Thoughts about Mane Six’s Cutie mark, Twilicorn, BOX and Immortal Issue

[Dream Web 2]

             Thoughts About the Connection Between Mane Six’s Cutie Marks, Twilicorn, The BOX and Immortal Issue.

               Hi… I am new here, I had seen many guesses and debate about the show and Twilicorn and Immortal issue as well as that box. Then I had some guesses too. Because it is covering too many things so I decided to open a new topic. And I am not sure had someone else bring out this idea already. After all this is a huge community and I can’t read every single post…

             (Is that OK??? )

              And… English is my second language. SO…say sorry for those verbal mistakes first…

            First, about the aging issue. I believed that every Alicorn are immortal (or can live more than a thousand years) (See note 1). I know many of you say that Twilight and Cadance are not immortal. They are aging like other normal ponies.

            Well… have you seen Twilight Saga (The one has many vampires and werewolves)??? Heard of Bella’s daughter: Renesmee Cullen? I think she is the answer about Alicorn’s aging mystery. They may grow up with the rate like normal pony (or even faster). But the process start slowing down at their mid age and finally stop. Just like Renesmee Cullen. And this actually can explain why Twilight had become a little taller than her friend in S04.

              Second, I want to talk about the box and Mane Six’s cutie Marks. It is grown out from the root of the tree of  harmony. So I think it is not just a box with present in it. I think it can affect the life of the mane six. Probably will be the  solution about the twilicorn’s immortal issue (I hate the idea that she will outlive her friends, too).

              Then, the cutie Marks. I think you had notice EOH was exactly the same shape of Mane Six’s cutie mark. And… In  s04E02 the tree of harmony has twilight’s and the royal sisters’ cutie marks on it.

 For me, it seems like it is a hint to tell us that the mane six are as important as the royal sisters. So that’s why I think that  box was important to the main story line more than for a season maybe for the whole show.

               Finally, you can see what I am thinking now. From the EOH and that tree we learn that Mane Six are important. And the official had confirmed that Twilight won’t outlive her friend. But Alicorn are immortal!!! SO here comes the box.

               Yes, the box. What’s in it? Will it change all the Mane Six become Alicorn?

or it can change some rule that was written.??? I am excited to see what is coming.

        Thank you for reading.

 

Note 1 :

I know that “immortal Alicorn” is an idea that someone think can only put on Royal sisters because there are the goodness control the moon and the sun. But… then what is the point to make two different type of Alicorn? And why the writer want to make Twilight become an Alicorn???

        I have some thought about that too. But I was still not that sure, so better not talk about it now. (That thought involved where does Alicorn come from, it is too complicated.)

At least I believed that there are only one type of Alicorn. 

Edited December 9, 2013 by Dream Web

[ghostfacekiller39 23,879]

I'm going to go get a Pepsi real quick.

 

K.

 

If you're saying all of the mane 6 are going to become alicorns...oh, dear. Some jimmies will be rustled on this topic, I'd bet.

 

 

As for my take on the mane 6 becoming alicorns:

 

Rarity did it first, before it was cool.

 

Just saying.

Edited December 9, 2013 by ~Sadistic ghostfk39~

[Dream Web 2]

I'm going to go get a Pepsi real quick.

 

K.

 

If you're saying all of the mane 6 are going to become alicorns...oh, dear. Some jimmies will be rustled on this topic, I'd bet.

Well...Like what i say. It is just a thought... I had some guesses but it is too early to tell. Maybe not all mane Six become alicorn...(that will be...scary??? Princess Pinky Pie???)

I think it must be something. 

[ghostfacekiller39 23,879]

Well...Like what i say. It is just a thought... I had some guesses but it is too early to tell. Maybe not all mane Six become alicorn...(that will be...scary??? Princess Pinky Pie???)

I think it must be something. 

ALL OF THE MANE 6 WILL BE ALICORNS, AND EVERYONE WILL LIKE IT.

