I went with the highest option on the list because, in all honesty, I do wish that she was my girlfriend. At first, I was really self conscious about what people would think if I mentioned that I had feelings for a pony, that they would just bring up the whole bestiality argument even though I knew that that wasn't true on my part. I've never found normal animals attractive in real life. Cute, yes. But what really hit me is the fact that Fluttershy is not just a normal pony. She's just as human as any other individual I come across in real life. I find her attractive in more than one way too. Outside of her long flowing mane and tail, her kind, expressive eyes, and her gentle, soothing voice that has always been a comfort to me, it's her personality that I find myself just as attracted to as anything else. Fluttershy is such a caring, nurturing individual (probably the most nurturing out of anypony else in the show) that she has many of the qualities I'd look for both in a girlfriend and even a wife. There's no doubt in my mind that Fluttershy would make for an incredible mother and, if she were to have me, I'd consider myself the luckiest guy in all Equestria. Whether she was pony or human, I see no difference. She was even the very first tattoo I ever got, which should tell you a lot about my love for her and how unchanging it is. Which is why I get really peeved when people try to say that Fluttershy as a pony can only be a pet to someone because that's denying her her own individuality as one who can freely think for herself. Fluttershy is honestly my second highest ranking waifu of all time (#1 is from all the way back in my childhood), but considering that she's beaten out other crushes I've had for much longer than her, I still consider second place to be pretty high praise on my part and I know for fact that none will ever be able to take her place she's left in my heart. I love you so much, Flutters, and you definitely rock. Woo hoo.