If a pony had a crush on you

[Parties like Pinkie 385]

I'd say "Pinkie Pie! why are you acting so out of character?" and then we would go back to my place and (removed)

 

She's Pinkie Pie, she's never and yet always in character.

[Mr. Jaguar 1,403]

I'm glad no one wants to defile Fluttershy.

[Laydee Kaze 400]

MFW This thread.

 

I don't like, get crushes on fictional ponies that are 90% female.

 

On the other hand >.>

 

Youallknowwherethisisgoingso... *cough*

 

gentlemen.

[willinilly 134]

I'm glad no one wants to defile Fluttershy.

 

Seeing as this is if they had a crush on us if we were ponies, I personally don't think that Fluttershy would act on any feelings because of her personality.

 

Idk though.

[Mr. Jaguar 1,403]

Seeing as this is if they had a crush on us if we were ponies, I personally don't think that Fluttershy would act on any feelings because of her personality.

 

Idk though.

 

Yes but a lot of people are talking about what they'd do afterwards (if you know what I mean).

 

[media=]http-~~-//www.youtube.com/watch?v=UWnTNSa-k-E[/media]

 

Works for me.

 

[Ant 3]

Depends on the pony of course. I would probably say something like "sure, i like you too" and kiss back. Then i would ask if he/she wants to go out and maybe develop a nice relationship...

[Fawn'd of you 6]

If it was Fluttershy.....I would probably melt on the spot! Then we would get married, take care of each other and live happily ever after!

[DashPony 359]

First I would be very confused....then I would promptly die from shock

[Senor Citizen 516]

It's a good thing I won that trip to Cuba a while back. Just saying.

[Victoria and Co. 782]

I would be extremely confused.

How did a Flash animated, talking, sentient pony from another reality find me, get to know me well enough to fall in love with me, and then kiss me without me even noticing until then? I mean, what the buck, how oblivious can you get?

[KTP Pretorius 16]

If it were Dash, and the one kissed were Kiba, he would just raise one eyebrow and shrug, then return it. He is not a mean fellow. After that, if anypony alse tried,(other than Dash) i'm willing to bet he would glare and maybe a bit show his fangs.

[Mr. Jaguar 1,403]

I'd say "Pinkie Pie! why are you acting so out of character?" and then we would go back to my place and

 

....bake cupcakes?

Edited May 26, 2012 by Pegasus25

[Bendy 1,821]

As a Human hell no, never! I'd run if one of the MLP Ponies did that to me! It would creep the hell out of me. I don't want to even think of the freak of nature abomination mutant babies. XD

 

As a Pony, or was turned into a Pony. I guess I'd be Ok with it, but I'd still feel a bit creeped out if I was once a Human.

 

This thread reminds me of a thread like this: Human relationships with other sentient aliens/beings. Over on FMMB: The Futurama Madhouse.

Edited May 26, 2012 by Rush

[Swit Swat 536]

I'd grab my shotgun.

 

"Buck of B****!"

 

*BOOM*

 

Or, I would kiss her right back and love her forever.

Edited May 26, 2012 by Swit Swat

[SmileForever^.^ 128]

I would probably Blush, and jump on him!!!!

As for Pony i would like Shining armor, but dammit he's married!...

[Noteworthy 41]

I suppose it would depend on the pony.

If it was, say, Applejack, I would be the happiest colt in the world.

 

If it was, say, Mayor Mare, I'd be less than enthralled.

 

Really, though, if it was any of the Mane 6 I'd be pretty happy. But especially with Applejack.

[Graphite 80]

id go with it

[Proailurus 214]

That would never happen obviously, because everypony knows that nopony would ever like me! *eye twitches*

viceversa, still would never happen because I would never have the guts to do that ^^

 

But let's say it, on the .00000000000000000000000000000000000000000002% chance that it did maybe happen, I would prolly be like wtf and it would be really akward and then I would just walk away like nothin happened

[Mr. Jaguar 1,403]

I'd let her give me a ride, if you know what I mean...

