What do you think about Pinkie Pie being "evil" in some videos?

[roguesoul 85]

Me too, I love this song. Discovered it from Doctor Who.

[wcgunmaxp 6]

i don't think of her as evil, more autistic and hyperactive. i really don't like watching bronymade videos because they're all stupid lol (but that's just my opinion).

[kelseymarie805 301]

I find some of them interesting, although a lot of them go too far in my opinion.

 

Although I did find one of my favorite songs to date from one of the more mild videos of this sort (if you feel like watching this, there's not any gore or anything, just implication really):

 

 

Haha well that was um....interesting....

 

Kind of disturbing (well, it wasn't too bad, I've seen worse, at least it wasn't gory, it's just the idea of seeing Pinkie Pie like that instead her usual, sweet, happy, bubbly self.....)

[~ Indigo Windigo ~ 232]

Well, some of them are made for creepypasta and some are them are Pinkamena. Though in some MLP Eps, example Filli Vanilli, Pinkie just became a little evil and made fluttershy cry is just to make the episode better

[The Crimson Cross 7,532]

I think I speak for a lot of forum members when I say "I will never forget what happened on that day... When I watched Smile HD" If anyone else has ever heard General Mumble's song "Crack up the Creepy" That's kind of disturbing too!

Edited June 3, 2014 by The Golden Cross

[GreyScholar 1,584]

The Six Winged Serpent -a Cupcakes alternation- by Culu-Bluebeaver

---------------------

Part 1

 

Part 2

Edited June 3, 2014 by EquestrianScholar

[The Leafeon Pinkeh 3,603]

The first thing I think of is Going for a Ride xD

It's because of Pinkemena. Who else to be the evil one but the one that wants the most happiness? It's how grim things work d: 

To make a good enemy, make it from the best "hero" and Pinkie Pie, out of all the ponies, is the one who wishes the most joy. With all the parties and stuff she would make a good enemy for a double-personality of being evil. 

 

Also, she has a canon insane side, so does Twilight, but Pinkie Pie's was more.. creepy o.o 

[Eloquence 2,076]

It makes sense that she would be the one to get this interpretation, to be certain, and I have no problem with it. I do, however, have a problem with people who make such content, for Pinkie or any other pony, and then don't properly flag it as gory and/or frightening, sometimes even going so far as to make it look innocent to deliberately try to trick people (Smile HD being a definite culprit here). Such content is acceptable, but not when you trick sensitive people and young children into watching it, or leave it for them when they're just looking for innocent pony videos to watch.

 

Do what you want, but for Celestia's sake show some consideration!

[GreyScholar 1,584]

Since it seems I can't get all four video working I am going to try spilling them up.

 

Part 3

 

Part 4

[yeet 2,027]

My friend told me to watch smile hd once, eventually I saw it on my pc. It was funny as fuck to me, but the rainbow dash bit where pinkie jumps on her made me feel sick a bit, but doesn't anymore now I've seen it so much.

Cupcakes hd is the funniest of the two, and that song is amazing.

[Artist-Sky 23]

Cupcakes creeped me out WAY MORE than Smile... WAY MORE!

Edited June 8, 2014 by Artist-Sky

[Ziggy + Angel + Rain 11,304]

I was already plenty frightened of canon Pinkie Pie lol; I don't need to see any of this fan-made "evil" Pinkie.  It's not something I'd ever deliberately seek out.  Just like I won't be seeking out gory fan art of the ponies - it's just not my thing.

[Nit Pick 247]

Me personally I have a cannibalism phobia.  It just churns my stomach knowing that creepy pasta exists.  It's hard for me to type this post let alone talk about it.  Also seeing/reading about my favorite characters get mutilated just makes me depressed.  Someone couldn't pay me all the money in the world to draw a "Cupcakes" picture.  Even any character getting mutilated, eaten, or (what I discovered recently) chopped up and being sold as meat cuts.  Seeing stuff like this makes my social anxiety disorder all the more prominent.

[Sir Hugsalot 9,359]

It is kinda irony, probably most friendly character from MLP is made into psychopatic sadistic murderer. I mean, in the show if she kills You she'd do it by hugging You to death and it would not be on purpose yet fandom makes her look like some random sadistic mare. For me all of this gory stuff  is not interesting at all, I don't consider it part of canon and I just, well, don't watch it. I just hear about it sometimes. Other thing is that most of stories made by fandom are not something I am interested with, when someone sends one that is not grimdark, gore or clop I will read it (and probably enjoy it) but I don't look for them myself. 

 

Overall - I just don't watch it. In my eyes Pinkie Pie will always be that most random and very friendly pony and I won't spoil that picture with gruesome and dark stories that are spread by fandom. Of course I don't mind people liking them, everyone has right to enjoy the show in any way he/she wants. 

[Artist-Sky 23]

I actually like We're going for a ride.

 

1. The song's awesome

2.There's no gore

3. It's cool animation

4. She ends up hugging a Rainbow Dash plushie or something in the end instead of killing her

[Lord Bradley 1,319]

I find them interesting. I mostly like it, but ONLY if its in like a RP or Fanfiction because it makes them a tad more interesting. But i wont like it at all if people do the concept in canon, i wouldnt like to think Pinkie being a murdering psychopath. Anyways, its my opinon. Only one out of a million

Edited June 13, 2014 by Bradley-MysteryLord