Which character would you want to see become evil?

[cider float 2,538]

Whether it's a good, bad or redeemed character which character would you love to see become evil? 

[Skullbuster 1,906]

Twilight Sparkle, I want to see how the rest of them deal with twilights OPness when she goes rouge

[QuirkyUsername 1,576]

Well I was gonna say evil Pinkie but she would just be Discord lite. I gotta agree with Skullbuster. Having them try to handle plot armor and other OP nonsense for any given situation would be interesting.

[Merion 783]

Scootaloo... I'd like to see her become frustrated with her lack of ability to fly. Maybe she could develop an inferiority complex that would twist her?

[CandyStrike 603]

Winona becomes rapid after being bit by a fruit bat.  The apple family is too late to realize before one of them gets hurt. 

 

Spike dies and Twilight Sparkle turns to dark magic to resurrect him.  They both become corrupted!

 

Princess Flurry Heart, because no evil is more dangerous than adorable evil.

 

I don't really want to see any of these, I'm just sharing my ideas

Edited February 13, 2016 by CandyStrike

[Hazy Skies 1,010]

Hmmm.. Do you mean evil permanently?

 

If it's temporary I'd like to see Celestia turn evil..

Just because that'd be interesting to see

 

Wait.. What if Derpy became evil? O_O

Edited February 13, 2016 by AURAequine

[Limeblossom 482]

Scootaloo... I'd like to see her become frustrated with her lack of ability to fly. Maybe she could develop an inferiority complex that would twist her?

That's quite possible to happen.

[Mesme Rize 15,687]

Won't happen. It's not the right show for this kinda stuff.

[Megas 27,783]

Won't happen. It's not the right show for this kinda stuff.

this

 

Though I'd be fine with Trixie going back to being bad guy, she's a lot more entertaining

[Buck Testa 5,505]

Hmmm.. Do you mean evil permanently?

 

If it's temporary I'd like to see Celestia turn evil..

Just because that'd be interesting to see

 

Wait.. What if Derpy became evil? O_O

Basically this

________________

 

 

As for who'd I want to go bad. Twilight AND Spike. Those two would be formidable as hell. Spike does draw power from Greed after all. 

Edited February 13, 2016 by Buck Testa

[Chuckles4lyfe 441]

I love playing with the idea that Spike and Twilight go rogue and become evil. Sure it will never happen in the show, but I think there is a lot of untapped potential here.

 

My other choice goes to the recently revealed Princess Flurry Heart. I would love to see the past villains swoop her up and take her under their wing. 

[cider float 2,538]

this

 

Though I'd be fine with Trixie going back to being bad guy, she's a lot more entertaining

Her being bad was the basis of her character.

[Mesme Rize 15,687]

Her being bad was the basis of her character.

 

Trixie wasn't bad, she was a showmare and showmares (or man, if you want) are often very brash, because they play a "role." That's why i don't like boast busters, because the mane 6 got easily mad about role she played.

 

Now, she was bad in Magic Duel, but mostly because of the Alicorn Amulet, because it corrupted her.

[cider float 2,538]

Trixie wasn't bad, she was a showmare and showmares (or man, if you want) are often very brash, because they play a "role." That's why i don't like boast busters, because the mane 6 got easily mad about role she played.

 

Now, she was bad in Magic Duel, but mostly because of the Alicorn Amulet, because it corrupted her.

No she was arrogant and her lies brought disaster.

[Mesme Rize 15,687]

No she was arrogant and her lies brought disaster.

 

It's called keeping your persona up, to make your "character" believable.

 

Also, it wasn't her fault that "bulk and skull" went into the cave.

[Ruddboy Olaf 10,628]

Lightning Dust,Flim Flam Bros,Special Delivery,and Octavia.

[cider float 2,538]

It's called keeping your persona up, to make your "character" believable.

 

Also, it wasn't her fault that "bulk and skull" went into the cave.

No, that was her personality, she's an unicorn they are meant to do magic she's not a human magician that have to use fraud to get by. Her magic tricks was actual telekinesis. 

 

And it is her fault Snips and Snails went out to the cave. They're just children and she uses lies to buy them.

[Silver Stream. 708]

It's called keeping your persona up, to make your "character" believable.

