planning Would Anyone Like to do a Romantic RP?

[Silver Herald 169]

 

 

Yes, Sunset has a lot of info, but... and I say this without judgement or anything similar, I have nothing against her...  Spirit? Are you sure there's  much info there? Every category only has two lines of text, and she's an alicorn, which isn't very well recieved with most people. I don't have a problem with alicorns as long as they aren't overpowered, but they don't fit well into SOLs either, and this is a SOL-type RP. I mean no offense and Spirit does seem like an interesting character, but she wouldn't get my vote.  I'd vote... Scribe Rose Shimmer and Sunset Sky 

That is a good point, and I'm glad you brought it up. Does anyone else have an opinion?

 

 

 

I would like to add my character, just let me find the link http://mlpforums.com...ire-sharp-r4122

Another character above^  

[Ihei 714]

This sounds fun; I'll join with my OC that's been in the most romances, Minty! Therefore, I'd know what to do..! :3 

 

Hope I get accepted!

[The Elusive Cinder 1,328]

I'm afraid I agree: Alicorns have always felt out of place in most RP's whenever I've seen them. I know Spirit might well be an excellent character but...

 

<insert noncommital 'merrgergle' sound here>

[~Rose Shimmer~ 34]

Wait...

 

Yes, Sunset has a lot of info, but... and I say this without judgement or anything similar, I have nothing against her...  Spirit? Are you sure there's  much info there? Every category only has two lines of text, and she's an alicorn, which isn't very well recieved with most people. I don't have a problem with alicorns as long as they aren't overpowered, but they don't fit well into SOLs either, and this is a SOL-type RP.

I mean no offense and Spirit does seem like an interesting character, but she wouldn't get my vote. 

I'd vote...

Scribe

Rose Shimmer

and Sunset Sky 

 

Oh my goodness, vote me? I'm actually surprised, don't know what the vote is for but if you could tell me then I'd be happy about it ^^"

[sunne 660]

@@~Rose Shimmer~, We're basically voting for who should be in this RP. Probably best to read earlier posts xD

[~Rose Shimmer~ 34]

Ohh of course, now I see from the other posts I honestly just figured that out just now...hehehe silly me~ ^.^"

 

(How embarrassing)

Edited October 15, 2013 by ~Rose Shimmer~

[sunne 660]

@@~Rose Shimmer~, Don't worry about it ^-^ I do stuff like that all the time c:

(which prompted my friend Becker to start calling me Mint Derp and then Mont Dorp and several other variations. xD)

Edited October 15, 2013 by Mint Drop

[~Rose Shimmer~ 34]

I'm glad to know that somepony like you would vote for me, thank you again ^^

 

I can't wait until this RP starts

[The Elusive Cinder 1,328]

Huh, I didn't get the standard notifications for new messages on this post...

 

Anywho! I'm still about and hoping this is still going ahead.

 

[**Appleshy** 19]

Why can't she be an alicorn? She won't be overpowering.

[Half-Note 273]

http://mlpforums.com/page/roleplay-characters/_/sonic-wubz-r853

 

Too late to join? I hope not, I haven't busted this OC out in a while. (May even need to edit him now that I think of it.)

[**Appleshy** 19]

http://mlpforums.com/page/roleplay-characters/_/sonic-wubz-r853

Too late to join? I hope not, I haven't busted this OC out in a while. (May even need to edit him now that I think of it.)

Nice OC.

[sunne 660]

@, 
Even if she's not OP, several alicorns are Mary Sues/Gary Stus and are widely disliked.
But the main problem with your OC is that there's barely any information on her.

[**Appleshy** 19]

*Face Palm* Really? She wont overpower anypony, I promise.

[sunne 660]

@, 
Did you really even read the post?
I never said she would overpower any pony.
The biggest problem with your OC is that there's barely any information on her in your page. Sure, she's supposed to be mysterious, but a GM needs information on a character so they can be sure they'll fit.

All this aside, even if she's not a Mary Sue and won't overpower anyone, there still is the fact that she still is an alicorn, and powers or not, non-royal alicorns typically aren't received well in Equestria, and there's also the fact that even with the minimal information you gave, she just wouldn't fit. She would truly fit better in an Adventure RP, rather than a SOL.

@@Silver Herald, 
Any chance of this starting anytime soon?

[Spark_Vision 28]

I would love to join a RO like this. But just one question. What is the plot line for a story like this? No pun intended

[sunne 660]

@@Spark_Vision, As this is a SoL RP, there is no real plot.
We're all in one tow, we find somepony and date and fall in love. That's it.