Who was your first MLP crush

[SIgmaBETA 98]

For me it was all about Trixie because she is a witch and i like witches, and maybe a little Twilight

[Splashee 28,601]

@SIgmaBETA

When you are talking about FIM obliquely, such as asking about favorite characters, post your topic in Sugarcube Corner.

Your thread has been moved to Sugarcube Corner section of the forum.

[Megalobronia 193]

Rarity. She still is my crush to this day.

[Mlpfan23 7]

I had never any crush on any pony but I may have crush on their human counterpart. 

So my first crush was fluttershy 

Edited September 29, 2023 by Mlpfan23

[XxR3ckl3ss 22]

Rainbow Dash, to this day I've always thought she was the coolest

[Never Returning 28,616]

My first pony crush was Fluttershy, all the way back in 2017 when I first got into the show. She's no longer my #1 favorite pony, but she's still my favorite of the Mane 6.

[Crash_xox 376]

Rainbow Dash, when she bumped into Twilight in the first ep I felt like she was gonna be my fav pony. She's just 20% cooler.

[Rethajni 2,826]

I would say Rarity because she is just like me in many ways, too dramatic, too perfectionist, too artistic and too generous, I felt a conection back in 2013 and felt that nobody would understood me in the pony world like her, and of course I learned from my mistakes, became a better person with time and just be more generous with my friends

[KPackratt 1,249]

Rainbow Dash was my first MLP crush in both Friendship is Magic and Equestria Girls.

[Maplehoof 20]

Of all people, it started with Rarity.  Then it became Coco pommell.. and then magically it evolved into the best pink haired pony around.

Enjoy my silly little scribbles

[Sparklefan1234 184,354]

Twilight Sparkle wasn't my original favorite but she's been my pony crush since she became my favorite.

[ExplosionMare 26,127]

Double Diamond, since I always thought he was cute!