searching MLP Harry Potter RP! (Searching)

[Salazar Slytherin 3]

Age is important when considering how powerful witch or wizard is, and if we allow that he is still alive it would mean he found a way to extend his life span... something the books, I cannot speak for the movies, show only the Dark Arts have answers for.

 

Yes, you're correct, in that we have no idea exactly what spells the founders most skilled in or their true power but I feel that only skilled wizards and witches with a wish to pass on their knowledge and magic to others would form a school.

 

Dumbledore was powerful enough for Lord Voldemort to be afraid of him, the most feared Dark Arts wizard in history. So much so few were even willing to speak his name, that I feel speaks volumes for how powerful Dumbledore was.

 

What part of the Half Blood Prince are you invoking?

This part

Has you clearly seen Dumbledor performed an advanced spell to destroy the water creatures.  An act that will label him as over powered.

[GreyScholar 1,584]

Here one clearly sees Dumbledore perform an advanced spell to destroy the water creatures. An act that will label him as over powered.

Not overpowered, simply powerful. Now consider a wizard over twice his age and one of the founders of Hogwarts.

 

In such a setting as this I feel the Salazar Slytherin would a high level unicorn yet unicorns aren't long lived so how he is alive woukd still need to be answered... and the original poster made the rule no alicorns except for the headmaster.

 

All in all it would like having Starswirl the Bearded all the sudden appear in the show (please don't bring up the SStB/Discord theory).

 

Updated

Edited February 1, 2014 by EquestrianScholar

[Salazar Slytherin 3]

Not overpowered, simply powerful. Now consider a wizard over twice his age and one of the founders of Hogwarts.

 

In such a setting as this I feel the founders would be alicorns or at the very least high level unicorns, I didn't bring this up before because the fact not all alicorns are immortal/long lived so how he is alice woukd still need to be answered... and the original poster made the rule no alicorns except for the headmaster.

 

All in all it would like having Starswirl the Bearded all the sudden appear in the show (please don't bring up the SStB/Discord theory).

And also the order of the phoenix where he made his escape from his office, Dumbledore has a large verity of powers and spells that we can't put our mind around, we all know how powerful Dummbledor can be and i am sure i can quote more videos to prove this point but here is the thing if you would disallow Salazar Slytherin from the rp then why not just disallow Alicorns as headmasters? They can be twice as powerful a Dumbledore in ever aspect not to mention twice as powerful as salazar.  

[GreyScholar 1,584]

And also the order of the phoenix where he made his escape from his office, Dumbledore has a large verity of powers and spells that we can't put our mind around, we all know how powerful Dummbledor can be and i am sure I can quote more videos to prove this point but here is the thing if you would disallow Salazar Slytherin from the rp then why not just disallow Alicorns as headmasters? They can be twice as powerful a Dumbledore in ever aspect not to mention twice as powerful as salazar.

 

First off, rechecked my last post as I edited it.

 

Second, it matters how you see alicorns. If you believe the royal sisters to be superpowered goddesses, then you correct. If not the otherhoof you do not see them is goddesses or uberpowerful then you case is weaker. That and there is the fact that there are two types of alicorns (though the issue may be farther muddled). As it stands Celestia and Luna are immortal/very long lived while Cadance and Twilight are not. There is also the fact the royal sister are meant to be born alicorns while Cadance and Twilight are ascended alicorns.

 

This does bring up a question though, how and why are the headmasters' alicorns? Reasonably it would make the most sense for them to be acended alicorns, perhaps on taking the office of headmaster they are changed into an alicorn... otherwise it wont make much sense.

Edited February 1, 2014 by EquestrianScholar

[Salazar Slytherin 3]

Objection my opponent as failed to make his/her point. 

[GreyScholar 1,584]

Objection my opponent as failed to make his/her point.

 

The point is that unless Salazar Slytherin is a ghost or celestial level alicorn, the only way he'd still be alive is the use of dark and forbidden magic. Which, because of how both Harry Potter and the MLP universe treats users of dark magic he would not be allowed into the school. Also given his far extended age and being allowed to learn magic far beyond th age of other witches and wizards he would logically be more powerful than both the Lord Voldemort or Dumbledore as both universes used magic that require study and time to learn. Edited February 1, 2014 by EquestrianScholar

[Salazar Slytherin 3]

This is pointless we already went over how powerful Dumbledore can be. Salazar should be allowed into the rp his powers can be easily managed as we only know a few from reading the books, thus making him not even remotely close to being over powered. 

Edited February 1, 2014 by Salazar Slytherin

[Iridescent Quill 70]

On this topic, I'm wondering why Salazar Slytherin would even need to be in school or want to be since he already is well versed in magic. I know you never stop learning, but does he really even want to be with underage wizards learning about stuff he's known since forever? I'd suggest you make him a long lost relative, but it was already said in the books that Tom Riddle aka Voldemort was Slytherin's last relative or heir.

That being said, if the head of this RP wants to include you in which ever which way they want, I won't dispute their decision. I honestly just really want this RP to happen.

[GreyScholar 1,584]

This is pointless we already went over how powerful Dumbledore can be. Salazar should be allowed into the rp his powers can be easily managed as we only know a few from reading the books, thus making him not even remotely close to being over powered.

 

Dumbledore is not a part of this roleplay and if he was as headmaster he would have been an alicorn... so the point you're trying to make is moot.

 

Of any case I think you forgot the most important part of my point so let me quote myself: "The point is that unless Salazar Slytherin is a ghost or celestial level alicorn, the only way he'd still be alive is the use of dark and forbidden magic. Which, because of how both Harry Potter and the MLP_FiM universes treats users of dark magic he would not be allowed into the school."