 

Also, it wasn't her fault that "bulk and skull" went into the cave.

 

This. If people look hard enough, they'd notice that Trixie never directly brought on the disasters that happened during her appearance. But more so indirectly: She lies and tries to upstage every pony in attempts to gain fame and money because that's what she does for a living. But because of her arrogance and lies, snips and snails caused the big monster bear disaster. 

 

In Magic Duel, Trixie stole the amulet in hopes to redeem herself. But because she wasn't aware of the consequences, the amulet took over and caused chaos for every pony in ponyville. 

 

 

Basically, Trixie isn't evil or a bad character. She's simply "human". Making choices without thinking about the consequences of her actions because of her need to prove herself to the world. I'm not a huge trixie fan, but I can understand why she's so popular to the others because many might see her as a relatable character. She's arrogant, ignorant, and TOO proud....but I personally believe she uses these to mask her insecurities for being imperfect. Which MANY of us do all the time.

Edited February 13, 2016 by Silver Stream.

[Mesme Rize 15,687]

No, that was her personality, she's an unicorn they are meant to do magic she's not a human magician that have to use fraud to get by. Her magic tricks was actual telekinesis. 

 

And it is her fault Snips and Snails went out to the cave. They're just children and she uses lies to buy them.

 

So, she can't act because she is not human and because she uses actual magic?

 

Where is the sense in all this?

[cider float 2,538]

So, she can't act because she is not human and because she uses actual magic?

 

Where is the sense in all this?

Okay so she chose a profession for the rest of her life which she have to be arrogant and a liar, anything I remember from acting class is that you don't really pretend you just pull out a part of you that matches that character which is still you yourself, the best actors are really being themselves not pretending to be something else and the fact that she decided to be arrogant and fake... says enough about her. Also I don't buy it's an act or anything why? Because in a world where magic is possible and the fact that she's an unicorn that can perform real magic nobody would be impressed by her in fact they would see her as a fraud. In our world it's different because magic isn't real but those that can trick us into it are something we are impressed with and consider it a profession. Her profession in this world is a joke.

[Mesme Rize 15,687]

Okay so she chose a profession for the rest of her life which she have to be arrogant and a liar, anything I remember from acting class is that you don't really pretend you just pull out a part of you that matches that character which is still you yourself, the best actors are really being themselves not pretending to be something else and the fact that she decided to be arrogant and fake... says enough about her. Also I don't buy it's an act or anything why? Because in a world where magic is possible and the fact that she's an unicorn that can perform real magic nobody would be impressed by her in fact they would see her as a fraud. In our world it's different because magic isn't real but those that can trick us into it are something we are impressed with and consider it a profession. Her profession in this world is a joke.

 

These are all claims that you do and not facts.

 

We like to project the stuff that we see in this show to our everyday lifes, that's why it's also a "slice of life" show. In this world, be it stage magicians, prowrestlers or circus artists, they all have certain personas, that they have to keep even in real life, because they don't want that the illusion of this character breaks for the audience.

[Silver Stream. 708]

Okay so she chose a profession for the rest of her life which she have to be arrogant and a liar, anything I remember from acting class is that you don't really pretend you just pull out a part of you that matches that character which is still you yourself, the best actors are really being themselves not pretending to be something else and the fact that she decided to be arrogant and fake... says enough about her. Also I don't buy it's an act or anything why? Because in a world where magic is possible and the fact that she's an unicorn that can perform real magic nobody would be impressed by her in fact they would see her as a fraud. In our world it's different because magic isn't real but those that can trick us into it are something we are impressed with and consider it a profession. Her profession in this world is a joke.

 

 

You misunderstand, hun. Trixie's profession is to impress with powerful magic capabilities she does NOT have. Her magic is what many would consider weak. She didn't "decide" to be arrogant and fake. She's like that for reasons that aren't known to us but it doesn't hurt to take certain guesses. Some believe she is the way she is because she insecure that she's a unicorn with weak powers.....and tries to hide it behind a mask of pride which comes out as arrogance to others. It's called impressing the people with illusions and lies. The illusion is making it seem as though she is far more powerful than she actually is. And the lies are, of course, stories to make a reputation for herself and back up her illusions. Even in a world of magic being common, ponies seemingly are still impressed by magic itself. In fact, "power" seems to be a big deal within the FiM series anyway. The powerful you are, the better your reputation. And quite frankly, reputation, whether it's in this world or theirs, is EVERYTHING. 