 

[Strafe 594]

I would be like

 

[Rizoel & Crepuscule 491]

I would be extremely confused.

How did a Flash animated, talking, sentient pony from another reality find me, get to know me well enough to fall in love with me, and then kiss me without me even noticing until then? I mean, what the buck, how oblivious can you get?

 

Well, remember OP did say:

 

You are a pony and another pony has a crush on you.

 

If you were both ponies and you both grew up living as ponies, then I think the whole situation would be perfectly fine. So just imagine what would happen if both of you were humans, then the reaction would still apply to that situation. AKA Nothing wrong with it.

 

But anyway, if I saw two entirely different species walking down the street, holding hands/hooves, I would actually be all for what they got between them. They love each other too much to care about something silly like difference in species.

 

Why would I be OK with this?

 

It's because neither of them are animals. They can both talk, show emotions, and can experience the feeling of being in love the same way us humans can. They're technically not animals, so why can they NOT be together? It's not like the universe would care.

 

Think about it this way: About 100 years ago or so, if a black guy and a white girl were seen together even platonically, they would get all sorts of s**t coming from some of the people back then. (I know not everyone was like that, but still.)

 

And today, something like homosexual couples are mostly accepted in most of today's society.

 

So what if, we could take this another step further, and apply this to difference in species that are also sentient?

 

Of course, we don't really need to do that today, seeing as humans are pretty much the only sentient species on the planet.

 

Now as for something like Humans doing 'you-know-what' with NON-sentient creatures...

I try to stay open-minded, but I think a relationship like this just simply won't work.

I know that some animals actually don't mind about bestiality, (How many times has your dog tried to hump your leg? Yeah...) but animals can't really experience that feeling of being in love the same way humans do. I just can't see that as OK.

 

But that's my opinion on this whole 'inter-species relationship' doohickey. As long as both of them are aware that they're in love with one another, I got no problem with it. It's not like I would be able to do much about it even if I did.

 

But anyway, how would I react if I were kissed by a pony, as a pony? My reaction would be the same if I was a Human being kissed by another human - provided they are the opposite gender of me.

 

If it were someone/somepony I had feelings for, my brain would explode. After recovering, I would tell them from the bottom of my heart that I too had feelings for them all along, and apologize for being a coward and not acting sooner.

 

If it were someone/somepony I was friends with, but didn't have feelings for, my brain would still explode. If someone shows that they have feelings for me, that would be more than enough for me to quickly develop feelings for them.

 

Now let's mix it up a bit. If I were a human and the one to show feelings was a pony, I believe my reaction would be indifferent from what my reaction would be if she was human. In other words, I wouldn't mind all that much.​ (Especially if it was Twilight Sparkle.)

 

If she is friendly, and was aware that we could not have kids, (Except maybe via adoption.) but still wanted to be with me and we were both sure that neither would get any diseases from... 'trying' to have kids if we were both OK with going that far, I wouldn't mind being with her like that. (Please be Twilight Sparkle. *Creepy Grin*)

 

If it turns out that we might catch some disease by doing stuff like that thanks to differences in biology or something, I think I would still want to be with her, even if we couldn't do something like that. If she still wanted us to be together, I would pinkie promise to not leave her for anypony else.

And mean it.

 

Just because I can't 'You-know-what' with them doesn't mean I won't stop loving them.

 

I know, I'm a bit of a romantic, but I really do mean this.

Edited May 28, 2012 by Crepuscule

[Victoria and Co. 782]

Well, remember OP did say:

 

 

 

If you were both ponies and you both grew up living as ponies, then I think the whole situation would be perfectly fine. So just imagine what would happen if both of you were humans, then the reaction would still apply to that situation. AKA Nothing wrong with it.

 

But anyway, if I saw two entirely different species walking down the street, holding hands/hooves, I would actually be all for what they got between them. They love each other too much to care about something silly like difference in species.

 

Why would I be OK with this?

 

It's because neither of them are animals. They can both talk, show emotions, and can experience the feeling of being in love the same way us humans can. They're technically not animals, so why can they NOT be together? It's not like the universe would care.