 

THEN DERPY WILL COME BACK AS AN ALICORN.

 

THEN LYRA, AND THEN BON BON, THEN DISCORD, AND EVEN SPIKE AND FLASH SENTRY WILL BECOME ALICORNS!!! MUAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!

 

K. Got that out of my system.

 

They should hire me to write for the show. I think I just had a great idea.

 

Anyway, dude, I think if one of the other 5 becomes alicorns, they should all be alicorns.

Edited December 9, 2013 by ~Sadistic ghostfk39~

[ShadOBabe 19,028]

 

 

I know that “immortal Alicorn” is an idea that someone think can only put on Royal sisters because there are the goodness control the moon and the sun. But… then what is the point to make two different type of Alicorn?

 

The creators of the show straight up said Twilight will not outlive her friends.

That can only mean two things:

 

1) Twilight is not immortal

2) The Mane 6 will ALL become immortal

 

I think the first is more likely.

[Scootalove 10,692]

Twilight will not outlive her friends, since Twilight is not immortal. So, there is no problem here.

[Dream Web 2]

Twilight will not outlive her friends, since Twilight is not immortal. So, there is no problem here.

Twilight is not immortal ... did that have been confirm??? No offense just asking.

The creators of the show straight up said Twilight will not outlive her friends.

That can only mean two things:

 

1) Twilight is not immortal

2) The Mane 6 will ALL become immortal

 

I think the first is more likely.

I know that the creator had said that Twilight will not out live her friends. and I understand your point.

Twilight was not immortal will be the easiest way to solve the outlive problem. 

I just put up another guesses. because I think that will be more dramatic and interesting, and that box makes so many possibility. After all, it is from the EOH, the most powerful thing in the pony world. 

[Scootalove 10,692]

Twilight is not immortal ... did that have been confirm??? No offense just asking.

Yeah, it's been confirmed by the creators of the show.

[ShadOBabe 19,028]

Yeah, it's been confirmed by the creators of the show.

 

All I heard them say was "Twilight will not outlive her friends".

If her friends become immortal like her, then that statement is still true.

[Dream Web 2]

Yeah, it's been confirmed by the creators of the show.

But... it only say "Twilight won't outlive her friend. " That can mean a lot.

[Scootalove 10,692]

All I heard them say was "Twilight will not outlive her friends".

If her friends become immortal like her, then that statement is still true.

That may be true, but I don't think the writers will make her friends immortal like her if there was a reason for it. Maybe, Twilight doesn't want her friends to die and leave her alone.

But... it only say "Twilight won't outlive her friend. " That can mean a lot.

Well, she might not be immortal unless we see it.

[ShadOBabe 19,028]

I personally think the "not immortal" option is the better one.

The creators confirmed that Twilight and her friends will not outlive each other, but they didn't say anything about Cadence and Shining Armor.

If alicorn = immortal, then she's going to have to watch her husband die eventually.

 

You asked, why make two kinds of alicorns? I ask, why NOT make two kinds of alicorns?

There's nothing wrong with it.

[Dream Web 2]

That may be true, but I don't think the writers will make her friends immortal like her if there was a reason for it. Maybe, Twilight doesn't want her friends to die and leave her alone.

 

Well, she might not be immortal unless we see it.

Here is my thought. Royal sisters are godness ruling the moon and sun. What is Twilights duty? I say it will be ruling the EOH. So... if her Friend were die off... what will happened to EOH? Do you think friend can be replace? This is the reason i think mane six is very important to the pony world.

Edited December 9, 2013 by Dream Web

[Scootalove 10,692]

Here is my thought. Royal sisters are godness ruling the moon and sun. What is Twilights duty? I say it will be ruling the EOH. So... if her Friend were die off... what will happened to EOH? Do you think friend can be replace? This is the reason i think mane six is very important to the pony world.

They are important to the pony world because, they are the means of defense in Ponyville or an important whole of Equestria. If a friend were to replace one of the Elements of Harmony if that bearer dies, then they would have to represent the Element physically or spiritually. Not saying, it can't be done.

