Who wins in a fight

[Disney17 5]

Who would win in a fight in Disneys Robin Hood between Friar tuck and the Sheriff of Nottingham if they were to go at it? 

Edited May 18, 2018 by Disney17

[Black Sabbath 2,487]

Friar Tuck is the monk, right? I doubt he'd have much change to win against the sheriff. 

[ShadOBabe 19,023]

45 minutes ago, Yamet said:

Friar Tuck is the monk, right? I doubt he'd have much change to win against the sheriff. 

He almost beat the Sheriff stupid in the movie, but the Sheriff’s cronies helped gang up on him.

One on one, Friar Tuck.

[Black Sabbath 2,487]

43 minutes ago, ShadOBabe said:

He almost beat the Sheriff stupid in the movie, but the Sheriff’s cronies helped gang up on him.

One on one, Friar Tuck.

He did? Oh well, it's been a while since I watched it so I must have forgotten that scene. 

[ShadOBabe 19,023]

4 minutes ago, Yamet said:

He did? Oh well, it's been a while since I watched it so I must have forgotten that scene. 

Yeah the Sheriff stole from the church’s Poor Box, and Friar Tuck gave him a beating for it.

The Sheriff is that particular brand of coward that can only seem to fight when he thinks there won’t be any resistance. I’ll have to watch it again, but he seems to only actually fight characters that are less armed than him, or not armed at all. But even though he had a sword, he couldn’t do anything against Friar Tuck’s stick and righteous anger.

One of his buzzard minions had sneak up behind him and blind him with the hood of his robe before the Sheriff got the upper hand.

[Disney17 5]

I found the fight! Friar tuck Imprisoned on You tube. This will give everyone more of an opinion. https://www.google.com/search?source=hp&ei=G_b-Wtj2LaLZjwSs6aqgDA&q=Friar+tuck+imprisoned&oq=Friar+tuck+imprisoned&gs_l=psy-ab.3..0.983.4751.0.5227.21.19.0.0.0.0.221.2728.0j15j1.16.0..2..0...1.1.64.psy-ab..5.16.2715...0i131k1j0i3k1j0i22i30k1j0i22i10i30k1.0.gkm79-wC6zY

[Disney17 5]

Friar tuck was pretty short too compared to the sheriff.

[Dreambiscuit 11,134]

The Sheriff is big and burly but he's all show and no go. He lets his cronies do all the dirty work while he throws his weight around. Friar Tuck may be a bit out of shape but he can throw down when push comes to shove. My money is on the Friar. 

[Disney17 5]

10 hours ago, Dreambiscuit said:

The Sheriff is big and burly but he's all show and no go. He lets his cronies do all the dirty work while he throws his weight around. Friar Tuck may be a bit out of shape but he can throw down when push comes to shove. My money is on the Friar. 

Watching that scene again you think the Friar wins that fight if that bird doesn't intervene?  

On May 18, 2018 at 11:13 AM, ShadOBabe said:

Yeah the Sheriff stole from the church’s Poor Box, and Friar Tuck gave him a beating for it.

The Sheriff is that particular brand of coward that can only seem to fight when he thinks there won’t be any resistance. I’ll have to watch it again, but he seems to only actually fight characters that are less armed than him, or not armed at all. But even though he had a sword, he couldn’t do anything against Friar Tuck’s stick and righteous anger.

One of his buzzard minions had sneak up behind him and blind him with the hood of his robe before the Sheriff got the upper hand.

Watching the scene again he did have his stick sliced in half but he still was fighting hard. The Sheriff though only had height to his advantage. If they were the same size he would have been finished. Little John, Robin Hood and Lady Kluck all took him down earlier in the movie or Robin Hood again at the end.

[Plonkett 345]

Friar Tuck would, without the Sheriff's minions.

Edited May 22, 2018 by vgmaster9

[Disney17 5]

The Sheriff did put up a fight against Robin Hood at the end but Robin took him down.

[Narcissus 356]

Tuck would win because he has conviction on his side where the Sheriff is just Prince John's stooge. The Sheriff has no personal investment beyond his job title, and sends his lackeys to do most of his work anyway.