 

Think about it this way: About 100 years ago or so, if a black guy and a white girl were seen together even platonically, they would get all sorts of s**t coming from some of the people back then. (I know not everyone was like that, but still.)

 

And today, something like homosexual couples are mostly accepted in most of today's society.

 

So what if, we could take this another step further, and apply this to difference in species that are also sentient?

 

Of course, we don't really need to do that today, seeing as humans are pretty much the only sentient species on the planet.

 

Now as for something like Humans doing 'you-know-what' with NON-sentient creatures...

I try to stay open-minded, but I think a relationship like this just simply won't work.

I know that some animals actually don't mind about bestiality, (How many times has your dog tried to hump your leg? Yeah...) but animals can't really experience that feeling of being in love the same way humans do. I just can't see that as OK.

 

But that's my opinion on this whole 'inter-species relationship' doohickey. As long as both of them are aware that they're in love with one another, I got no problem with it. It's not like I would be able to do much about it even if I did.

 

But anyway, how would I react if I were kissed by a pony, as a pony? My reaction would be the same if I was a Human being kissed by another human - provided they are the opposite gender of me.

 

If it were someone/somepony I had feelings for, my brain would explode. After recovering, I would tell them from the bottom of my heart that I too had feelings for them all along, and apologize for being a coward and not acting sooner.

 

If it were someone/somepony I was friends with, but didn't have feelings for, my brain would still explode. If someone shows that they have feelings for me, that would be more than enough for me to quickly develop feelings for them.

 

Now let's switch around a bit. If I were a human and the one to show feelings was a pony, I believe my reaction would be indifferent from what my reaction would be if she was human. In other words, I wouldn't mind all that much.​ (Especially if it was Twilight Sparkle.)

 

If she is friendly, and was aware that we could not have kids, (Except maybe via adoption.) but still wanted to be with me and we were both sure that neither would get any diseases from... 'trying' to have kids if we were both OK with going that far, I wouldn't mind being with her like that. (Please be Twilight Sparkle. *Creepy Grin*)

If it turns out that we might catch some disease by doing stuff like that thanks to differences in biology or something, I think I would still want to be with her, even if we couldn't do something like that. If she still wanted us to be together, I would pinkie promise to not leave her for anypony else.

And mean it.

 

Just because I can't 'You-know-what' with them doesn't mean I won't stop loving them.

 

I know, I'm a bit of a romantic, but I really do mean this.

 

See, that's what I mean! How would have not noticed that I turned into a pony? It only adds to the confusion.

(I assuming that the question is saying that I wasn't always a pony.)

[Rizoel & Crepuscule 491]

See, that's what I mean! How would have not noticed that I turned into a pony? It only adds to the confusion.

(I assuming that the question is saying that I wasn't always a pony.)

 

No, the question says under the fact that both of you are, and grew up living as ponies.

Edited May 28, 2012 by Crepuscule

[Victoria and Co. 782]

No, the question says under the fact that both of you are, and grew up living as ponies.

 

Knowing me, I'd be just as oblivious if I had been a pony my whole life.

[Mr. Jaguar 1,403]

Snip

 

Well.......my rule is that if she isn't a fully grown adult (like roughly my age), doesn't have boobs, doesn't have curves, and doesn't walk on two legs, than I just can't, not even if she encompassed my dream woman, don't care, not touching that with a 50 foot pole. Tho, I guess you could argue that it's not wrong if it's one of ponies from equestria as long as he/she is an adult able to consent, since they're sentient and can communicate like humans, and therefore are capable of consent, pretty much getting rid of the amorality part of beastiality.......still, for me, I just can't, it still feels wrong to me.

 

This reminds me of shrek 2, how fiona's father was permanently transformed into a sentient talking frog at the end of the movie, but his human wife still chose to be with him romantically, and I don't recall hearing anyone talking about it as if it were wrong (then again I never thought about it being wrong till now).

Edited May 28, 2012 by Pegasus25