MLP Forums Best Fan Tournament - Mane 6 (Results)

[Pinkazoid 3,493]

I won?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h0OsqPhqLDo

 

TAKE THAT PINKAZOID! TAKE THAT FLIPTURN! I WON! Every time you say you're best fan, the only response you're gonna get from me is a link to this topic.

 

I'd like to take this opportunity to thank each and every one the 34 people who voted for me. You guys are awesome, I would like you to pat yourselves on the back. You deserve it. The rest of you are dead to me.

;^;

 

BUT I'M TAKING IT EASILY

 

PFSH

PFSH

 

I FORGOT THIS EVEN EXISTED, I DON'T EVEN CARE, LALALALA, SO MUCH NOT CARING ABOUT THIS, SO MUCH OF IT

[Clarity 3,094]

Yes! I won! Yeah, I already thanked you all, but, thank you all again.  

 

However--and forgive me for my apparent lack of modesty--I think I do really deserve it. Yes, I may sound arrogant and be bashing on spas, but (no offense) you really did nothing to earn points for being the "best fan", but rather "best lover". Again, those two things are different. Contributing to pony discussions is what really makes a best fan the best fan, and with that thought in mind I think Stellafara deserved the second place of being the best Applejack fan, rather than Spazzy. Sorry bro, but you're not the best fan in my eyes. You definitely love AJ the most, though. However, those two things are very separate, even if they don't seem to be.

 

 

Do you think that, if a newbie RD fan comes to the forums and spends all day in Cloudsdale, saying they love Rainbow Dash so much they want to fuck her, all the time, will people believe them? And they did nothing in the real world of Show Discussions and Sugarcube Corners. Is he the best fan?

 

In my eyes...*cough* not really.

 

Anyway, I doubt that I got any brownie points for my arrogant rant above, but eh...wanted to make something clear. Because, after all, you did get 21 votes Good game, though, and I knew you wanted me to win anyway because you agreed with all the above. At least I think you did...

 

Just wanna ask those 21 people, I would just like 2 reasons why you think he's a bigger fan (note the word fan). I won't be offended so throw all your hell at me.

[spas-ticShotty 3,584]

 

Yes! I won! Yeah, I already thanked you all, but, thank you all again.

 

However--and forgive me for my apparent lack of modesty--I think I do really deserve it. Yes, I may sound arrogant and be bashing on spas, but (no offense) you really did nothing to earn points for being the "best fan", but rather "best lover". Again, those two things are different. Contributing to pony discussions is what really makes a best fan the best fan, and with that thought in mind I think Stellafara deserved the second place of being the best Applejack fan, rather than Spazzy. Sorry bro, but you're not the best fan in my eyes. You definitely love AJ the most, though. However, those two things are very separate, even if they don't seem to be.

 

 

Do you think that, if a newbie RD fan comes to the forums and spends all day in Cloudsdale, saying they love Rainbow Dash so much they want to fuck her, all the time, will people believe them? And they did nothing in the real world of Show Discussions and Sugarcube Corners. Is he the best fan?

 

In my eyes...*cough* not really.

 

Anyway, I doubt that I got any brownie points for my arrogant rant above, but eh...wanted to make something clear. Because, after all, you did get 21 votes Good game, though, and I knew you wanted me to win anyway because you agreed with all the above. At least I think you did...

 

Just wanna ask those 21 people, I would just like 2 reasons why you think he's a bigger fan (note the word fan). I won't be offended so throw all your hell at me.

I think "lover" and "fan" are very similiar to each other, but you probably won't listen anyways. Hey, atleast you called be the bigger lover.

 

I'm glad that this wasn't a "Best lover" competition. If it was, and the results were the exact same, I would be pretty pissed right now >:c (Don't get any ideas RD92. I don't want a Best Lover thread only to lose to Clari a 2nd time).

Edited January 27, 2013 by spas-ticShotty

[Clarity 3,094]

 

I think "lover" and "fan" are very similiar to each other, but you probably won't listen anyways.

