Pinkie. Since she gives people free parties and food, and tries to cheer them up and all sorts of nice stuff.

 

For Honesty I picked Rainbow, since loyalty and honesty often go hand in hand. Without honesty, it's hard to be loyal. Or rather, it's hard to be loyal and dishonest.

 

For Generosity I picked Pinkie, y'know, free parties, food, and all sorts of stuff.

 

For Loyalty I picked Twilight, since she has never considered abandoning her friends, and didn't abandon Equestria, and therefore everypony, when she was told to stop being mean to Cadence (AKA Chrysalis).

 

For Laughter, Rainbow, she pulls pranks and loves having fun. Very critical to someone who laughs a lot.

 

For Magic, well, who else BUT Rarity. I mean, I know you said pretend the others have horns, but aside from the fact that the Element of Magic knows a lot of magic and is really powerful, there isn't really much to that particular element. Meaning that it would have to be somepony who we can gauge her magical strength and knowledge. Which only leaves Rarity and Twilight. Since Twilight is the element of Magic, this leaves only Rarity.

Edited July 25, 2012 by Archangel

[NavelColt 22,880]

Dash would be honesty, she says it like it is. I'd also peg her for laughter, because she likes pranks, parties and making jokes and having fun like Pinkie.

 

Applejack would be kindness. She's polite, friendly and one of the most mature of the six of them. She could also be loyalty.

 

Rarity could be magic. If she didn't focus on clothes, she could probably be very good at overall magic.

 

Fluttershy would be generosity. She is so kind that she'd do anything for anyone if it was within her power.

[Radiance64 7,053]

Kindness- Twilight because she tends to be very kind towards her friends, plus she's very modest.

Honesty- Rainbow Dash, because she's never afraid to speak her mind, plus Friendship is Witchcraft said so.

Generosity- Fluttershy's a no brainer here. She's very generous towards her animal friends, plus her unassertiveness tends to lead to some unintentional generosity(see: Putting Your Hoof Down)

Loyalty- Applejack, because she's very loyal to her family and friends, and also because of FiW.

Laughter- Rarity, because she does unexpected things that make me laugh.

Magic- Pinkie Pie, because of her numerous superpowers.

[weegeez 150]

Pinkie Pie

Laughter: No need for explanation

Honesty: Pinkie Promises?

Kindness: Always tries to makes friends smile

Loyalty: I have never seen Pinkie ditch her friends over anything ever on the show and doesn't have the personality to either, she is more loyal then RD is IMO

Generosity: I can imagine her being a giving pony, she cares for her friends as we know

Magic: SHE BREAKS THE FOURTH WALL! MAGEEK! Oh and Pinkie sense

Edited July 25, 2012 by weegeez