If You Found Out Your Lover Was A Pony......

[Twilight Sky 449]

In one way no, but in many others yes. I am just pointing out that what I explained still means she lied regardless of her gender.

 

What if she never lied but she just found out??

 

but if she lied to you about being a pony then it's alright? ~

 

Sorry but natural guy instincts......nothing you can do about that....

[TomokoKuroki 1,707]

What if she never lied but she just found out??

 

 

 

Sorry but natural guy instincts......nothing you can do about that....

 

It still doesn't change my argument. My argument is the species is more important than the gender.

 

How does instincts have any relevence to being fooled into beastiality (or possibly leading towards it) than being fooled about gender?

 

Are you suggesting man can fall in love with an animal more than another man because of how they are naturally?

Edited July 2, 2012 by Hayzelestia

[Twilight Sky 449]

How does instincts have any relevence to being fooled into beastiality (or possibly leading towards it) than being fooled about gender?

 

Are you suggesting man can fall in love with an animal more than another man because of how they are naturally?

 

Hmmmmm....paradox....or something of the sort.....but lets stop this discussion before the mod says, "Stop Posting This!!!!111!!11!!11!!!! by the way this auto generated..."

Edited July 2, 2012 by Valiant

[TomokoKuroki 1,707]

Hmmmmm....paradox....or something of the sort.....

 

Not at all. I simply asked how can a man naturally be told by their instinct that you finding out that the person you fell in love with, who is a different species is more acceptable than finding out your lover was the opposite gender.

 

Isn't the lover being human more important to an individual than the gender? You can't look at an elephant knowing you kissed it, and say "Well it's fine because it's a girl" unless you are into sexual things with animals.

[Twilight Sky 449]

Not at all. I simply asked how can a man naturally be told by their instinct that you finding out that the person you fell in love with, who is a different species is more acceptable than finding out your lover was the opposite gender.

 

Isn't the lover being human more important to an individual than the gender? You can't look at an elephant knowing you kissed it, and say "Well it's fine because it's a girl" unless you are into sexual things with animals.

 

Thinking....I will have to consult philasoraptor...

Edited July 2, 2012 by Valiant

[Smokin'HotRarity 182]

i think the issue here is communication, and appearances, when u have ponies that communicate like humans the only issue is appearance, which is pretty much the same problem as gender appearances. its whether u like guys and gals, and ponies and humans. cuz once you nail down to it there is no difference from ponies and humans except ponies are nicer and look different from humans.

[Twilight Sky 449]

i think the issue here is communication, and appearances, when u have ponies that communicate like humans the only issue is appearance, which is pretty much the same problem as gender appearances. its whether u like guys and gals, and ponies and humans. cuz once you nail down to it there is no difference from ponies and humans except ponies are nicer and look different from humans.

 

You saved me!!! I wuv u :3

[Rizoel & Crepuscule 491]

Not at all. I simply asked how can a man naturally be told by their instinct that you finding out that the person you fell in love with, who is a different species is more acceptable than finding out your lover was the opposite gender.

 

Isn't the lover being human more important to an individual than the gender? You can't look at an elephant knowing you kissed it, and say "Well it's fine because it's a girl" unless you are into sexual things with animals.

 

As Dreamwalker said; some people just have different standards about some things than others.

[Twilight Sky 449]

Okay but seriously....*deep breath* guys would prefer a female pony from MLP FiM that acts like a female human over a dude.....but people's standards are different I guess..

Edited July 2, 2012 by Valiant

[TomokoKuroki 1,707]

i think the issue here is communication, and appearances, when u have ponies that communicate like humans the only issue is appearance, which is pretty much the same problem as gender appearances. its whether u like guys and gals, and ponies and humans. cuz once you nail down to it there is no difference from ponies and humans except ponies are nicer and look different from humans.

 

The pony wouldn't look like how they look in the show if they were real. They wouldn't be cartoon-like. The issue though was this whole thing originated from lies and deceit about gender.

 

My point is the fact that being fooled about species is worse than being fooled about gender. And I've been lead to believe that it is natural for men to apparently feel instinct tell him that accepting something non-human and very different(no matter how human-like is not a humanoid in any sense and IS an animal) as a companion rather than another male.

Edited July 2, 2012 by Hayzelestia

[Nightfall 3,950]

This sounds.. Interesting. It would be a bit weird to be in this situation... I mean, I would try to remain friends with this pony, but romantic? I don't see ponies in a romantic way, like Pegasus25.

Also, I've never had a girlfriend, so I don't exactly know what a romantic relationship is like...

[Twilight Sky 449]

The pony wouldn't look like how they look in the show if they were real. They wouldn't be cartoon-like. The issue though was this whole thing originated from lies and deceit about gender.

