Twilight's Punishment?

[Comet Tail 808]

Celestia never said she was going to punish Twilight. She ordered her to the library so they could talk privately, and then calmed the distraught student down. The rest assumed the punishment, and ran to Twilight's defense. The princess was amused, and humored them by saying their concern was enough for her to give Twilight a reprieve. This is how I read the situation.

 

Pinkie Pie: "You can't punish her!"

Applejack: "It wasn't her fault!"

Celestia, dryly: "I'm listening..."

[they all explain how they should've helped]

Celestia: "Looks like you all learned a pretty valuable lesson today..."

All but Celestia: "Mhmm!"

Celestia: "Very well, I'll forget TWilight's punishment on one condition..."

 

I doubt it was anything harsh, though, if you look at how her expression reacts to Twilight's cries moments before, she looks like she thinks Twilight's had enough guilt.

 

Oh yeah, how could I forgot, banishing to the moon, Celestia's trademark.

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PkGBM5Mw2SY

 

Ponified version of

.

[I used to be a stranger 7,993]

Twilight's punishment would've been washing Celestia's hair.

 

Which is kind of like "How do you catch a cloud and pin it down?"

[Tailssod 20]

I believe that the punishment would be for Twilight to return to Canterlot and stay.

 

That would be sad ._.

[cuteycindyhoney 13,307]

If the punishment was kissing Celestia's hooves, Rarity would have shoved Twilight out of the way!

 

LOL

 

 

Pinkie Pie: "You can't punish her!"

Applejack: "It wasn't her fault!"

Celestia, dryly: "I'm listening..."

[they all explain how they should've helped]

Celestia: "Looks like you all learned a pretty valuable lesson today..."

All but Celestia: "Mhmm!"

Celestia: "Very well, I'll forget TWilight's punishment on one condition..."

 

I doubt it was anything harsh, though, if you look at how her expression reacts to Twilight's cries moments before, she looks like she thinks Twilight's had enough guilt.

 

 

 

http://www.youtube.c...h?v=PkGBM5Mw2SY

 

Ponified version of

.

 

[windy_prance 114]

OFF WITH HER HORN!!

 

lol just kidding! I bet it was something like "no magic casting for a month" or something like that.

[Kyreth 194]

I don't think she was ever going to. She was either joking or just humouring them.

[NavelColt 22,880]

If you want my opinion, there wasn't going to be one at all other than Celestia verbally reprimanding her like she had been doing, before Twilight's friends ran in. Celestia only mentioned this so-called punishment after they came in and asked her not to punish Twilight, so it leads me to believe that she played along with the fact that they thought there was going to be a punishment, and used the opportunity to corral them all into her friendship mail for learning ponies program.

[Street Comedy 327]

She gets sent to Magic Kindergarten, ooooooooo super scary I know.

 

Celestia has gone too far this time. 0_0

[silvadel 1,393]

No way would celestia do something like that to twilight sparkle -- she was just joking around (which is very much in her character) and playing into the moment. She did a much larger thing at the wedding and did not even get more than an ominous I may have to rethink things.