Will you guys stop being bronies because of this whole Alicorn Twilght thing?

[ColtofPersonality 855]

There's a pit in my stomach whenever I see or read about her. It sits near the middle of my pecks and it hurts alot. I'm trying to be optimistic for the future ahead.  However even if I do stop watching my friends here on the forum are what matters most to me and I won't walk away from them. I'll just not watch anymore simple as that.

Edited March 4, 2013 by GolgoXIII

[Sir.Flutter Hooves 2,953]

There's a pit in my stomach whenever I see or read about her. It sits near the middle of my pecks and it hurts alot. I'm trying to be optimistic for the future ahead however even if I do stop watching my friends here are what matters and I won't walk away from them. I'll just not watch anymore simple as that.

What do you mean a pit in your stomach? Like a worry or something of that sort. I got that before this whole Twilcorn thing, but everytime I read something about it I get excited. 

 

And just my personal advice don't quit the show. Season 4 will be awesome, Daniel Ingram, and Megan McCarthy already said so. But if you choose to do that, I'll still count you as one of my briny brethren. 

 

Thanks and bro hoof /)

[cuteycindyhoney 13,307]

while I agree with you about the many possibilities that Alicorn Twilight will bring, I disagree with little girls out numbering bronies. Without bronies, this show would get maybe a million, a million and a half tops. But now it's getting alot more then that.

Bronies are by far more vocal than the intended audience demographic. That doesn't mean there are more of them. Think of the toys. Most of them are shunned by Bronies, and openly mocked. Yet, they're flying off of the shelves. I bet for every one Brony buying a Hasbro pony toy, there are several hundred parents buying that same toy for a child.

[Sir.Flutter Hooves 2,953]

Bronies are by far more vocal than the intended audience demographic. That doesn't mean there are more of them. Think of the toys. Most of them are shunned by Bronies, and openly mocked. Yet, they're flying off of the shelves. I bet for every one Brony buying a Hasbro pony toy, there are several hundred parents buying that same toy for a child.

Yet the bronies keep buying theme. Have you not checked the MLP page? Recently there have been posts about new upcoming toys from the show, one being Stephen Magnet. Stephen Magnet being the serpent from episode one. I'm pretty sure that little girls will not understand this.

[PoniesPlease 365]

I know this topic has been done before, but I just wanted to know.

 

I won't, I think the show evolving so early is a good sign for what is to come. 

 

So, will you guys quite being bronies, and do you think this fandom is dying?

 

Thanks, and bro hoof. /)

 

(P.S. I'm not one of those dramatic bronies who freak out at every little change. Just wanted to know your guys' input on this.)

There shouldn't be that much of a problem with Alicorn Twilight. She's been on our screens for 3 minutes, and obviously has had no time for any development in that brief time. To leave the fandom over that would be very... petty, I think.

 

My point is that I find it more an act of attention seeking rather than genuine concern over one character getting wings. No, I will not leave a fandom as great as this because one character got wings for three minutes. If she goes on a murderous rampage and kills all of her friends, only to be stopped by spike, who becomes an Alicorn-Dragon hybrid, maybe then I'll have some question marks. I still wouldn't leave the fandom though.

[Sir.Flutter Hooves 2,953]

There shouldn't be that much of a problem with Alicorn Twilight. She's been on our screens for 3 minutes, and obviously has had no time for any development in that brief time. To leave the fandom over that would be very... petty, I think.

 

My point is that I find it more an act of attention seeking rather than genuine concern over one character getting wings. No, I will not leave a fandom as great as this because one character got wings for three minutes. If she goes on a murderous rampage and kills all of her friends, only to be stopped by spike, who becomes an Alicorn-Dragon hybrid, maybe then I'll have some question marks. I still wouldn't leave the fandom though.

 That sounds like an extremly horrid fanfiction. And as I recall it was only three minutes. I'm praying that when part 3 shows up, Twilight wakes up from a coma and it was all a dream.

 

Thanks and bro hoof /)

[cuteycindyhoney 13,307]

Yet the bronies keep buying theme. Have you not checked the MLP page? Recently there have been posts about new upcoming toys from the show, one being Stephen Magnet. Stephen Magnet being the serpent from episode one. I'm pretty sure that little girls will not understand this.

Little girls don't have to understand the origin of the name to like the toy. A Yahoo bot named him, and it stuck. Steven Magnet is actually a cool name for a serpent if you ask me!

 

 That sounds like an extremly horrid fanfiction. And as I recall it was only three minutes. I'm praying that when part 3 shows up, Twilight wakes up from a coma and it was all a dream.

 

Thanks and bro hoof /)

That would be extremely lazy writing if you ask me! Why would they reverse things anyway. The message then would be "Twilight is a failure. She wasn't good enough."

[Sir.Flutter Hooves 2,953]

Little girls don't have to understand the origin of the name to like the toy. A Yahoo bot named him, and it stuck. Steven Magnet is actually a cool name for a serpent if you ask me!

I agree with you, it is a cool name. Let's agree to disagree. I respect your thoughts on this, and bro hoof you. /) 

 

By the way Kim Possible was a pretty cool show.