 

My point is the fact that being fooled about species is worse than being fooled about gender. And I've been lead to believe that it is natural for men to apparently feel instinct tell him that accepting something non-human and very different(no matter how human-like is not a humanoid in any sense and IS an animal) as a companion rather than another male.

 

Well you have to realize the one magical word.....depends.....

[TomokoKuroki 1,707]

Well you have to realize the one magical word.....depends.....

 

Well depending on what? You have to say what it depends on if you are going to use that word.

[Starshine 16,334]

say "Well it's fine because it's a girl" unless you are into sexual things with animals.

 

My point is the fact that being fooled about species is worse than being fooled about gender. And I've been lead to believe that it is natural for men to apparently feel instinct tell him that accepting something non-human and very different(no matter how human-like is not a humanoid in any sense and IS an animal) as a companion rather than another male.

Two words: Personal Preferences

 

[cuteycindyhoney 13,307]

Maybe he's a pony who performed a magic spell that gave him human appendages, the ability to walk upright, and to basically look like a human in general

 

 

I am going to restrain myself from making any comments about pony appendages...

 

[TomokoKuroki 1,707]

Two words: Personal Preferences

 

 

All you did was re-state your stance on how you rather be lied to, not adding anything or enlightening me of the discussion at hand.

 

​Are you only re-stating what you said about the lie, or are you saying that inter-species relationships is of personal preference?(Which it is) You need to elaborate. And even if that was your statement, doesn't it seem more important to know what you are in love with and not what sex it is? Why does something being male or female have much more importance than the species of the animal? Why is it more painful to hear "my lover is actually male", than "my lover is actually a miniature- horse"?

Edited July 2, 2012 by Hayzelestia

[Radiance64 7,053]

Well, as long as they were an inteligent, sentient pony like from the show, I think we could make it work~

[Starshine 16,334]

All you did was re-state your stance on how you rather be lied to, not adding anything or enlightening me of the discussion at hand.

 

​Are you only re-stating what you said about the lie, or are you saying that inter-species relationships is of personal preference?(Which it is) You need to elaborate. And even if that was your statement, doesn't it seem more important to know what you are in love with and not what sex it is? Why does something being male or female have much more importance than the species of the animal? Why is it more painful to hear "my lover is actually male", than "my lover is actually a miniature- horse"?

 

The simplest explanation I could think of is the 'connection' between the lovers' heart.

 

If my spouse was a female and being honest about it, regardless of species or maybe genitalia, I could still feel this link between me and her. And no, I don't need any sexual intercourse to feel in love, so my spouse can easily be a flying tiger and I would feel content hanging around her and talking about my days.

 

But if this spouse turns out as a male (again, regardless of species and form), well, let's just say I would rather cut one of my limbs.

 

If this doesn't satisfy you, then I'm sorry. Couldn't think of any better way to say it

[Smokin'HotRarity 182]

The pony wouldn't look like how they look in the show if they were real. They wouldn't be cartoon-like. The issue though was this whole thing originated from lies and deceit about gender.

 

My point is the fact that being fooled about species is worse than being fooled about gender. And I've been lead to believe that it is natural for men to apparently feel instinct tell him that accepting something non-human and very different(no matter how human-like is not a humanoid in any sense and IS an animal) as a companion rather than another male.

 

what matters when u dig down to it everyone is the same...species in this case is a physical construct. if the pony can chat online then isn't that pony pretty much human (except for appearances)?

for being lied to, they probably had there reason, but when it boils down to it, there is no difference whether they are boy or girl, pony or human or whatever. they are pretty much the same inside so the lie about gender is no more of a lie about being a human. probably at this point you gaiz just want something somewhat silly to discuss because this question is pretty much slightly silly to begin with.

Edited July 2, 2012 by glitterlicious

[Abstract 832]

Love is love, I don't think there should be boundaries or constraints on it regardless of pretty much anything, as long as it is true. If it's really there and it really means something, then it will work.

[Mr. Jaguar 1,403]

The fact is....

If fluttershy ended up with me and she could turn into human....I would want to be her lover forever....

 

 

Is everyone in love with Fluttershy?

Edited July 2, 2012 by Pegasus25

[Legate Umbra 5]

In a way i'm with dreamwalker on this one, cept for that last part. Anyways, for me if we had be talking and i found that i truly liked her and we could have fun together, the physical doesnt matter, if you look at it objectively it would only become an obstacle to adjust to and overcome if you truly loved whoever it was on the inside, sentience is sentience.

[Smokin'HotRarity 182]

Is everyone in love with Fluttershy?

 

yes

[Mr. Jaguar 1,403]

yes

 

Huge fight to the death for Fluttershy's affection, GO!

[Twilight Sky 449]

 

 

Huge fight to the death for Fluttershy's affection, GO!

 

Realistically I would win that fight but Fluttershy would disapprove.....