Jump to content
Banner by ~ Ice Princess Silky

Tealeaf

Retired Staff
  • Posts

    133
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Tealeaf

  1. Tealeaf

    offering critique OC Critique and Advice

    Hey there! I know it's been a real, real long time since I've gotten to one of these but I'm really hoping to get back into this c: So here we go. His Appearance. It definitely seems like a lot of thought has been put into your character's visual concept. The fact that you explained each feature and how it might effect the character's performance and mannerisms is very appealing to me as an outside viewer. I feel as though the leather jacket may be a bit out of place given the rest of his overall theme, but it isn't something that distracts from the concept greatly and I do believe it could be pulled off well. In general, I'd have to nit-pick to really express much frustration with the design, although I would say to avoid pitch blacks if you ever get him drawn. His Cutiemark. As a gryphon, it wouldn't make sense for him to have a cutiemark really. It isn't a part of their biological makeup so I'm glad you left it out. His Personality and bio. All in all, you have a pretty well-formed character. I think it was very good that you noted he was raised in a different environment, but retained some of his species' programmed responses and desires. For me it shows a lot of depth in character, and isn't too extreme to where they are quite literally two individual personalities. He's multi-faceted, but not unrealistic. A lot of people make the mistake of giving their characters a type of 'psuedo' MPD, which is normally really upsetting for me personally because the disorder is so insanely complex and very few people accurately portray it. You did a good job of giving your character believable flaws without giving them an unnecessary "excuse", which is what people often times do. You did a really fantastic job with this character's basic concept c: They're interesting without being overbearing and I think that's something that can be difficult to capture for some people.
  2. Tealeaf

    offering critique OC Critique and Advice

    Been real busy lately but I'm hoping soon.
  3. I know I've been kinda absent lately, but I'm streaming tonight ;3; hoping to get some work done so I can get some time to do more here. link here; https://picarto.tv/EniiWisp

  4. Tealeaf

    offering critique OC Critique and Advice

    I'll be getting to yours and any others I've missed as soon as possible c: So feel free to drop your character off.
  5. Tealeaf

    offering critique OC Critique and Advice

    I've been away for a long while with school but am hoping to get everything back up and running within the next couple of days c:
  6. Hey guys, I know I've been away a LOT. My lizard recently died so I've been mourning. Just want you to know I'm doing alright though. Still sorry about the art delay.

  7. Oh god ;3; Really feel bad about how long it's been taking me to post those damn free sketches. Soon though! Just been busy with stuff and keep forgetting.

    1. Sweet Pen

      Sweet Pen

      Don't worry about it, since it's free, no one should bother you to ask about the art

    2. Tealeaf

      Tealeaf

      I'm glad you guys understand c: They're actually done >< I just keep getting held up with work.

  8. Drawings are done c: Just havent been able to post yet. Will do so as soon as possible and then, once my trades and commissions are done, I'll open another que.
  9. Hey guys! Working on commissions and trades today, but I'm hoping to finish up this silly little sketch que sometime tomorrow. Once again, so sorry for the wait!
  10. I've already spent plenty of time explaining my reasoning as to why it can be considered in a debate about the canon universe, and I think that it would be pretty silly for me to repeat myself more than twice. There is still a huge difference between fan fiction and the comics, but this is besides the point. I appreciate that you have a different outlook on the subject.
  11. Tealeaf

    offering critique OC Critique and Advice

    That is reasonable, for sure. I just feel as though there might be some difficulty in regards to him having to wear lots of clothing and so forth, since he might be prone to heatstroke, etc, realistically.
  12. The comics are not fan fictions. They are recognized and licensed by hasbro. It makes absolutely no sense to relate these two things because there is a very particular difference between the two.
  13. Tealeaf