 

Thanks and bro hoof /)

[ColtofPersonality 855]

What do you mean a pit in your stomach? Like a worry or something of that sort. I got that before this whole Twilcorn thing, but everytime I read something about it I get excited. 

 

And just my personal advice don't quit the show. Season 4 will be awesome, Daniel Ingram, and Megan McCarthy already said so. But if you choose to do that, I'll still count you as one of my briny brethren. 

 

Thanks and bro hoof /)

Not one of worry. More so the feeling of 'Why? What does this accomplish besides hurting your loyal fans who made the show what is is' In a way this change was too soon and more suited to a start of summer kinda ordeal..even if the 3 minutes I saw her were short I wasn't ready to see the change happen so quick.  I mean I like the idea I just wasn't ready to see it so soon.

Edited March 4, 2013 by GolgoXIII

[Harmonic Revelations 8,835]

Whether or not I leave depends almost entirely on whether people stop making this exact topic literally five or six a times a day.

 

Serious, it's a bit ridiculous.

[Scootalove 10,689]

There is no point in leaving just because of one ridiculous thing. The only time I would leave is, if Hasbro does something stupid. But right now, I'm not going anywhere for a long long time.

 

Besides, the Best in the World © does not give up.

[Minecraft200 6]

Bro hoof to all Bronies

 

i will never ever give up on this show even if they made twlight princess.after they made twlicorn princess, theres a lot of new story line that can be used...as always,once a brony,always a brony

[Sir.Flutter Hooves 2,953]

Not one of worry. More so the feeling of 'Why? What does this accomplish besides hurting your loyal fans who made the show what is is' in a way this change was too soon and more suited to a start of summer kinda ordeal..even if the 3 minutes I saw her were short I wasn't ready to see the change happen so quick.  I mean I like the idea I just wasn't ready to see it so soon.

 Well it's better to rip the bandage off quick. Would you rather have let it been a series finale and wonder forever who she did? Or enjoy the ride with her along the trip?

 

Thanks and bro hoof /)

[ColtofPersonality 855]

A finale would have given me some closure atleast. A pre-mature one albeit but I know it couldn't be possibly be ruined anymore then it has. What's worrisome to me is the fact we don't know how bad its gonna be potentially! I mean Lauren Faust [Who stepped down from the show..which should if at all being the warning shot something bad was coming] is a genius and knows her fans like the back of her hand! Look at the Power Puff Girls, Fosters Home For The Imaginary Friends all successful cartoons she helped develop for TV with her husband..She could careless if the show made any money shes just happy making cartoons!

Edited March 4, 2013 by GolgoXIII

[PoniesPlease 365]

There is no point in leaving just because of one ridiculous thing. The only time I would leave is, if Hasbro does something stupid. But right now, I'm not going anywhere for a long long time.

 

Besides, the Best in the World © does not give up.

Hasbro doing something stupid is debatable among some bronies. 

 

But I agree, if you mean "something stupid" in the sense that they start adding characters until we have a mane 20, or if Discord becomes an Alicorn.

[Betez 1,734]

Hell no. This is not a big deal at all. It certainly isn't something worth leavin the Brony fandom over. I am still a Brony, and a pro-Twilicorn.

[Loriem 639]

No way in hay would I leave the fandom just because of another big debate. I am neutral on the subject, but even though all of us a**wipe over reacting pieces of doodle are making big fuss, I will stick around.

 

This debate will make it harder to convince non bronies that we actually "love and tolerate". As we all already know that is a lie.

 

I am more of the "ignore and isolate" kind.

[Megas 27,649]

When hell freezes. 

 

Renouncing your fandon over a change that no has seen in effect yet is incredibly childish. I for one am interested to see where they can take this

[Veronica The Miffvixen 232]

The moment any shipping pair becomes COMPLETELY canon as a relationship, that's where I get off this bus.

 

No sooner, no later.

[Twinhead B 482]

Nope.

 

I'm waiting for Season 4 to air before I judge Alicorn Twilight. Even if I hate it, I doubt it'd impact the show enough to make me leave. I have a feeling I'm gonna be ponying on all the way to the series' end, no matter if it is finished or cancelled.

[hawkflame 3,310]

No way.  Much as I have a problem with Twilicorn, I'm seeing this whole thing through. 

 

That way I can say "I told you so" when it utterly fails.

[Emerald Flame 381]

I don't like the idea, but I'm not leaving. At the most, I'll switch over to the comic series, since Andy Price said it's likely that it will become it's own canon at some point.

[Fluttermoon 192]

Heck no! I will not stop being a brony/pegasister because of Twilight. I still like MLP no matter what. I'm much to attached to it to just throw my hands up and be like "lol nope" Even if I wasn't a fan of twilight becoming an alicorn, I'd still be a fan of it.

[TBB Symphonia 39]

Twilight isn't exactly my favorite pony out of the mane six, but her becoming a princess will not make me stay a brony.

 

 

Being a brony is awesome, we have great music, comedy, fanfic, roleplay, cosplay, and a great show to back it up. We would be losing more then we would gain if someone stopped just because Twilight became a princess.

 

[Buttonmash1973 1,026]

I am not going anywhere after Twilight Sparkle had become an alicorn.

 

Back in the autumn where alicorn Twilight plushie had been shown I did not think it will cause an uproar later.