Gee, I detect sarcasm in that sentence. :V

 

A lover is basically what the majority of the fandom contains. They fall in love with colorful pixels on a television screen. They say "ZOMG I LOVE HIM/HER SO MUCH, I WISH I COULD LIFT UP HER TAIL AND--"

 

A fan is an entirely different story. They like the pixels, but they don't go overboard like above. They contribute to discussions. They involve themselves in fanfics of their favorite pony. Or fanart, or any media, really. And if someone wants to be the best fan on these forums, forums, note it, then it's best that they would have discussions rather than anything else. If someone wants to be the best fan on, say, FiMfiction.net, then writing, or reading fanfics would probably get you brownie points for that.

 

A best fan is certainly not someone who obsesses with having sex with their favorite. 

[spas-ticShotty 3,584]

Gee, I detect sarcasm in that sentence. :V

 

A lover is basically what the majority of the fandom contains. They fall in love with colorful pixels on a television screen. They say "ZOMG I LOVE HIM/HER SO MUCH, I WISH I COULD LIFT UP HER TAIL AND--"

 

A fan is an entirely different story. They like the pixels, but they don't go overboard like above. They contribute to discussions. They involve themselves in fanfics of their favorite pony. Or fanart, or any media, really. And if someone wants to be the best fan on these forums, forums, note it, then it's best that they would have discussions rather than anything else. If someone wants to be the best fan on, say, FiMfiction.net, then writing, or reading fanfics would probably get you brownie points for that.

 

A best fan is certainly not someone who obsesses with having sex with their favorite. 

A best fan can obsess with having sex with their favorite. I dunno what you're talking about.

 

I think you're just trying to find reasons so that people won't consider me best fan :/. I don't consider myself it, but I consider myself close.

Edited January 27, 2013 by spas-ticShotty

[Clarity 3,094]

 

A best fan can obsess with having sex with their favorite. I dunno what you're talking about.

Well, they can, but that's not a candidate in being best fan unless the person at the same time contributes to discussions.

 

 

I think you're just trying to find reasons so that people won't consider me best fan :/.

Because I don't think you're the best fan. Read my post again. :V I'm saying MY reasons why I don't think you're the best fan, and if people agree with me, that's their choice. Rather, I'm confused of the 21 votes (not saying that I don't think you deserve them, but rather the reason why). That's why my rant's up there in the first place, because I think people may be mistaking best fan and best lover.

 

I might sound too arrogant but that's what I believe. 

[spas-ticShotty 3,584]

Well, they can, but that's not a candidate in being best fan unless the person at the same time contributes to discussions.

 

 

Because I don't think you're the best fan. Read my post again. :V I'm saying MY reasons why I don't think you're the best fan, and if people agree with me, that's their choice. Rather, I'm confused of the 21 votes (not saying that I don't think you deserve them, but rather the reason why). That's why my rant's up there in the first place, because I think people may be mistaking best fan and best lover.

 

I might sound too arrogant but that's what I believe. 

Confused on the 21 votes? Maybe they consider lover and fan to be the same thing? I dunno.

 

As for the 21 votes, danke to whoever voted for me.

[Champion RD92 8,658]

Gee, I detect sarcasm in that sentence. :V

 

A lover is basically what the majority of the fandom contains. They fall in love with colorful pixels on a television screen. They say "ZOMG I LOVE HIM/HER SO MUCH, I WISH I COULD LIFT UP HER TAIL AND--"

 

A fan is an entirely different story. They like the pixels, but they don't go overboard like above. They contribute to discussions. They involve themselves in fanfics of their favorite pony. Or fanart, or any media, really. And if someone wants to be the best fan on these forums, forums, note it, then it's best that they would have discussions rather than anything else. If someone wants to be the best fan on, say, FiMfiction.net, then writing, or reading fanfics would probably get you brownie points for that.

 

A best fan is certainly not someone who obsesses with having sex with their favorite.

Who's to say you can't be both a lover and a fan? I think you can love your favorite pony the most, and also be the best fan of that pony.

[Clarity 3,094]

 

Who's to say you can't be both a lover and a fan? I think you can love your favorite pony the most, and also be the best fan of that pony.

I never said you can't be both at once. :V Except that Spas wasn't a fan in my eyes, only a lover. That was my point.

 

 

Confused on the 21 votes? Maybe they consider lover and fan to be the same thing? I dunno.

