ooc Bangcolt Arena! (Fighting/Sol) (OOC)

[Unicorncob 5,681]

Oh yeah... they have their marks... you know, I need to have the CMC get their marks soon. 

 

Choose wisely

 

 

Not for their sake but your own

 

[Not Yellow Diamond 925]

 

 

Are you sure that's a good idea man? You know that's heavily canon breaking, like the recent Cadence thing. At least their mare marks were shown on merchandise. I saw a video about what could be the talent for Scoots and an image was shown of all the Crusaders as mares. No longer fillies. As for what it could mean, the video didn't say. You can probably find this image or the video.

 

Actually, it wouldn't be breaking canon since the episode, "The Cutie Mark Crusaders" confirmed there talents as did Michelle Creber, and the two other actors for the CMC. So it wouldn't be breaking canon.

 

What part of the Cadence thing was breaking Canon? 

[J.R. 3,183]

 

 

Kevin could come with Fluttershy if he wants to ask?

Let's do it.

@,

Where's Flutters right now?

[Unicorncob 5,681]

Cadence losing her magic permanently is all kinds of canon breaking. Where were you going with that dude?

 

Yeah, you kinda...did that and then left it >.>

[Not Yellow Diamond 925]

 

 

Is that a spoiler for a future episode? Cause I know I haven't seen one titled like this yet. Cadence losing her magic permanently is all kinds of canon breaking. Where were you going with that dude?

 

Nope, Season one epsiode eighteen.  

 

 

 

Cadence losing her magic permanently is all kinds of canon breaking. Where were you going with that dude?

 

Be patient and you'll see. Also, it's not breaking canon, I have altered it in no such way. I just added something new which is legit

[Not Yellow Diamond 925]

 

 

That he did. That he did. Just wondering where it's leading is all.

 

Well, just wait. And if you can name one way it broke Canon, I'd love to hear it 

[P-Jay 1,987]

I love how Night Tracer says, he could pull a few strings, and possibly get Rune a chance to perform, and then he closes in after hours... when nopony is there, not even V.I.P because you know... it's closed... Just staff, and demands a spot because of NT... How unprofessional...That's practically tresspassing and not to mention lying

...so how do i roll with this?

[Not Yellow Diamond 925]

 

 

...so how do i roll with this?

 

Night Tracer will just address it 

[Unicorncob 5,681]

@

 

We didn't say you broke canon, we were talking about the Cadence thing

[Dust and Memories 557]

Hey, , I need a bit of time on the mic for Wilhelm at the party, preferably near the end.

 

Also, I'll be at a Shakespeare play all the rest of the day, so no party crashing until I get back around 11:00 EST.

Edited July 19, 2015 by Orion Caelum

[J.R. 3,183]

Hey, , I need a bit of time on the mic for Wilhelm at the party, preferably near the end.

 

Also, I'll be at a Shakespeare play all the rest of the day, so no party crashing until I get back around 11:00 EST.

Ok, good luck bro.

@,

And if Will gets some time, I want IB to crack some jokes onstage.

[J.R. 3,183]

So Ice Lektra just flew off as originally planned. She doesn't have company so I'll be going off of whatever happens that I see as an opening.

 

I'll be posting kinda randomly depending on who else is around, and probably gonna wait for the CMC/twins group with Fair.

Sorry if I was being mean with you earlier about that.

[Not Yellow Diamond 925]

 

 

Um, Cadence is supposed to have magic and she doesn't now in Arena. How is that not canon breaking?   Sorry if I confused you there bud. Was not talking about the CMC but Cadence.

 

It's not "Breaking" canon to have that happen. It's going off of it. I didn't go against anything that was canon.

 

 

 

Hey, Flying Far, I need a bit of time on the mic for Wilhelm at the party, preferably near the end.   Also, I'll be at a Shakespeare play all the rest of the day, so no party crashing until I get back around 11:00 EST.

 

 

 

 

@Flying Far, And if Will gets some time, I want IB to crack some jokes onstage.

 

What do you need the mic for? Explain to me, you can tell me in a PM so it isn't giving anything away. I'd like to know and if it's another "performance" like singing, it better of been in your profile beforehand and I've checked both. Because, this stacking on abilities is ridiculous. IMO 

 

And Ice,  "Cracking jokes." Isn't really an activity for this party. One i imagine they will be really cheesy and no one will laugh at unless he's secretly a comical prodigy which I don't recall ever being mentioned. And Secondly, Octavia, would no way in hell allow that. Talking about breaking Canon Bron? That's breaking Canon. Getting Twilight into a relationship with a mare, is "breaking canon."

[J.R. 3,183]

It's not "Breaking" canon to have that happen. It's going off of it. I didn't go against anything that was canon.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

What do you need the mic for? Explain to me, you can tell me in a PM so it isn't giving anything away. I'd like to know and if it's another "performance" like singing, it better of been in your profile beforehand and I've checked both. Because, this stacking on abilities is ridiculous. IMO 

 

And Ice,  "Cracking jokes." Isn't really an activity for this party. One i imagine they will be really cheesy and no one will laugh at unless he's secretly a comical prodigy which I don't recall ever being mentioned. And Secondly, Octavia, would no way in hell allow that. Talking about breaking Canon Bron? That's breaking Canon. Getting Twilight into a relationship with a mare, is "breaking canon."

