Cutie Mark (Original or new Design?)

[Dark Heart 284]

So this is my Oc original cutie mark i conbine/made

 

This is my new Version (Paint Version)

 

And this one i dont count but since i been making "realistic" Eyes i made the cutie mark kinda realistic as well 

 

So what do you guys think? is original better or does the new improves on the old one?

[Pinkamena-Pills 6,839]

First off, lovely cutie mark.

It's certainly a improvement, however, depending on the 'style' you draw your OC in, the never version might be too 'out of place' as far as the surrounding art(the OC in question ect), i only say this, because the new version is pretty damn detailed, and in a way jumps out at you. 

 

Regardless, it looks lovely, all of em' do. Good job.