If the Earth ponies could be a pegasus or unicorn...

[Clarity 3,094]

If you can imagine Applejack or Pinkie Pie or a background pony as a pegasus or unicorn, what would you choose?

 

Use the form below! (You don't have to use all ponies )

 

Applejack:

 

Pinkie Pie:

 

Octavia:

 

Apple Bloom:

 

Big Macintosh:

 

Golden Harvest/Carrot Top:

 

Berry Punch:

 

Diamond Tiara:

 

Silver Spoon:

 

Other ponies?:

 

For Me-

 

Applejack: I really couldn't decide, but I'd say Unicorn, because of a deviantART drawing I saw.

 

Pinkie Pie: Pegasus, no doubt. It fits her personality.

 

Octavia: Unicorn; she looks like the type of pony to be dignified like Rarity.

 

Apple Bloom: Pegasus, because of all her excitement thingies? XD I can't decide. >.<

 

Big Mac: Unicorn, because he's so reserved and everything.

 

Golden Harvest/Carrot Top: Unicorn, because I think it would match her curly mane.

 

Berry Punch: Pegasus, just cause she looks like one? XD

 

Diamond Tiara: Unicorn; it matches her name, and I can so easily imagine her having one, eyes narrowed in evil...

Silver Spoon: Unicorn, but for different reasons from Diamond Tiara. She looks really cute with it in my mind's eye.

 

So what do you think?

[AppleTreeBrony 228]

Applejack: Pegasus, Because it would help her in her job

 

Pinkie Pie: Pegasus, Because SURPRISE!

 

Octavia: Unicorn, Being a Unicorn has benifits, Including playing 600 instruments at the same time.

 

Apple Bloom: I really can't imagine her with anything.

 

Big Macintosh: Pegasus, Again Work help.

 

Golden Harvest/Carrot Top: Can't imagine

 

Berry Punch: Unicorn, Mixing 800 drinks at the same time. DAAAAAAAAAAAAAMN!

 

Diamond Tiara: Unicorn, She's rich, Alot of Rich ponies are Unicorns.

 

Silver Spoon: Ditto

[Planty 1,053]

I really really really like how they are;

 

However i put them all for unicorn's because i can't imagine any of them with wing's.

 

Applejack: Magic + heard working = every job every in Ponyville done and million's of apples for everyone!

 

Pinkie Pie: See can already break the 4th wall, imagine if she also had magic? she already has super speed to so magic would effectively make her the most powerful pony in all of equestria!

 

Octavia: Magic would really ,help her with chello + she could probably just play the entire orchestra on her own with magic

 

Apple Bloom: Magic here so that she can make her cutie mark appear with magic <3!

 

Big Macintosh: Hard working already? give magic and his output will increase 10 fold!

 

Golden Harvest/Carrot Top: even more food and can be produced with magic they can make the perfect condition's and even greenhouses more easily with magic!

 

Berry Punch: magic more punch = win!

 

Diamond Tiara / silver spoon: magic because she is spoiled already, now she really doesn't have to get anything for herself, just use levitation magic!

[Dusty Soul 2,611]

Applejack: Pegasus, because I couldn't imagine her as a unicorn

 

Pinkie Pie: Pegasus.... SURPRISE

 

Octavia: Unicorn... it would help her play her cello... (As if she needed any help)

 

Apple Bloom: Unicorn...

 

Big Macintosh: Pegasus, I couldn't see him as a unicorn

 

Golden Harvest/Carrot Top: Unicorn

 

Berry Punch: Unicorn

 

Diamond Tiara: Unicorn

 

Silver Spoon: Unicorn

[Waffles 12]

Honestly....I coudn't decide at all by picking for Apple Jack and Big Mac.

At the end i picked unicorn because it would help her with her work in the farm.

Same goes for Big Mac.

:/

[K3WRO 79]

Oh Gawd

Applejack : As pegasus, I think she'll look cute with wings

 

Pinkie : With wings or horn she'll be a disaster!

 

Octavia : Unicorn, looks like she'll need some help with that cello

 

Apple Bloom :

 

Big Mac : WTF

 

Carrot Top : Unicorn

 

Berry Punch : This is hard to decide, UNICORN

 

Diamond Tiara : What? She deserves no wings or horn

 

Silver Spoon : I'll make you a pegasus

[Clarity 3,094]

Hmmm, seeing a lot of detailed responses! If there were actually an episode in Season 3 that had the ponies switching wings and horns, that would be very interesting.

[pinkiefan1287 610]

For Apple Jack I went with unicorn. Using magic may make work easier on her.

 

Pinkie I went with unicorn. To see her use magic would just be funny.

 

Big Mac Pegasus.

 

DD and SS, I also went with unicorn just because they act like some unicorns.

 

As for the others I just guessed, cause I had no idea for the others.

[silvadel 1,393]

Applejack definitely pegasus -- I think she would love to be able to fly and compete with rainbow dash on that level.

 

Pinkie Pie -- Unicorn. Really, could you see Pinkie Pie with wings? She has enough devices to let her fly if she needs to but -- pinkie pie with wings.... It would be like giving a cat wings.

 

Big Mac -- Unicorn. I could see him having uses for it, and I see him as the most studious apple (although that could be fanon bleeding into canon). He is just the quiet type in the extreme.

 

Other than that I went with the flow.

[XUNUSEDXXX 3,459]

I would not see Big Mac as a pegasus at ALL, I mean, all that muscle and his big bulky shape would not fit any type of pegasus wings

[Smokey the mudkip 52]

Pinky pie HAS to be a Pegasus, because it suits her?

applejack, Unicorn, i don't think she could be a Pegasus, since it wouldn't suit her whatsoever.

and i dont feel like doing the rest X3

[notdog1996 315]

Applejack: Pegasus

 

Pinkie Pie: Pegasus, surprise duh

 

Octavia: Unicorn, high society ponies are often unicorns

 

Apple Bloom: Pegasus, because

 

Big Macintosh: Pegasus

 

Golden Harvest/Carrot Top: Unicorn because a horn could fit her

 

Berry Punch: Pegasus since wings look great on her

 

Diamond Tiara: Unicorn because unicorn princess

 

Silver Spoon: Pegasus (only one against the majority)