Jump to content
  • entries
    7
  • comments
    44
  • views
    8,464

Why an Episode About Applejack's Parents Can Work.


Sugar Cube

1,913 views

Hello everypony! I'm Sugar Cube, and this is my first blog entry on any site ever, so please try to bear with me as I'm pretty tired, so this may or may not be very well-written. I'll try to keep it short and sweet, but knowing how I am, it probably won't be. smile.png

 

By now, it should be common knowledge amongst bronies that Applejack's parents are deceased. Lauren Faust said that if she had it her way, they would be dead, and the writers confirmed the death in Apple Family Reunion. You can visibly see two shooting stars go by twice in the episode, and these shooting stars are a subtle symbolization of Applejack's parents. It only makes sense that they are deceased, as they didn't appear at the family reunion at all, or at any point in the series thus far.

 

640px-S3E08_Applejack_Shooting_Stars.png

This is the first occurrence...

 

640px-S3E8_ending.png

And the second.

 

Now, a lot of fans have been hopeful that the show will touch upon the deaths in an episode. I think not only can it be done, but it should be done, as it will really give an added boost to Applejack's character and the Apple Family as a whole. It can provide an important lesson to the audience while potentially being a very emotional and powerful episode. And I think I speak for most people when I say I love stories that pull at the heartstrings, so to speak. The problem is is that it's pretty dark subject matter, and it might be deemed too dark for Hasbro's target audience of young girls. I can understand the concern, but I believe in the writers and their ability to make it happen without any problems. My Little Pony would not be the first cartoon to pull this off anyway. For example...

 

Does anyone remember Rugrats? One of the main characters, Chuckie Finster, had a deceased mother, and this was actually touched upon, not only in a special Mother's Day episode, but a movie that followed a few years later. Rugrats had a similar target audience of younger kids, and the characters were even more innocent in nature than our fellow ponies, as they were just babies! And yet, the writers pulled off a real tear-jerker of an episode. And bear in mind, Rugrats was on Nickelodeon and was the top show on the network for a long time. It had a bigger television audience than Friendship is Magic currently does, and I don't recall any controversy surrounding the episode. I remember watching the episode when I was just a young girl myself, and I quite loved it.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ha-vSGRuqKs

 

Here's the Rugrats episode if you want to watch it and get an idea of how the Rugrats writers handled the death of a parent.

 

Hey Arnold, which was another TV show on Nick, was very similar in that the titular character, Arnold, was implied to be an orphan until the episode "Parent's Day" revealed some backstory about Arnold's parents. I think that the show was originally going to follow a plot where Arnold finds his parents, (confirming that they were missing rather than dead) but the show got cancelled before it ever happened. Even still, the aforementioned episode never confirmed whether or not Arnold's parents were alive, but it was written in a way where you would think his parents are likely to be dead, and it was still a very emotionally powerful episode.

 

Anyway, the only thing I'm not sure about is how they would pull off an episode about Applejack's parents, simply because there's so many ways to approach it. We don't know how AJ's parents died in the first place. Would it be a mystery, or would we find out what exactly happened to them? And would the episode be more about Applejack, Apple Bloom, or both? Does the rest of the Mane Six know about AJ's parents, or are they still unaware?

 

So, tell me in the comments how you'd like for the episode to go down! How would you write an episode about Applejack's parents? Should the MLP writers develop an episode about this, or is it a bad idea? I'll be giving this some thought myself.

 

Thanks for reading everypony! biggrin.png

  • Brohoof 8

7 Comments


Recommended Comments

I think that maybe it could be that Applebloom asks Applejack/Big Mac/Granny Smith where her parents are on "parent's day" at school. It might also introduce us to Scootaloo's parents. It would be that Scootaloo and Sweetie Belle's parents are there, and Diamond Tiara (being the B*^@# she is) snarks about Applebloom's missing parents. We can learn that, even though her parents are dead, she has other ponies who care for her the same way, and that she should remember those lost, but still remember to enjoy the time left with those she love that are still alive. In a way, Granny Smith, Big Mac and Applejack are her parents, as well as her grandmother and siblings.

  • Brohoof 2
Link to comment

Dear Princess Celestia,

Today I learned that you're never alone.  And your friends are always there for you to be a shoulder to cry on when you think you ARE alone.

 

~ Your faithful students Applejack and Fluttershy

  • Brohoof 2
Link to comment

I remember both the Rugrats episode and the Hey Arnold episode and point to those to anyone who says that children can't handle that kind of subject matter. I have had an idea for a fanfic for quite a while myself that deals with this subject in it Granny Smith dies of old age and one of her last wishes was for Applejack to read particular passages in the Apple Family Diary many of which deal with her parents. And I was thinking that some of them could also go into the grandfather as well, I have this idea that Big Macintosh was very close to him but that he died when Applejack was too young to remember him much like how the parents most likely died when Applebloom was too young to remember.

  • Brohoof 1
Link to comment

I think such an episode would be very well received if and when they make one.  If they can show a brief glimpse of a funeral in progress in Hooves and Hearts Day, there is no reason they can't do this. 

 

Oh, and I can't believe this is your first blog.  With all the nice posts you've made in Show Discussion and Sugarcube Corner, I thought you would've written one a lot sooner. 

  • Brohoof 2
Link to comment

Here's one I posted in "Your Episode Ideas":


Hats Off To Yule: 

 
Synopsis: All of the Mane 6's parents had visited Ponyville for Hearth's Warming Eve this year. All except one's; Applejack's. When the outgoing country mare suddenly turns reclusive during the holiday season and stops wearing her usual stetson, her friends are determined to find out why. 
  • Brohoof 1
Link to comment

I think they could pull off an episode like that. I'd imagine it'd be a very well received episode, even to non bronies.

 

I personally would like to see a approach similar to how Hey Arnold! did it. Just one night The Apple Family (Applebloom, Applejack and Big Macintosh) are just chatting and then the subject suddenly diverges into a discussion about thier parents. They all go silent in sadness until Granny Smith comes in with a optimistic attitude and lightens up thier moods with stories about thier parents.

 

 

  • Brohoof 1
Link to comment

I think such an episode would be very well received if and when they make one.  If they can show a brief glimpse of a funeral in progress in Hooves and Hearts Day, there is no reason they can't do this. 

 

Oh, and I can't believe this is your first blog.  With all the nice posts you've made in Show Discussion and Sugarcube Corner, I thought you would've written one a lot sooner. 

 

Thanks, that's very nice of you to say. I'll have to think of some more things to blog about in the future. smile.png

 

Thanks for the comments everyone. You all posted some great ideas. I can't decide if I want the episode to be about Applejack telling the Mane Five, or Applejack and Apple Bloom having "the talk." Heck, maybe incorporate both. I definitely think Granny Smith would have a place in the episode as well.

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Join the herd!

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...