Which Equestria Girls outfits do you like better?

[Snoopy Fan 8,170]

The originals

or the new ones?

[ZiggWheelsManning 13,250]

Not sure if I can choose on this one  

[rottenpawzies 135]

Personally I adore Fluttershy's old design,as well as the others,but I feel like Sunset Shimmer's and Rainbow Dash's new designs fit them more,nonetheless,I prefer the old ones :) Fluttershy is just too cute!!

[Snoopy Fan 8,170]

2 minutes ago, rottenpawzies said:

Fluttershy is just too cute!!

Agreed 

[Dawnshine Wonder 2,723]

On 2025-06-08 at 4:32 PM, Snoopy Fan said:

The originals

or the new ones?

To be honest, I cannot really speak about this as I don't know enough about this or the fashion industry in general, so it would not be helpful for me to have an opinion which is better.

The idea of looking good is not wrong though, I am aware that Equestria Girls is a fashion doll spin off, and some people may be put off by that. But I don't call fashion as inherently bad.

It would be appropriate of me to say something along the lines of this, however, like with men, women should dress the way they feel, and not as others pressure them into. So there are merits to Equestria Girls I had not noticed before.

The negative opinions I once held about Equestria Girls spin off, well, I've changed them, since I've had more time to think it through, being overly critical of it, kind of disrespects Rarity since fashion is her thing, if I am to respect who she is as a character even from MLP FIM, then I've got to make allowances for something like this to happen, plus it's Hasbro's IP, not my own.

Not only this, but I feel hypocritical for some of my old criticisms of Equestria Girls since I began writing an MLP FIM fan fiction of some human souls becoming Ponies in their next life in Equestria if they consented and if ordained to by their spiritual guide, Princess Luna from an alternate reality. Why is it a negative if Mane Six were to transform into humans to visit the world humans inhabit? it's not inherently so. Not all humans are disruptive, and their ethos of friendship is magic can still persist even if they were to visit the world humans inhabit, and the fact that they would try to make our world a better place even if fictional as they are, is something that should be cherished, not shamed.

 

 

[feralfilly 161]

I think they're both really cute, theres qualities in both outfits that are very fitting. ^^ Though, I like that in the new outfits they're not all just wearing extremely similar skirts—they actually have some variation in clothing. Which is something I'm happy to see, them all having the same structured outfit kind of bothered me

[Solar Power 338]

I mostly prefer the new ones - with the exception of Sunset. The newer clothes are good but I prefer the older look. There's just something about all the other newer ones that I find appealing.

[Sparklefan1234 180,087]

On 2025-06-08 at 8:32 AM, Snoopy Fan said:

 

or the new ones?

I like the new Equestria Girls look especially, Rarity’s. 

[KPackratt 720]

I prefer the originals. In my opinion, the redesigns just didn't feel right. I personally would've gone the route that they took with the minor characters (specifically Trixie and Big Mac) by keeping their outfits the same, but changing their shoes.

As for Sunset Shimmer, I like her first redesign (from Friendship Games and the Rainbow Rocks music video shorts that featured her) the most.