[Dream Web 2]

I personally think the "not immortal" option is the better one.

The creators confirmed that Twilight and her friends will not outlive each other, but they didn't say anything about Cadence and Shining Armor.

If alicorn = immortal, then she's going to have to watch her husband die eventually.

 

You asked, why make two kinds of alicorns? I ask, why NOT make two kinds of alicorns?

There's nothing wrong with it.

You get the point... that's one of the problems in my theory, and that's the reason why i want it been open discussed.

They are important to the pony world because, they are the means of defense in Ponyville or an important whole of Equestria. If a friend were to replace one of the Elements of Harmony if that bearer dies, then they would have to represent the Element physically or spiritually. Not saying, it can't be done.

Sorry for my basic English... I can't understand what are you trying to say...(only the last part... what can't be done? )

 

Let's Explain this way. Due to Elements were returned to the tree. The friendship between mane six are the only defense power left that they can use. (Like in the movie Equestria girl, they activate the power of the harmony without elements. )

 

My thought that mane six should be immortal is that if they die of age. Who can protect Equestria then? Find another six pony and let them become friend? I say no to that, because their cutie marks are on that tree! This is a sign that mane sixs cannot be replaced for me.

 

 

And... no offense... for that i can't understand you...

Edited December 9, 2013 by Dream Web

[Scootalove 10,692]

You get the point... that's one of the problems in my theory, and that's the reason why i want it been open discussed.

 

Sorry for my basic English... I can't understand what are you trying to say...

 

Let's Explain this way. Due to Elements were returned to the tree. The friendship between mane six are the only defense power left that they can use. (Like in the movie Equestria girl, they activate the power of the harmony without elements. )

 

My thought that mane six should be immortal is that if they die of age. Who can protect Equestria then? Find another six pony and let them become friend? I say no to that, because their cutie marks are on that tree! This is a sign that mane sixs cannot be replaced for me.

 

 

And... no offense... for that i can't understand you...

I'm not really offended. I want the Mane 6 to be immortal too but, I'm afraid that some people won't accept that change.

[Dream Web 2]

I'm not really offended. I want the Mane 6 to be immortal too but, I'm afraid that some people won't accept that change.

Agree... the "Twilicorn issues"...will be the example of people's react to big changes.

Edited December 9, 2013 by Dream Web

[Scootalove 10,692]

Agree... the "Twilicorn issues"...will be the example of people's react to big changes.

If the people who can't get over it, they should really get over it. This is what I think they say: ''I hate change, I don't want change! Everything has to stay the same!''

[Dream Web 2]

If the people who can't get over it, they should really get over it. This is what I think they say: ''I hate change, I don't want change! Everything has to stay the same!''

That sounds like my grandma... lol.

[Scootalove 10,692]

That sounds like my grandma... lol.

Your grandma must hate change.

[Dream Web 2]

Your grandma must hate change.

Ture... internet is on the top of her black list...

[Flight 11 89]

We're talking about how cartoon ponies could outlive one-another

 

 

eeeyup

[ShadOBabe 19,028]

I'm not really offended. I want the Mane 6 to be immortal too but, I'm afraid that some people won't accept that change.

 

Why do you want the Mane 6 to be immortal?

I'm a fan of the "two types of alicorns" theory.

[Scootalove 10,692]

Ture... internet is on the top of her black list...

Hmm, I'm not really surprised. Well anyway, thanks for clearing up the immortality thing.

Why do you want the Mane 6 to be immortal?

I'm a fan of the "two types of alicorns" theory.

The ''two types of alicorns'' theory, I'm not against that. I want them to be immortal because, having one of the EoH die could lead to some problems surrounding the Elements themselves.

[Dream Web 2]

Or any one think of the "Life sharing." ??? Like Dragon Knight did with their Dragon. (Just saying)

Edited December 9, 2013 by Dream Web