What if MLP dropped Applejack and Rarity?

[~Scootaloo 440]

It'd lose me as a viewer, as Rarity and Applejack are obviously the two best ponies. Seriously though, I can't believe people prefer One-Dimensional Dash, Lemming Pie, and Doormat Shy over them.

 

lol.

Wow... talking quite a bit of trash are we? because Applejack and Rarity have so much depth. Honestly though AJ and Rarity are nice however they are not any better than the others.

 

For those of you who talk trash about others...

[Stellafera 3,836]

You know, I just realized something. Rarity seems to be one of the less popular mane Six, and the reasoning I've heard is that bronies can't relate to her. But look at our fandom, particularly its huge creative and artistic side. Rarity is, at heart, an artist. You'd think that more in the community would connect with her through that.

 

*raises hand*

 

I identify with Rarity. I like fashion and I tend to act dramatic and I consider myself somewhat generous...

 

But, yeah, the "nobody cares" argument is clearly invalidated by the direct evidence on this very thread against it. "Nobody would miss" them is directly destroyed as a reason by the multiple bronies on her who demonstrate that they WOULD miss Applejack and Rarity.My reaction overall is

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nAvmOccqPNk

[Bucky McGillyCuddy 956]

Ah, us Bronys always say the funniest things. 

 

Applejack and Rarity are my favorite characters and I love that they're the least popular characters of the Mane 6, it makes them more...mine. I'd probably still watch the show but i'd definitely be a little upset about it.  

[~Scootaloo 440]

Ah, us Bronys always say the funniest things. 

 

Applejack and Rarity are my favorite characters and I love that they're the least popular characters of the Mane 6, it makes them more...mine. I'd probably still watch the show but i'd definitely be a little upset about it.  

I can kind of understand that. I like Scootaloo she is my second favorite however a lot of people don't care for her. Fluttershy is currently number one even with her big fan base.

[Derpy Azusa 272]

I like Apple Jack but not so much with Rarity however if they took them out it wouldn't be the same show so I don't see how that is possibly a good idea.

[Thundershock 310]

Drop Applejack and Rarity,2 main characters? No no no,that would not be good.But maybe in season 4, they might have alot more applejack and rarity episodes.

[Stellafera 3,836]

Drop Applejack and Rarity,2 main characters? No no no,that would not be good.But maybe in season 4, they might have alot more applejack and rarity episodes.

 

Season 4, Episode 1: Twilicorn

Season 4, Episode 2: Twilicorn

Season 4, Episode 3: Applejack and Rarity go to a painting workshop

Season 4, Episode 4: Rarity finds out that she's not so different from Applejack after all

Season 4, Episode 5: Applejack has an argument with her sister

Season 4, Episode 6: Rarity gets lost in the Everfree and has to find her way back out

Season 4, Episode 7: Applejack and Rarity face off once more against the diamond dogs

Season 4, Episode 8: Applejack gets hit on the head and becomes convinced that she is Rarity

Season 4, Episode 9: Applejack goes to a dance party

Season 4, Episode 10: Rarity gets hit in the head and becomes convinced that she is Applejack

Season 4, Episode 11: The entire cast gets hit in the head and half think they are Applejack and half think they are Rarity

Season 4, Episode 12: Rarity tries too hard to have fun with Sweetie Belle and just annoys her instead

Season 4, Episode 13: Rarity makes deliberately bad dresses out of spite for one fashion critic, but they become successful

Season 4, Episode 14: Applejack and Rarity play D&D

Season 4, Episode 15: Applejack decides to don the Mare Do Well costume once more

Season 4, Episode 16: Applejack reveals her Manehatten accent that she affected as a filly (TOTES NOT STOLEN FROM FANFIC)

Season 4, Episode 17: Rarity goes to the junkyard

Season 4, Episode 18: Applejack goes to the mall

Season 4, Episode 19: Rarity goes to the store. With Applejack.

