Evil Mane 6

[Hive King 2,001]

I got this idea from Pripyat Pony's thread that was unfortunately locked. So this one doesn't get locked, I ask you what is your opinion of an evil mane 6. Basically, just describe what you think an evil Mane 6 would be like. Here's my version of an evil Mane 6

 

Element of Cruelty=Flapping Brazen= A headstrong and cocky psycho with a mentality that might makes right. She is a brute with the intelligence of an orange and prefers to slam something until it breaks. 

Element of Cowardice=Monochrome Slug=Acts tough when in charge but will run as fast as she can when in trouble and is a sneaky traitor. Quite clever and subversive but loses control when the slightest thing goes wrong and flees. 

Element of Greed=Trinket=An active and tough tax collector for the regime, acts as the lieutenant to Dawn Shine. She hoards compulsively and keeps most of the tax money for herself, aiming to make a bed out of it.

Element of Lies=Orangejackie= A compulsive liar and lowest on the villain rank, little more than an annoyance. Her specialty is creating mazes designed to make one doubt themselves and works with Trinket to get more money out of ponies.

Element of Depression=Green Lime= If she finds anything happy, you get the axe. Acts murderously happy with the intelligence and moral compass of a child. Has only the barest of self control and actually enjoys her own pain. She however, thinks she's the only one entitled to happiness.

Element of Hatred=Dawn Shine= A creature of monstrous evil who will do nothing more than kill all due to simple sadism. Enjoys watching ponies die and is the leader of the regime. Quite simply, her ultimate goal is to destroy the planet out of spite and watch ponies die.

[Doc. Volt 2,561]

pretty nice stuff... maybe somepony can have an idea on another dark fanfic... now

[Hive King 2,001]

pretty nice stuff... maybe somepony can have an idea on another dark fanfic... now

Let's see what others think. Speaking of which, what are your versions of an Evil Mane 6?

[Winona the Dog 1,984]

That's good.

 

I feel like I'd rather have characters that have already been revealed to be the evil versions of the mane 6, but I don't think that's going to happen.

[Doc. Volt 2,561]

element of magic--> element of science, probably me (i mean my ponysona, my OC Doc Volt), everything not handable or describable isn't worth to exist, everything gotta be controlled, from nature to time, everything should be planned and engineered, also ponies lives must be planned from birth (Brave New World)

 

element of laughter--> element of mockery, everypony should be mocked about his defects and fails, theyr special ability isn't something really special, just something worthless and meaningless

 

element of loyalty--> element of betrayal, everypony is just a pawn to use to reach our objectives, everypony is a foe and an opportunity

 

element of kindness--> element of hate, nothing should be spared, everypony is just a stupid enemy that wants your head, take them first

 

element of generousity--> element of avarice, everything is yours, the others wants your stuff too... get everything before it's too late

 

element of honesty--> element of lie, your words are like a blade.. use it to reach your goals, make everypony against everypony and just walk behind them fightining

[windy_prance 114]

element of magic--> element of science, probably me (i mean my ponysona, my OC Doc Volt), everything not handable or describable isn't worth to exist, everything gotta be controlled, from nature to time, everything should be planned and engineered, also ponies lives must be planned from birth (Brave New World)

 

I have to 1000 percent disagree with the element of science as possible entry to the elements of chaos!!! That would be irresponsible for the writers to make science be portrayed as a bad thing. That just screams a hidden agenda to make the little girls watching the show disinterested and distrust science.

[Hive King 2,001]

I have to 1000 percent disagree with the element of science as possible entry to the elements of chaos!!! That would be irresponsible for the writers to make science be portrayed as a bad thing. That just screams a hidden agenda to make the little girls watching the show disinterested and distrust science.

This is more for fanfic, not really show canon. What are your evil Elements?

[windy_prance 114]

This is more for fanfic, not really show canon. What are your evil Elements?

 

I know but just the suggestion still feel irresponsible.

 

Anyway as for me...

 

Element of Laughter will become the Element of Despair. Every compliment and encouragement heard twisted into a self-harming insult in the mind of the pony that represents this element.

 

Element of Generosity will become the Element of Greed. All actions done for ones selfish wants and needs. Manipulative and petty.

 

Element of Loyalty will become the Element of Treachery. Constantly backstabbing those around them. Careless to others feeling and does such deeds purely for their own amusement.

 

Element of Honesty will become the Element of Lies. A pathological liar who adds more lies on top of lies since telling the truth is "boring" and "uncomfortable". Enjoys the attention it brings both positive or negative.

 

Element of Kindness will become the Element of Cruelty. Physically and verbally attacks and demeans anything weaker than oneself. Thrilled at the sight of the pain and suffering of another.

