• entries
    352
  • comments
    1077
  • views
    253987

episode review "Student Counsel" Quickieview

Note: Expanded my thoughts from here and here.


Being Starlight's first episode of Season 9 and from a prior synopsis, one could guess a low-stakes episode, magic-oriented, or possible repeat of a Every Little Thing She Does. That couldn’t be any further from the truth. Magic's involved, but it wasn't central to the story. With her friends off for Spring Break, she's running the school now until they return, and she needs something to organize her time in school while also not being in office. Casting an alert curse on a bracelet was convenient and made sense: Once they need her help, she'll be right there.

Unfortunately, she didn't foresee what was to come. Her schedule just before Spring Break became so hectic that she not only got many ponies lined up, but Silverstream came over several times for very small problems related to an unnamed project. And to make matters worse, Starlight was unable to help Trixie gather the right objects for Maud and Mud’s spring solstice party the next morning (with Sunburst invited, too) and Trixie had to prepare it all by herself. The episode spends a good amount of time gradually building tension, starting with the innocent(ly funny expressions by Trixie) and ending with the stressful. Some examples include:

  1. Trixie casually drinking tea and eating sandwiches as Starlight juggles between her office and the picnic.
  2. Starlight helping her students while trying (and failing :laugh:) to hide her nerves.
  3. As Trixie reminds her of the errands, Starlight stays conspicuously silent as she looks around and taps her hooves.
  4. As Ocellus deals with her identity crisis, Starlight tries to solve it while rushing through.
  5. Starlight leaving the store once her bracelet buzzes, accidentally dropping the streamers she plans to buy.
  6. After Starlight realizes she missed out on everything and failed to keep her promises, she crouched and smacked her muzzle on the ground. Suddenly, her bracelet rang again.
    Quote

    Starlight Glimmer *dejected*: Of course it is. *facehoofs the ground, teleports*

During this first third of the story, a lot of great faces were animated to accentuate the stress building up amongst themselves and each other, like their eyes increasing size, Trixie's sneers, Smolder's smirk, and Starlight's anguish. The dialogue was also top-notch, adding to both the humor and drama.

Additionally, despite being Starlight-centric, Haber doesn't write Trixie in the wrong for expecting her to keep her promise, too. Yes, Starlight was justified to not keep 'em, even though she tried her hardest to keep up. Being in charge of the school for now, she's responsible for their safety and guidance if need be. To her, rejecting any help could mean missing out on something truly important to solve and letting Twilight et al down. Nevertheless, Haber doesn't let Trxie's feelings go or feel marginalized, spending good time airing her frustrations and then confronting her after taking care of the party arrangements. So when Silverstream asked for help one more time, the moment when Starlight turned her away and took off her bracelet until the Break ends made sense and didn't feel rushed through.

So when Terramar alerted her that Silverstream vanished and then called her out for turning her away (Thanks, Trixie :dry:), could you blame her feeling terrible for the whole thing? By closing the school early, she believed she could've solved an actual problem rather than any nerve-wracking nitpick from earlier. After realizing that she was in the Everfree Forest to likely research cockatrices, the tension climbed hundredfold and added further uncertainty for Starlight. Early in the open, Starlight explained how becoming a counselor allowed her to use her "checkered past" to get to others' shoes and aid them below the surface. The guilt she felt from seasons ago disappeared. But that guilt returned and only increased as the episode and danger progressed. Even after they all realized SS was safe and sound, that guilt never went away.

The communication between the rest of her friends also felt very complete with plenty of humor. Some of the best moments were as follows:

  1. Quote

    Mudbriar: Technically, it's not symmetrical or aesthetically pleasing.
    Trixie: [growls]

    The anime-like blood vessels ready to burst and SG's shock really sell the joke and immediately show how even he gets on her nerves. :laugh:

  2. Trixie standing up for Starlight to Terramar and eventually accepting partial blame for her disappearance.

  3. After Terramar criticized Starlight's party for not being "perfect," everyone, including Maud, glared crossly at him, shutting him up.

  4. In acts of desperation, Starlight looked in even the most unconventional places, such as inside Pinkie's party cannon and on a crowded bookshelf. Moments like these show both the panic creeping from within and the guilt that she already possesses.

  5. This little exchange:

    Quote

    Maud Pie: [deadpan] Actually, rocks aren't the most hospitable environment for shade trees.

    Mudbriar: Technically, pine trees like Pinus cembra or Pinus sylvestris can grow from narrow crevasses or cracks in a rocky rhizosphere.

    Maud Pie: [deadpan] You complete me.

    In the final two acts alone, there was plenty of flirting between them in comparison to Maud Couple from last year. Mud's little smile after Maud's reply feels genuine and shows appreciation for each other.

The lesson has some similarities with Zeppelin, but they’re not the same. In Zeppelin, it’s about how it’s not selfish to have time with yourself. Here, it’s about not getting bogged down with a very stressful job to spend quality time with others. It’s a really good lesson.

There are two problems.

  1. When Starlight and the others made it inside the open ruins of the sisters’ castle, they assumed the cockatrices won’t fly in and only surround. One big problem. Cockatrices can fly high, and they got too close to a flock of migrating ones by watching them from a cliff above. What if the provoked cockatrices decide to fly over the walls or through the old windows? They were just as vulnerable inside the ruins as out, yet the episode lowers the stakes a bit here and assumes they’re safe until they walk out. It was really dumb of everyone to gather and breathe there.
  2. At the very end, Silverstream admits to Starlight that her advice didn't amount to anything in the long run. First off, the joke wasn't funny. Secondly, it all but made Starlight's stress over "not doing her job" pointless and marginalizes the moral, as SS's visits didn't factor at all into the conclusion of her Spring Break project. Had Trixie not interrupt, Starlight would've completely lost her temper and given her the riot act.

That said, it’s really good, and given the fact that Starlight’s takeover of the school may be inevitable, she really needed this episode. Good work, Haber! :D

  • Brohoof 2
Sign in to follow this  


2 Comments


Recommended Comments

That Silver Stream last line left a little of bitterness in my mouth. (It didnt ruin the episode or anything but it still bother me)

The cockatrices outside the sister castle is dumb but not that dumb to be consider the flaw of the episode. The Trixie leads everyone montage in Act 3 should be the negative, it's too long and it's not funny.

Sunburst is another problem. Remember this guy used to be one of the most important things of Starlight? That character is just there for exposition now. He didnt develop as a character, he's just there. Trixie and Maud, which are Starlight's friend have more development and chemistry than him. Cut him off and i will notice no difference. To think he used to be an important part of Starlight's life, a part of her 'controversial' backstory that people had to take 2 seasons to get used to it, not worth it. 

Trixie & Starlight friendship is still one of best things that the show has ever done for me in post-S5 era.

  • Brohoof 2

Share this comment


Link to comment

You are really good at writing reviews I must admit. Can I hire you for some of my college book reviews lol? Because I just can't handle those without using some additional resources... Wish I were as good as you at writing.

Share this comment


Link to comment

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Add a comment...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.