Background Mane Six and Elements

[DukeofCanterlot 158]

I have seen a lot of good stuff about the background mane six and what their own specific elements would be. However, which of the canon elements of harmony do you think they would have?

My thoughts. I'll probably elaborate on explanations later today but am a little busy right now. Just wanted to get this out there.

Magic: Doctor Whooves (time travel magic)
Generosity: Octavia
Honesty: Bon-Bon
Laughter: Vinyl Scratch
Kindness: Lyra Heartstrings
Loyalty: Derpy Hooves


The ones I'm least certain about are Derpy and Doctor Whooves.. can switch these two. Especially, if I want to do something like magic is friendship and in the heart etc...

Thoughts?

I might make a fanfic about this in the future.

I might assign them their own special elements but think it would be interesting to have "copies" of the current Mane Six as well and see how the Mane Six react to that .. especially if Trollestia initiates it.

 

Even though Lyra and Vinyl are the unicorns of the group, I think Kindness and Laughter work better for each one respectively than Magic.

[Scootalove 10,692]

Magic: Lyra Heartstrings

Kindness: Derpy Hooves

Generosity: Octavia

Laughter: Vinyl Scratch

Honesty: Bon Bon

Loyalty: Doctor Whooves
 

[DukeofCanterlot 158]

Scootalove, I like those better actually.

Derpy as kindness. Doctor Whooves as loyalty. Leads the way for Lyra to take magic

Derpy fits kindness very nicely.