*shrug* That's why I'm asking. 

[spas-ticShotty 3,584]

I never said you can't be both at once. :V Except that Spas wasn't a fan in my eyes, only a lover. That was my point.

 

 

*shrug* That's why I'm asking. 

Err, how am I not a fan, though ? I mean, if I wasn't a fan of Applejack, I wouldn't be a lover of hers as well. Think about it for a second.

[Clarity 3,094]

Err, how am I not a fan, though ? I mean, if I wasn't a fan of Applejack, I wouldn't be a lover of hers as well. Think about it for a second.

Okay, okay...fine, you're a fan. But you're never going to be a bigger fan than Stellafara, she contributes a lot more to discussions than you do. Sorry. I forgot we weren't allowed to have opinions. :V

Edited January 27, 2013 by ~Chaotic Clarity~

[spas-ticShotty 3,584]

Okay, okay...fine, you're a fan. But you're never going to be a bigger fan than Stellafara, she contributes a lot more to discussions than you do. Sorry. I forgot we weren't allowed to have opinions. :V

That's because I've probably already contributed a lot in Applejack discussions back in the day :/. What else is there to talk about that?

 

But hey, congrats on that victory.

[Pinkazoid 3,493]

I couldn't help drawing something related to this thread, and my carelessness about it, and how I'm totally not bothered by it so here it is

 

 

 

It looks somewhat creepy to me, I don't know, so just beware or some chiz

 

 

 

 

 

[An Old Head 4,816]

I won?

 

TAKE THAT PINKAZOID! TAKE THAT FLIPTURN! I WON! Every time you say you're best fan, the only response you're gonna get from me is a link to this topic.

 

I'd like to take this opportunity to thank each and every one the 34 people who voted for me. You guys are awesome, I would like you to pat yourselves on the back. You deserve it. The rest of you are dead to me.

 

Pssh, I don't even care if I'm not the biggest fan. The only thing that matters is that I'm a fan at all

 

(And I've only been here a month, so I'm super pleased for my nomination alone.)

 

Well done to all the winners - it's great to see all this spirit and pride in your ponies of choice.

Edited January 27, 2013 by Flipturn

[Twiliscael 3,960]

Are you serious? Do you see how hard I'm defending Twilight in the most attractive pony tournament? I've been out there for DAYS thrashing and kicking away all Lyra fanboys and so far it's successful. She is winning, and she was behind by a bunch before I came.

[Lightning Fluttershy 1,844]

Second is alright I suppose. I'm honestly super happy that 17 people acknowledged me as best Fluttershy fan.Thank you all, it means a lot.

[spas-ticShotty 3,584]

Are you serious? Do you see how hard I'm defending Twilight in the most attractive pony tournament? I've been out there for DAYS thrashing and kicking away all Lyra fanboys and so far it's successful. She is winning, and she was behind by a bunch before I came.

Give me credit for voting for Twi even though I want nothing to do with that crapjob competition anymore :/.

 

I only voted for Hylian since there was no real Twi fan that became vocal, but Hylian came along and I was like "m'kay".

[Twiliscael 3,960]

Give me credit for voting for Twi even though I want nothing to do with that crapjob competition anymore :/.

 

I only voted for Hylian since there was no real Twi fan that became vocal, but Hylian came along and I was like "m'kay".

Vocal? VOCAL? WHADDYA MEAN I'M NOT VOCAL?!?! Do you NOT see me swagging around with this sexeh avatar, constantly spewing Twilight quotes, and ACTUALLY BEING THERE TO DEFEND HER IN THE THREADS?

*facedesks*

 

(Of course I'm only kidding. A little bit)

[Stellafera 3,836]

 

I'm pleasantly surprised by my 10 non self votes (maybe it's just the result of being both literally and figuratively the third option?). I'm not quite as devoted or focused in my appreciation as Clarity or Spazzy; I write about how much I like RD almost as much as I write about how I like AJ! I mean, the reason why I voted for myself was because 

 

A. Voting for yourself is fun

 

B. Clarity and Spazzy are both great fans, and the reason why their definitions clash is because they are awesome fans in different ways. Spazzy is the adoring fan, the one who absolutely loves their favorite to pieces. Clarity is more of the fan that's got their favorite's back all the time, the one ready to leap to defend them. I think that both types are valuable, so I didn't want to chose between them.