I was joking!

 

Ice does tell decent jokes tho, but nah, he'll save 'em for a different time.

[Not Yellow Diamond 925]

I was joking!   Ice does tell decent jokes tho, but nah, he'll save 'em for a different time.

 

Ok, haha, sorry. I'm trying to get stuff done and not really addressing things, "jokingly." My apologies,

Orion. That still stands for you two though 

Edited July 20, 2015 by Flying Far

[J.R. 3,183]

You went against everything canon as far as Cadence. She has no magic, and she should.

As DM I will alow it. -_-

[P-Jay 1,987]

You went against everything canon as far as Cadence. She has no magic, and she should.

wait waht

[Not Yellow Diamond 925]

 

 

You went against everything canon as far as Cadence. She has no magic, and she should.

 

No, I didn't. Bron because you and I don't have the same opinion and if that's what you think is "canon." Then you've been misinformed. You're telling me I'm "breaking canon." You've yet to tell me how I broke it. you haven't said, "how," but that i did. Taking away her magic powers is not breaking canon. It changing a character. I hate to tell you but YOU don't know what "breaking" canon is if you're complaining over this and frankly... if this is "breaking" canon to you. Then, this WHOLE RP is "breaking" canon. Because explain to me why, violence woulf be encouraged in Equestria?  

[Not Yellow Diamond 925]

 

 

You are changing a canon character. That's canon breaking. Regardless, this is done. Ice says it's fine.

 

No, sorry. But I'm... actually... not going to drop it because I'm not going be told I'm wrong for something that i'm not. Sorry, It's sort of pride to me.  

 

That's not breaking a character, it's called changing one. Hate to tell you, but she just got faced with a "challenge" and that challenge changed her. Change happens. If you don't understand change then you need to. Are you telling me Cadence could never lose her powers in canon?

[J.R. 3,183]

Well Ice says it's fine, but my point still stands it's canon breaking. I'm not GM so I'm just concerned is all.

 

Peyton Fair made Cadence lose her magic permanently a couple of pages back.

 

 

No, I didn't. Bron because you and I don't have the same opinion and if that's what you think is "canon." Then you've been misinformed. You're telling me I'm "breaking canon." You've yet to tell me how I broke it. you haven't said, "how," but that i did. Taking away her magic powers is not breaking canon. It changing a character. I hate to tell you but YOU don't know what "breaking" canon is if you're complaining over this and frankly... if this is "breaking" canon to you. Then, this WHOLE RP is "breaking" canon. Because explain to me why, violence woulf be encouraged in Equestria?  

*remembers something*

S4 Finale:

 

Cadence and the other 3 Princesses lose their magic to fend off Tirek.

 

Cadence losing her magic, is not only canon, but it's also plausible!

Edited July 20, 2015 by Ice Blizzard

[Not Yellow Diamond 925]

Wow, not going to drop it? Are you kidding me? Ice just said it's fine.   You wanna keep going so we both get suspended? I'm probably going to get permabanned. You want me to get permabanned?   Changing a character that heavily is breaking canon because unless you have a way to return her magic she's staying that way for the whole RP. You said permanently.

 

No, I'm not going to get banned and neither should you... It's a friendly deate/discussion. That I would like to have but last time this happened, you crossed a line. So don't, have a civilized debate with me about the RP.

 

So say if Tirek would of won. That would be breaking Canon?

Edited July 20, 2015 by Flying Far

[J.R. 3,183]

 

 

So say if Tirek would of won. That would be breaking Canon?

That's an X-Factor consideration.

 

So, waiting on a Flutters post from you.

[Not Yellow Diamond 925]

If someone wrote a fanfic or had an RP with that as the premise, then no. But so far Arena hasn't had any major changes to things established by the show, until you did that.   You know, I'm not really sure why I'm even discussing this. Cadence is my least favorite Alicorn.

 

Bron, I apologized from last time. I'm just saying that you did last time and yes, you did. But I'm not getting into that and I hope you won't either. We can have a civilized debate, can't we.

 

So, Bron.  What actual evidence do you have that this isn't "canon" 

 

Canon:This is not so much a class, but a guide to the major works of the evolving literary canon. This canon is not modeled off of one particular literary canon, but based on a variety of opinions and canons that pick the major authors of the various English literary movements and their major works.

 

In this case "the show." A fanficition is unreliable evidence to tell me what is and isn't canon. 

 

If you would like to continue you this conversation, PM me, but due to Peyton's wishes. I will stop

Edited July 20, 2015 by Flying Far

[Not Yellow Diamond 925]

 

 

I said some things I shouldn't have also, yes. We apologized for that. But yes let's not keep going to get in trouble with anyone. I'll get back to you if you do something crazy with Twi cause Cadence isn't important to me, then we can have a long discussion on Skype or PM where we end up never talking to each other again.

 

Don't worry, nothing is happening with Twily, whether you think so or not. Ok, and don't disown our friendship over an RP, okay? That's just silly 

[Not Yellow Diamond 925]

 

 

Great. And I'm fine with that as long as you're fine with that. Remember the guy who did pretty much that? I'm just worried is all.   So how we doing on a CMC post dude? Their development interests me, a lot.

 

I've got 4 posts right now and I'mm on vacation so, a bit slow