If Major MLP Villains ruled Equestria

[cider float 2,539]

So if any of the major MLP villains ruled, who would you rather be ruled under and who would you least want to be under rule as?

 

I would rather be under rule with Nightmare Moon. There won't be a sun anymore and I might get major vitamin D deficiency and who knows how tyrannical Nightmare Moon can get but might be the lesser of evils.

 

I would least like to be under Queen Chrysalis rule as much as I like her character if I was under her rule I would become her complete slave without any thoughts. Hey at least under King Sombra I can be a slave who can think freely.

 

 

She also is so evil here.

Edited May 27, 2015 by cidershield

[EmiliaBoneca 52]

Um i guess the sirens first because i might hate anyone in that world but at least i hear good music
and Final Sombra because i would be a slave and know that im a slave and that would suck

[Black Sabbath 2,486]

I would rather be ruled by Discord, mostly because of chocolate rain. And the one I would want to be ruled by the least would be Nightmare Moon, mostly because I like to be alive. 

[Gestum 2,493]

Discord seems like a some what good leader, I guess I would pick him. 

 

I wouldn't like to be ruled by Nightmare Moon, because you need a sun to be able to live.

[Castle Bleck 19,399]

At least Discord would be Affably Evil and/or a Jerk With A Heart Of Gold.

[Ashen Pathfinder 16,163]

I would probably go with Starlight Glimmer as my top choice. Even considering the brainwashing, she is also the most vulnerable to be overthrown.

 

Sombra would be my least likely. Slavery aside, he is regarded as the dreaded for a reason, and I believe his reign was likely quite cruel. Why else would the crystal ponies be afraid of his return?

[JonasDarkmane 19,790]

I would probably go with Starlight Glimmer as my top choice. Even considering the brainwashing, she is also the most vulnerable to be overthrown.

 

Sombra would be my least likely. Slavery aside, he is regarded as the dreaded for a reason, and I believe his reign was likely quite cruel. Why else would the crystal ponies be afraid of his return?

I have to completely agree with you there. Although I am a huge fan of Sombra, I am quite sure that his rule would be the most cruel one. Go Sombra though 

[A Joe in the Bush 255]

I would prefer to live under Nightmare moon, since a chance exists that she can be cleansed back to Luna, and then It would be normal Equestira again, except with Luna instead of Celestia.

[Black Sabbath 2,486]

I would prefer to live under Nightmare moon, since a chance exists that she can be cleansed back to Luna, and then It would be normal Equestira again, except with Luna instead of Celestia.

So you wouldn't miss the sun?

[A Joe in the Bush 255]

Nope! I never go out in the sun anyway.

[Black Sabbath 2,486]

Nope! I never go out in the sun anyway.

Then there only remains one problem, we would die without the sun.

[Castle Bleck 19,399]

Then there only remains one problem, we would die without the sun.

 

Kind of need solar stuff for plants, after all.

Edited May 28, 2015 by A.V.

[A Joe in the Bush 255]

. . . Well, Presumably, Nightmare Moon would understand that, and move the moon once in a while, Letting the sun show. Maybe she would just enact laws that made it illegal to be out during the day?

[Kyoshi Frost Wolf 41,997]

The best leader would be....either Discord or Nightmare Moon. Discord would probably be really fun even if it would be very...well, chaotic. Nightmare Moon for the fact that she is all about the night and I like night time more, only thing is we don't really know what else she would do as a tyrannical ruler or even if she would be tyrannical at all. Maybe she just wants the sun gone.

 

Least favorite....Sombra or Starlight. Sombra for the simple fact that he has seemed like the most evil of all the villains so far by having slavery and just being tyrannical in general. Starlight would be terrible because nobody would have personalities of their own and she would make everyone pretty much the same, which would be very bad and not to mention boring.