    offering critique OC Critique and Advice

    Before I get into the specifics, I feel like I should mention that your character is AWFULLY cute <3 His appearance. As I've already sort of mentioned, this is a very cute character. The color scheme is very consistent and flows nicely, without contrasting too much or being too oversaturated or undersaturated. I enjoy the idea of a sort of fluffier-than-usual character because I like those type of quirks, but make sure to work this into their story. Major differences have an affect on how a character will be perceived in the universe they reside in, and having an excess of fur also means having some physical disadvantages because he might be likely to overheat easily in some scenarios (especially given the amount of clothing he needs to wear to protect from sunlight). My only qualm, and this is purely me being nit-picky, has to do with your burn marks. They just don't look like how a burn scar would look on an animal. You can express this in a more PG way by giving him a very light patch where no fur grows, since that is how burns work in the real world. Since fur density isn't typically apparent on MLP pony faces, you should be able to get away with just giving him a jagged little marking, but the fade out you have wouldn't be realistic and it definitely would not be dark. Burns are only dark at first before the skin heals over. Note- This is the usual case and is typically what is best to follow for simplified drawings such as that in mlp style. Burn scars on animals [TRIGGER WARNING FOR SOME PEOPLE], I tried to keep it relatively safe to look at and not too obscene: His cutiemark. While I can assume that it wouldn't be unrealistic for a mlp character to not find his talent early on like most ponies, a mlp adult character without a cutiemark has never actually been seen in the show to my knowledge. Strangely, at 16 he would technically be an adult given that Twilight and her friends are all marked to be around 15+ at the beginning of the show. Cutiemarks are a very important part of this society, and I can imagine him not having one being very hard on him emotionally, especially given his other trauma and trials. His personality and bio. I really enjoy the personality and cute little flaws you've given him. I think that the blindness is a little bit of a stretch, though it is acceptable if we are to assume this is something that was developed at a young age. I say this because adult eyes are very developed, and cave blindness is very unlikely, if not impossible, to occur in adults. However, for young children light deprivation can cause significant sight loss because their eyes are still developing. If a new born baby is not allowed to see for several months to years after birth or during the first to second year after birth, it can end up with a serious visual handicap, or may be even completely blind, despite having completely normal eyes. This happens because the visual cortex in the brain fails to develop in the absence of a visual input. This means that your pony would have to have been in near complete darkness for a VERY long time, directly after birth, so just keep that in mind. That being said, fur on animals is meant to protect from the elements, including cold, water, and even sun. As much as I like his fluff, I do think that it is completely incompatible with his apparent allergy to direct sunlight, because his dense fur would prevent the UV rays from making much contact with his bare skin. When animals take allergy tests, their fur needs to be shaved down so that the skin can be tested, because hair is already "dead" after leaving the skin and follicle. I will be getting to your critique shortly within this evening or tomorrow c: Your review takes only a tad bit more work because I have to imagine the visuals, rather than having them right there infront of me. It isn't a problem at all, it just means I have to apply particular attention to your descriptions.
  14. Honestly, that doesn't mean that the comics should be disregarded. It means that an order of importance has been established, but it would be safe for somebody to assume that the comics are accurate until proven otherwise by the show itself.
  15. The comics were hasbro licensed officially and are technically canon. You can assume they aren't in your own headcanon, of course, but the comics are a source of information that can be relied upon for canon discussions. Personally, I wouldn't consider them in my own approach to the universe, but again that doesn't change the fact that they are technically canon.
  16. Trying to catch up on artwork while also working on my wow character's backstory. I play on a PvP server, what am I doing?

  17. Actually, as much as I dislike Celestia, a lot of this just isn't true. For one, Celestia is not the reason that Sombra is a shadow pony. That is his inherent race, as has been expressed in the comics. He had the potential to become what he became long before Celestia ever contacted him. That being said, stripping her sister of all magic would be very difficult if not impossible, and would most likely yield more trauma for the young filly than the option that Celestia chose. These two are not only alicorns (and therefore have three forms of magic), but related, so being trapped in such close proximity would be very damaging to Luna and Celestia both. Discord was set in stone because he was uncontrollable. Because Celestia did not have a means of providing him aid and directing him towards a more righteous cause. The elements of harmony are very important, and even though Celestia can harness them, she does not possess their traits which is what Discord needed. As for your first point (because I went terribly out of order), these young mares aren't JUST young mares. This group consists of her most prized pupil and the LITERAL embodiment of each element of harmony, the strongest force in equestria. I really suggest looking into Celestia and Luna's origin stories, via the comics. This link will lead you to some of the info, but there's lots you simply can't get without reading it yourself: http://mlp.wikia.com/wiki/The_Journal_of_the_Two_Sisters Since it's released from Hasbro and approved by the MLP crew, it's canon.
  18. The shop will reopen once I can finish with my current que! But for now, since I can't really draw much atm, I need to be patient.
  19. Okay, so I'm hoping to get to some of these today lmao. My micro USB broke so I'm borrowing one from my mother. This, unfortunately, means that I can't draw at all after the time they go to sleep, so my draw-time has been cut considerably. I've also got some trades to do that take priority over these, but I'm doing these as warmups so they get done pretty quickly. Just understand that my speed is only cut down so much atm because of that little set back c:
  20. I still get on everyday and check around some of the threads to keep up to date lol I promise that, even if I'm not talking a whole lot for a day or more, I'm still around for the most part.

  21. In the meantime, this is what I have been working on aside from these mlp sketches. It's very, very messy atm. I also have three trades in progress lol
  22. Just wanted to stop by and update since I didn't do the work I had planned to do when I had planned to do it lol I do still intend to get it all done, but I'm doing this stuff in between personal work as well so please keep that in mind.
  23. I'm really glad you like it! c: Feel free to use it wherever and however you'd like, just credit me whenever necessary as EnigmaticWisp. I do these sketches for practice so that I keep sort of "in shape" with my art. It's pretty much the only way that I can guarantee I'm going to draw something every day lmao <3
  24. You absolutely do not have to, but if you decide that you'd like to, I always enjoy new artwork of my characters. The only one I have released right now is Misty Tealeaf, who you can find all over the place cuz she's my primary c:
  25. I'm very glad to hear that you're happy with how it came out! c:
×
×
  • Create New...