 

All together instead of the Element of Magic, the Element of War is formed. *insert the Major's speech from Hellsing Ultimate here*

[Doc. Volt 2,561]

I have to 1000 percent disagree with the element of science as possible entry to the elements of chaos!!! That would be irresponsible for the writers to make science be portrayed as a bad thing. That just screams a hidden agenda to make the little girls watching the show disinterested and distrust science.

ehi man calm down.. i am a real engineer.. science is MY LIFE, i am not talking about normal science but corrupted and brought to the limit one, like the one portataied in Brave New Worldl of Huxley http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brave_New_World

 

"the novel anticipates developments in reproductive technology, sleep-learning, psychological manipulation, and operant conditioning that combine to profoundly change society."

 

that means life already planned from birth

Edited November 25, 2013 by Doc. Volt

[Declen 118]

Some time ago I had the idea of anti-mane-six. I made a topic about it which can be found here.

Edited November 25, 2013 by Declen

[Koelath 445]

My opinion on an evil mane six...

 

 

...

 

"Bad fanfic."

[Phoenix237 353]

Element of magic--> Bearer of Mundane

Mundane could be referred to Pertaining of the earth in contrast to spiritual (or unnatural) views or elements. Was also used for a species in a film called the mundanes. The mundanes have no concept of magic, they're completely blind to it, our ways are strange to them.

 

Element of Honesty--> Bearer of Deceit

Deceit is basically lying and deceiving, plus it sounds cooler

 

Element of Loyalty--> Bearer of Treachery

Been sai before so no explanation

 

Element of Gennerosity--> Bearer of Avarice

Avarice is basically greed to the extreme

 

Element of Laughter--> Bearer of Dispare

Constantly making others feel bad or down or worthless

 

Element of Kindness--> Bearer of cruelty

Using acts that harm others

[Doc. Volt 2,561]

and also i wasn't thinking about some fancy fanfic gettig on like the show, but abaout bad ones like cupcakes or rainbow factory wich are supposed to (not exist) not be read by such a young public

[IridscentNionios 1,420]

Element of magic--> Element of Despair ((Since magic should be named "Hope" and not Magic... doesn't make any sense if you think about it)) Discourages any attempt to get better, and keeps things the way they are... promote de-humanization de-ponynyzation whatever... and the fact that you CAN'T make a difference.

Element of Honesty--> Element of Lies ((Honesty=Truth)) Lies in any way possible and makes it appear as truth... or promotes half-truths and the evil side of the truth meaning the biased and subjective one.

Element of Loyalty--> Element of Doubt ((since loyalty=trust)) Basically enjoys tearing any bond and attachment by showing the flaws in loyalty, saying that one should be loyal and trust none but himself. 

Element of Gennerosity--> Element of Selfishness ((Since Generosity in itself is Selflessness i thought it would be fitting)) She wants everything hers, she ruins happiness by taking other's stuff like the troll of Christmas or something.

Element of Laughter--> Element of Comformity/Weakness of Spirit ((Since Laughter in itself is courage and comformity is the opposite)) She basically just enjoys keeping people in their unhappy position by telling them to "DEAL WITH IT!"

Element of Kindness--> Element of Apathy ((Since Kindness if the synonym of compassion)) She doesn't care what she does and simply lives doing whatever she pleases without giving a single concern about others.

My opinion on an evil mane six...

 

 

...

 

"Bad fanfic."

Don't you think that's a bit rude? Considering we have already seen a version of it with the Discorded ponies?

Edited November 25, 2013 by nioniosbbbb

[Koelath 445]

Don't you think that's a bit rude? Considering we have already seen a version of it with the Discorded ponies?

 

Do I think obliging the OP's request by providing my asked-for opinion is rude? No, and the suggestion that doing as others request is rude strikes me as backwards and bizarre.

 

Those were not evil variants of the cast. They were mirrored (I.E., reflected backwards) variants. They were disloyal lying jerks (Dash, AJ, Shy) but none of those qualities alone makes evil.

 

 

(Not a real spoiler, just a lot of text.)

 

 

Observation: The Discorded cast could be seen as each pony with their worst flaws magnified. 

 

Fluttershy was a jerk, magnifying her inner aggression (as also seen in the Iron Hoof episode. Her timidity keeps it in check most often.)

 

Dashie was disloyal, magnifying her pride (pride leads to selfishness leads to disloyalty.)

 

Pinkie was depressive and hateful, magnifying her insecurity (also seen in Party of One.)

 

Applejack was a liar, magnifying her know-it-all tendencies. (I've known many know-it-all types to lie just to validate their egos. If you don't know the truth, you can't call them on any of their BS.)

 

Rarity is psychotically greedy, magnifying her vanity and materialism.

 

Twilight was hopeless, magnifying her constant worries that she isn't up to the standards expected of her. (As seen throughout the series.)

 

 

 

 

 

 

[IridscentNionios 1,420]

@@Koelath, Well what if they were like this in the beggining?