Season 4, Episode 20: Rarity feels jealous of Applejack's athletic abilities

Season 4, Episode 21: Applejack feels jealous of Rarity's non-fail acting abilities

Season 4, Episode 22: Rarity finds out that SHES A MARSHMALLOW

Season 4, Episode 22: Rarity finds out that that doesn't stop her from being AN ALICORN MARSHMALLOW

Season 4, Episode 23: Applejack finds out that SHES AN ACORN

Season 4, Episode 24: Applejack finds out that that doesn't stop her from being AN ALACORN

Season 4, Episode 25: Applejack eats an orange

Season 4, Episode 26: Fluttershy episode

[Twinhead B 482]

Wow... talking quite a bit of trash are we? because Applejack and Rarity have so much depth. Honestly though AJ and Rarity are nice however they are not any better than the others.

 

For those of you who talk trash about others...

 

Clearly you didn't realize I was kidding. All of the Mane 6 are important to the show, and none of them are truly one dimensional (though Season 1 Rainbow Dash was barely tolerable).

[~Scootaloo 440]

 

Clearly you didn't realize I was kidding. All of the Mane 6 are important to the show, and none of them are truly one dimensional (though Season 1 Rainbow Dash was barely tolerable).

If I didn't realize that you were kidding do you really think I would've included that sound clip too? XD

 

If include a fun audio bit then that is when you can tell I'm not being [completely] serious.

Edited March 9, 2013 by DarkEly

[NomDeSpite 452]

I think what needs to be done regarding Rarity and Applejack (also to a lesser extent Rainbow Dash) is that they need to exemplify the traits of the Elements Of Harmony better. That's really one of my only complaints with FiM as a whole. Applejack should be more brutally honest, Rarity should be more generous. Doing this would probably result in a big popularity boost for both characters. Also, what exactly is the difference between kindness and generosity? The show needs to do a better job of clarifying that.

[~Cider Barrel~ 125]

least popular

 

You anger me good sir i love Applejack, she is my top favourite up there  with Rd Scootaloo and spitfire!

 

Rarity is still awesome, if there did drop these 2 i think i agree with Rarity in saying it would "BE THE WORST! POSSIBLE!! THING!!!"

 

 

eason 4, Episode 25: Applejack eats an orange

 

 

This really shocked me, i was so scared its not right! it s UNACCEPTABLE! Dang right crazy! I would rather sacrifice a goat to the Elder Ponies then see this episode! 

Edited March 9, 2013 by ~Cider Barrel~

[poniesforfun 716]

I think what needs to be done regarding Rarity and Applejack (also to a lesser extent Rainbow Dash) is that they need to exemplify the traits of the Elements Of Harmony better. That's really one of my only complaints with FiM as a whole. Applejack should be more brutally honest, Rarity should be more generous. Doing this would probably result in a big popularity boost for both characters. Also, what exactly is the difference between kindness and generosity? The show needs to do a better job of clarifying that.

 

That's really no excuse since Rainbow Dash doesn't showcase loyalty as much either. The fact that there aren't many Rarity and Applejack episodes and representations means the writers have no idea on what plot to write them in (Apple Reunion was terrible and looked like it was forced imo).

[Pumpkinbot 69]

What if mlp made it so ponies regularly burst into flames

 

 

what if mlp gave Celestia a talking hand bag that yelled racist slurrs

 

 

what if mlp killed the cutie mark crusaders

 

 

 

 

Aren't questions that will never happen fun?

WHY CAN I NOT FAVORITE COMMENTS?!

 

But, yeah, that will never happen, OP. That's...very shallow thinking.

 

Jokingly, nobody would notice AJ gone, and the Mane 4 just wouldn't have dresses, hurr durr.

[Miss Light Diamond 2,802]

If that happened...I would go to the main Hasbro headquarters and punch the owner in the face, then punch all the writers then come home and complain about it...no...just no.

Applejack and Rarity are so freaking awesome and if they show got rid of them...I would cry