Jump to content
Guidelines

SunsetShimmerStan

User
 View Profile  See their content

  • Posts

    62

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Recent Profile Visitors

The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.

SunsetShimmerStan's Achievements

Parasprite

Parasprite (4/23)

36

Brohooves Received

  1. SunsetShimmerStan
    Technically Forgotten Friendship, Rollercoaster of Friendship, Spring Breakdown, and Sunset's Backstage Pass are technically TV movies too. I would say Rollercoaster of Friendship, Spring Breakdown, and Sunset's Backstage Pass make their own trilogy too as more light hearted fare that focuses more on the rest of the Rainbooms (Rarity, Applejack, Rainbow Dash, and Pinkie) and happen outside the school.
  2. SunsetShimmerStan
    Okay then. Also, how would you have fixed up Legend of Everfree? Considering it helped in fleshing out the Sunset and Sci-Twi friendship dynamic that is pretty important for the show, how would you have tried to fix Legend of Everfree and give a better showing of their dynamic?
  3. SunsetShimmerStan started following How did MLP Friendship is Magic fare compared to other long runners in quality? , What do you prefer between Friendship games and Legend of Everfree? , I would’ve loved to see a Sunset and Fluttershy centric special and 3 others
  4. SunsetShimmerStan
    So how would you have fixed Legend of Everfree then and made Sci-Twi's arc more enjoyable? Considering the movie does help in fleshing out the Sunset/Sci-Twi dynamic that is pretty important, how would you have improved it? So how would you have fixed Rainbow Rocks and Legend of Everfree then?
  5. SunsetShimmerStan
    Same. Though any idea on what potential story they'd share in a 44-minute special?
  6. SunsetShimmerStan
    So how much different are things now that Legend of Everfree and the other later EQG stuff have given more Sci-Twi content? Also, looks like Sunset prefers to stay in the human world anyway so that's one point in favor of Sci-Twi/Sunset.
  7. SunsetShimmerStan
    Then what story would you make from that? Pinkie and Fluttershy competing would be more out of character than Applejack and Rainbow Dash. Plus considering they teased AppleDash in the finale, AppleDash could've used at least one more episode given it'd been a while since the last AppleDash outing.
  8. SunsetShimmerStan
    So then what would have been the main plot for seasons 7 and 8 without the Pillars and School of Friendship? Like what would take the place of being the two-parter finale for seasons 7 and 8 and the season 8 premiere two-parter? As well as who the main villains for seasons 7 and 8 would be? How come you don't like the idea of having more than one group of six friends who have the magic of friendship?
  9. SunsetShimmerStan
    So what do you think are the MLP episodes that prove it is possible to have a good 22-44 minute episode without an antagonist? After all, most of the MLP two-parters (which the Equestria Girls specials are the equivalent of) always had a villain and even The Crystalling (the only two-parter without an antagonist) had a big threat too with the snow storm in the Crystal Empire caused by the Crystal Heart shattering.
  10. SunsetShimmerStan
    The trouble is though with making the reunion it's own story is that there still needs to be some set up on why Sunset chooses that specific time to reconcile with Celestia (given it is implied she was too afraid to talk to Celestia after everything that happened and only talked to her when she had no choice and needed her help for get her friends' memories back), a potential conflict in this, and how to make a 44-minute plot out of that.
  11. SunsetShimmerStan
    Juniper doesn't show up. Though the Shadowbolts do indeed return (except Indigo Zap) and we get to see how they're doing after Friendship Games, confirming Cadance took over as principal and Cinch got fired.
  12. SunsetShimmerStan
    How would you have improved Sunset and Sci-Twi's dynamic then in that movie?
  13. SunsetShimmerStan
    Well, how should they have done the Sunset reunion with Celestia? Given your issues with that, how should that have been handled better?
  14. SunsetShimmerStan
    What about for giving Sunset focus in the specials and movies like Legend of Everfree, Mirror Magic, Forgotten Friendship, and Sunset's Backstage Pass? How would you have done a better job giving Sunset better stories that can work for a special or a movie if none of them worked for you? Being the protagonist of EQG means that can't exactly stop giving her movies and specials focusing on her.
  15. SunsetShimmerStan
    Then how could they have done a better job with Sci-Twi? Like, how could they have done a better balance of making her more like her pony counterpart but keeping some differences to avoid making her too identical to the pony counterpart in personality? After all, people give the Humane 5 flak sometimes for being too similar to their pony counterparts and not having enough to flesh them out more, what would stop Sci-Twi from having that issue too? Not to mention having to avoid possible implications and theories on the Rainbooms only befriending her because she's exactly like her pony counterpart, we need some differences to avoid that. How would you have fixed her story in Friendship Games and Legend of Everfree (which are crucial for her arc)?
  16. SunsetShimmerStan
    Seeing how ever long runner is bound to have a at least one weak season, how did MLP FiM fare next to other long runners such as Simpsons, Family Guy, SpongeBob, Fairly OddParents, Adventure Time, and Regular Show in writing quality over the years? I'm especially curious how it fares against Adventure Time and Regular Show given they were also long running story driven 2010s cartoons airing around the same time as MLP (bonus for Adventure Time also having an alternate universe with alternate counterparts spin off with Fionna and Cake like MLP had with Equestria Girls)?
×
×
  • Create New...