[Disney17 5]

On June 1, 2018 at 11:54 PM, Narcissus said:

Tuck would win because he has conviction on his side where the Sheriff is just Prince John's stooge. The Sheriff has no personal investment beyond his job title, and sends his lackeys to do most of his work anyway.

Very true.

[SharpWit 2,844]

I assume you mean the anthropomorphic versions?

[Disney17 5]

10 minutes ago, SharpWit said:

I assume you mean the anthropomorphic versions?

The Disney movie yes.

[Disney17 5]

Prince John was too scared to fight and the Sheriff lost in every fight he was in during the movie. This would be an interesting matchup.

[ShadOBabe 19,023]

The Sheriff, definitely. Prince John is the more entertaining character, but he’s a sniveling little noodle. The only talent he’s shown to have is tantrum throwing.

Meanwhile, while certainly not the best, The Sheriff does have strength and basic combat training at the very least.

[Disney17 5]

Just now, ShadOBabe said:

The Sheriff, definitely. Prince John is the more entertaining character, but he’s a sniveling little noodle. The only talent he’s shown to have is tantrum throwing.

Meanwhile, while certainly not the best, The Sheriff does have strength and basic combat training at the very least.

He fought Robin Hood but lost and the same with Little John and lost. He fought Lady Kluck also and got flipped over. He was 0-3. Prince John got his sword knocked out of his hands by Robin Hood then backed away. Little John threatened him and he backed off. The Sheriff at least didn't back down.

[ShadOBabe 19,023]

Just now, Disney17 said:

He fought Robin Hood but lost and the same with Little John and lost. He fought Lady Kluck also and got flipped over. He was 0-3. Prince John got his sword knocked out of his hands by Robin Hood then backed away. Little John threatened him and he backed off. The Sheriff at least didn't back down.

Just because he was bested by several others, doesn’t mean EVERYONE can take him. There’s a reason he’s able to shove a lot of civilians around.

And like you yourself pointed out, to win a fight you have to at least show up. He may not win, but at least the Sheriff shows up. Meanwhile Prince John is likely hiding somewhere.

[Disney17 5]

Just now, ShadOBabe said:

Just because he was bested by several others, doesn’t mean EVERYONE can take him. There’s a reason he’s able to shove a lot of civilians around.

And like you yourself pointed out, to win a fight you have to at least show up. He may not win, but at least the Sheriff shows up. Meanwhile Prince John is likely hiding somewhere.

Yep Prince John was afraid. I forgot though Friar tuck was the only one that didn't beat the Sheriff so the Sheriff did win one fight. Heck even the captain crocodile was more of a fighter than Prince John.

[ShadOBabe 19,023]

4 minutes ago, Disney17 said:

Yep Prince John was afraid. I forgot though Friar tuck was the only one that didn't beat the Sheriff so the Sheriff did win one fight. Heck even the captain crocodile was more of a fighter than Prince John.

Eh, I’m not sure I’d call the Sheriff and Friar’s fight a win for Sheriff. He was getting his butt kicked till one of the vultures blinded Friar Tuck.

[Disney17 5]

39 minutes ago, ShadOBabe said:

Eh, I’m not sure I’d call the Sheriff and Friar’s fight a win for Sheriff. He was getting his butt kicked till one of the vultures blinded Friar Tuck.

I'm not positive Friar would have won. The Sheriff cut his stick in half and it seemed like the tide was turning. The Friar was still fighting hard though. What do you think?

Edited August 31, 2018 by Disney17

[Disney17 5]

One thing we can say is Sir Hiss was the biggest wimp of all time lol.

[Dreambiscuit 11,134]

Neither Prince John nor the Sheriff are what I'd call particularly menacing. But in a battle between the two, I'd go with the Sheriff. Prince John is just a craven worm and would likely run rather than fight. And the Sheriff wouldn't need to do much more than sit on him to claim his victory. 

[Disney17 5]

On September 1, 2018 at 11:57 PM, Dreambiscuit said:

Neither Prince John nor the Sheriff are what I'd call particularly menacing. But in a battle between the two, I'd go with the Sheriff. Prince John is just a craven worm and would likely run rather than fight. And the Sheriff wouldn't need to do much more than sit on him to claim his victory. 

Prince John was the weakest or one of the weakest Villians of all time.