Rate my Brony Signature?

[Tea 4]

This was just a quick signature for any forum that I whipped up in Photoshop. If this gets positive ratings, I might consider making signatures for public use. If you want to join the Steam Group, just search it

 

 

Please rate out of / 10

[Swit Swat 536]

8/10

 

It's good!

 

And, not to be rude but, there is already a thread about "Rating Signatures."

 

Here:http://mlpforums.com/topic/134-rate-the-users-signature-over-you/page__st__1520__p__399752__hl__rate%20users%20signature#entry399752

Edited May 28, 2012 by Swit Swat

[Bohtty 1,775]

3/10 from a design perspective is very bland. The hair on the RD pixel art is off and her cutie mark is colored wrong (there is no green)

Additionally The typography isn't very good.

 

I would say the main things that need to be worked on is the colors used and the typography. If you want more specific help and details send me a PM.

 

Sorry if this sounds harsh, you can only improve if you know whats wrong with it, right?

Good luck and keep practicing.

 

Here:http://mlpforums.com/topic/134-rate-the-users-signature-over-you/page__st__1520__p__399752__hl__rate%20users%20signature#entry399752

 

That's a forum game, I think hes looking for advice, pointers, tips and other such things where as that thread is just about giving a score and moving on.

Edited May 28, 2012 by Bohtty

[Tea 4]

3/10 from a design perspective is very bland. The hair on the RD pixel art is off and her cutie mark is colored wrong (there is no green)

Additionally The typography isn't very good.

 

I would say the main things that need to be worked on is the colors used and the typography. If you want more specific help and details send me a PM.

 

Sorry if this sounds harsh, you can only improve if you know whats wrong with it, right?

Good luck and keep practicing.

 

It's not harsh at all, constructive criticism will get me in the right direction!

8/10

 

It's good!

 

And, not to be rude but, there is already a thread about "Rating Signatures."

 

Here:http://mlpforums.com/topic/134-rate-the-users-signature-over-you/page__st__1520__p__399752__hl__rate%20users%20signature#entry399752

 

Thanks man! Edited May 28, 2012 by Tea

[Swit Swat 536]

3/10 from a design perspective is very bland. The hair on the RD pixel art is off and her cutie mark is colored wrong (there is no green)

Additionally The typography isn't very good.

 

I would say the main things that need to be worked on is the colors used and the typography. If you want more specific help and details send me a PM.

 

Sorry if this sounds harsh, you can only improve if you know whats wrong with it, right?

Good luck and keep practicing.

 

 

 

That's a forum game, I think hes looking for advice, pointers, tips and other such things where as that thread is just about giving a score and moving on.

 

Well, it still helps :3

 

It's not harsh at all, constructive criticism will get me in the right direction!

 

Thanks man!

 

Your welcome.