OC Redesign: Keep old or use new?

[Tao 7,756]

So I thought to go back and redo a few of old ocs to  get  in some new life into em!  One I loved back in the day some months ago was Wishvow in my Prism Ponies (redoing them in the winters) yet I could not think of a reason to really use her till as of late.  Thinking,  I've redone her design a bit roughly and thought to get some feedback to keep the new,  refine it or keep up with the old one:

 

Name: Wishvow

Type:  Earth Pony/Half Crystal Pony

Age:  17-26 (depends in rp)

Parents:  Adopted daughter of Fluttershy (might not use) or Crystal Pony Mare Jewel Joy

 

Cutie Mark Meaning/Talent" Can hear the music of the stars and remakes it into songs so other ponies can hear it. 

 

New:

 

Old:

Edited September 6, 2015 by Tao

[BlueBrony 388]

I do like the redesign better. I'm not sure though on the skin/fur color of the redesign. It could work, but it is also my clash too much with the mane/tail colors. I wouldn't go back to the pink/fuchsia, but maybe a light grey (with less blue tint in it)?

[Tao 7,756]

I do like the redesign better. I'm not sure though on the skin/fur color of the redesign. It could work, but it is also my clash too much with the mane/tail colors. I wouldn't go back to the pink/fuchsia, but maybe a light grey (with less blue tint in it)?

That could work,  I only did the colors I had to see how it might turn out a touch, I'll play around with it later.

[Lunar Echo 10,335]

I think you're doing a great job

[LordSwinton 759]

I quite like both design actually, they could be sisters or something lol

[Rawzy 1,302]

I think that the old body with the new mane would look really nice!

Edited September 9, 2015 by Rawzy

[NO_LONGER_AVAILABLE 22]

I love the old one more detailed

[Tao 7,756]

I think that the old body with the new mane would look really nice!

I had that idea a bit when playing around...

 

I love the old one more detailed

Yah,  that was a finale one I did on my Prism ponies,  and I might keep Wishvow just as Wishvow.....

[Cyandashie 128]

Old looks much better. It's neon awesomeness.