 

Lastly it should be noted that the Harry Potter wiki says he died during the Middle Ages: http://harrypotter.wikia.com/wiki/Salazar_Slytherin

 

If he wasn't dead, since Hogwarts was founded in 250 AD, Harry graduated in 1998, and the roleplay takes place five years after the books ... that would make Salazar Slytherin older then Princess Celestia and Princess Luna. This is over 2000 years old and I'm sorry but given that age I would definitely say Salazar Slytherin would have a good chance of being much more powerful than Dumbledore as that is over ten times his lifetime.

--------------

 

The only way this could possibly work is he was asleep for that 2000 years, a spell that put him in stasis... either that or by making him a ghost.

Edited February 1, 2014 by EquestrianScholar

[Salazar Slytherin 3]

irrelevant wikis take away from the book and saying he did die would be contradicting J.K rolling.

[GreyScholar 1,584]

irrelevant wikis take away from the book and saying he did die would be contradicting J.K rolling.

No it wouldn't, as all we know is that he disappeared.

 

Of any case don't ignore everything else I said!

Edit: I took this conversation to PM

Edited February 2, 2014 by EquestrianScholar

[XxConfusedUnicornxX 834]

No it wouldn't, as all we know is that he disappeared.

 

Of any case don't ignore everything else I said!

Edit: I took this conversation to PM

Calm yo titties guys! I've removed him from the list!

[GreyScholar 1,584]

Calm yo titties guys! I've removed him from the list!

I apologize for allow it to grow as it did... though you didn't need to outright remove him. My main conserns is in the how and why Salazar Slytherin was still alive... not helped by the fact tha in PM I learn he would actually be 20,000 years old. Also how being alive at such age would not make him anything but overpowered.

 

I ask that instead of removing him from the roleplay you ask th player to explain themselves in the bio and/or PM.

Edited February 2, 2014 by EquestrianScholar

[XxConfusedUnicornxX 834]

I apologize for allow it to grow as it did... though you didn't need to outright remove him. My main conserns is in the how and why Salazar Slytherin was still alive... not helped by the fact tha in PM I learn he would actually be 20,000 years old. Also how being alive at such age would not make him anything but overpowered.

 

I ask that instead of removing him from the roleplay you ask th player to explain themselves in the bio and/or PM.

Well having a 20 000 year old man as a student would be weird wouldnt it?

[GreyScholar 1,584]

Well having a 20 000 year old man as a student would be weird wouldnt it?

I believe the player wanted to actually be a teacher.

[XxConfusedUnicornxX 834]

I believe the player wanted to actually be a teacher.

oh o_o okay then XD I will make the change if he wishes to be one... tomorrow. I'm tired from studying

[GreyScholar 1,584]

oh o_o okay then XD I will make the change if he wishes to be one... tomorrow. I'm tired from studying

Also another issue we have been discussing is that his great age would be possible only through being marked as a user of the blackest of Dark Magic, the same magic Voldermort used, or through drnking unicorn blood... that too must be covered.

Edited February 2, 2014 by EquestrianScholar

[XxConfusedUnicornxX 834]

Also another issue we have been discussing is that his great age would be possible only through being mark him as a user of the blackest of Dark Magic, the same magic Voldermort used, or through drnking unicorn blood... that too must be covered.

Hmmmmm I guess so... *ponders*

[GreyScholar 1,584]

Wait... since we are playing this MLP style the 'drinking unicorn blood for immortality' won't really be an option for Salazar. Especially if he will be a pureblood unicorn himself

Edited February 2, 2014 by EquestrianScholar

[XxConfusedUnicornxX 834]

Wait... since we are playing this MLP style the 'drinking unicorn blood for immortality' won't really be an option for Salazar.Edpecially if he will be a pureblood unicorn himself

CANNIBALISM :OOOOO Thats cruel XD

[GreyScholar 1,584]

Also for future referance, I am using my phone and mistakes have been common. As I do try and fix my mistakes I ask that any that quote me wait 30 seconds, refresh the page, and then quote.

 

CANNIBALISM :OOOOO Thats cruel XD

Actually this reminds me: one part of Harry Potter is the subject of racism being pureblood witches and wizard of muggle-born parents, in addition to mixed blood of another races... we can use this.

 

'Purebloods' would be unicorns while 'mudbloods' would be earth ponies spellcasters, any that have a nonpony parent will be a 'mixed blood' spellcaster.

 

For one, this will give Slytherin students those to bully, insult, and raise there snouts up at. This and it would allow us the means of having smiliar conflict.

Edited February 2, 2014 by EquestrianScholar

[Armin 168]

Please tell me sign ups aren't closed! If not, is it possible to join with two characters please?

If so for both, could I join with Chipper in Hufflepuff and Rai in Ravenclaw please?

[Pripyat Pony 2,608]

@@EquestrianScholar, Works for me! Especially since my Slytherin character Diego is a unicorn. XD

 

I'd also say that it would be better if Salazar Slytherin wasn't in the RP at all, as this RP focuses on students and it's canon anyway that Slytherin never returns to the castle after the argument with Gryffindor. The user would be best suited to joining as a regular student.

[Salazar Slytherin 3]

@Pripyat Pony ,  Godric and Salazar just had an argument it's not like where he said "you know what get out and never return."  Salazar left of his own free will after he built the chamber of secrets.

[Pripyat Pony 2,608]

You're preaching to the converted. I've read the books hundreds of times, and did so from the very moment each of them came out. He argued with Gryffindor, then left the castle, never to return. In any case, that's irrelevant. What's relevant is that there's no point in insisting on this; either join with a regular student or teacher or make your own RP if you want to be Slytherin cuz Confused Unicorn already said that they removed you from the list.