 

Not because I thought I was really best fan. Congratulations to all the winners! There's definitely some of those that were my personal picks too.

Edited January 27, 2013 by Stellafera

[spas-ticShotty 3,584]

 

 

I'm pleasantly surprised by my 10 non self votes (maybe it's just the result of being both literally and figuratively the third option?). I'm not quite as devoted or focused in my appreciation as Clarity or Spazzy; I write about how much I like RD almost as much as I write about how I like AJ! I mean, the reason why I voted for myself was because 

 

A. Voting for yourself is fun

 

B. Clarity and Spazzy are both great fans, and the reason why their definitions clash is because they are awesome fans in different ways. Spazzy is the adoring fan, the one who absolutely loves her favorite to pieces. Clarity is more of the fan that's got their favorite's back all the time, the one ready to leap to defend them. I think that both types are valuable, so I didn't want to chose between them.

 

Not because I thought I was really best fan. Congratulations to all the winners! There's definitely some of those that were my personal picks too.

I'mma boy ._.

 

But I agree with you there. I'm absolutely in love with Applejack, while Clari tends to defend her in a very dangirlish manner.

[duidamasterXD 9,627]

I was going to finally make the big reveal over who I voted for, but to be honest I don't remember who I voted for Pinkie, Rarity or Twilight, so I'll just talk about the other three.

 

I generally have an ironclad rule against voting for myself, but I broke it because I'm a douchebag I feel like I've spent loads of time talking about why I like Rainbow and defending her from the villainous haters. I've noticed that when she's in a scene, even if she's in the background my eyes lock on to her and then refocus to see what's actually happening . I read tons of fanfics about her to try to explore different potential sides to her personality and she's on my mind quite a lot throughout the day.

 

For Fluttershy I voted for Dimitri because he's obviously very devoted to Flutters. Over the past few weeks though I've learned that LF is a pretty big fan in his own right and I think he can get there If Dimitri doesn't murder him first.

 

For Applejack I had declared neutrality in the ongoing debate because it became clear to me that Clari and Shotty are both amazing and incredible fans but in very different ways and I don't feel like it is my place to decide whose method makes for a better fan. So I voted for Stellafera because it's obvious to me that she's a massive Applejack fan in her own right and is more than willing to talk about why. Besides, she's underrated. Applejack fans love underrated stuff

Edited January 27, 2013 by DashForever

[Wingnut 6,990]

I hope this poll hasn't generated any hard feelings as it's a glorified popularity contest. We were being asked to vote for the best fan of a particular character, not the people we talk to or like the most. And I was not blameless in that regard. My vote for best Rainbow Dash and Applejack fans went to DashForever and Stellafera respectively. Since joining this forum I have come to immensely enjoy their essay-like posts in Sugarcube Corner and Show Discussion.  Anytime I see their avatar as the last post in a thread, I always click on it because I know it's going to be something good. Heck, DashForever was the last reply to this thread just now.  But at least I can defend my vote by saying they're able to articulate very well why they love Dashie and AJ so much. On the other hand, I've had very little interaction with Clarity but the reasoning everybody gave in this thread has convinced me that she deserved to win best AJ fan.

 

My votes for the rest of the Mane 6 were unbiased opinions on who I thought was the best fan for each one. I can only dream of being a true Fluttershy fan like Comrade Dimitri!

Edited January 27, 2013 by ~Chaotic Wingnut~

[Dimitri Hammer 3,645]

I don't like gloating at all, and I just wish to say once more I appreciate the votes for me.

 

As said before, I not wish to be...explicit...with Fluttershy. That's downright awful. I'd say things to protect and prove how great she is, I'd debate till you are aggravated and wish to kill me. I don't back down dammit! I take topic or thing I love and will fight to prove how wonderful it is.

 

If my English was better I would be debating and lecturing all the time! Is too bad I suck at English

 

 

I just happy that you all respect a stupid old Soviet immigrant

 

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A8qakI4mDII