 

There's nothing wrong with considering her profession as a joke. Regardless, it is her profession. Many say Rarity's profession is a joke because she dedicate herself to clothes which isn't a big deal to wear in the pony world. Same for the Pegasi....where their profession is to control weather, but it's been implied many times how unicorns are able to control the weather as well. In fact, many daily tasks can easily be done by "magic" from unicorns: baking, clothing, weather, building, even the rise of the sun and moon. Granted, it'll be difficult, but NOT impossible for any of these. One could then say that any other pony who performs these tasks as their profession are "jokes". 

 

Her goal isn't to prove that magic is real "yo give me money because I am a real unicorn performing real magic". Her goal is to prove she's more powerful than the average unicorn "yo give me money because I'm the most powerful unicorn in equestria". 

Edited February 13, 2016 by Silver Stream.

[cider float 2,538]

These are all claims that you do and not facts.

 

We like to project the stuff that we see in this show to our everyday lifes, that's why it's also a "slice of life" show. In this world, be it stage magicians, prowrestlers or circus artists, they all have certain personas, that they have to keep even in real life, because they don't want that the illusion of this character breaks for the audience.

And you've got nothing either so don't act like you do that's why we only explain in the manner we do. You can't prove that in that world where magic exists stage magicians are not even a real thing and is more or less a fraud.

You misunderstand, hun. Trixie's profession is to impress with powerful magic capabilities she does NOT have. Her magic is what many would consider weak. She didn't "decide" to be arrogant and fake. She's like that for reasons that aren't known to us but it doesn't hurt to take certain guesses. Some believe she is the way she is because she insecure that she's a unicorn with weak powers.....and tries to hide it behind a mask of pride which comes out as arrogance to others. It's called impressing the people with illusions and lies. The illusion is making it seem as though she is far more powerful than she actually is. And the lies are, of course, stories to make a reputation for herself and back up her illusions. Even in a world of magic being common, ponies seemingly are still impressed by magic itself. In fact, "power" seems to be a big deal within the FiM series anyway. The powerful you are, the better your reputation. And quite frankly, reputation, whether it's in this world or theirs, is EVERYTHING. 

 

There's nothing wrong with considering her profession as a joke. Regardless, it is her profession. Many say Rarity's profession is a joke because she dedicate herself to clothes which isn't a big deal to wear in the pony world. Same for the Pegasi....where their profession is to control weather, but it's been implied many times how unicorns are able to control the weather as well. In fact, many daily tasks can easily be done by "magic" from unicorns: baking, clothing, weather, building, even the rise of the sun and moon. Granted, it'll be difficult, but NOT impossible for any of these. One could then say that any other pony who performs these tasks as their profession are "jokes". 

 

Her goal isn't to prove that magic is real "yo give me money because I am a real unicorn performing real magic". Her goal is to prove she's more powerful than the average unicorn "yo give me money because I'm the most powerful unicorn in equestria". 

Yes what you said is she is a fraud. People that want to be powerful and only pretend to be are frauds.

[Mesme Rize 15,687]

And you've got nothing either so don't act like you do that's why we only explain in the manner we do. You can't prove that in that world where magic exists stage magicians are not even a real thing and is more or less a fraud.

Yes what you said is she is a fraud. People that want to be powerful and only pretend to be are frauds.

 

I never said i did. If i sounded like that, then i am sorry.

 

After all, we're only having a friendly discussion.

[Silver Stream. 708]

And you've got nothing either so don't act like you do that's why we only explain in the manner we do. You can't prove that in that world where magic exists stage magicians are not even a real thing and is more or less a fraud.

Yes what you said is she is a fraud. People that want to be powerful and only pretend to be are frauds.

Well of course! But what you were saying (at least that's what I understand) is that she chose to be arrogant on purpose as a profession. I was only explaining that the real profession is her trying to make a rep for herself as the most powerful pony in Equestria which isn't a bad idea because she is at least aware of what sells. And what sells, is powerful magic no other pony can possess. The only problem is, and this is what OFFICIALLY makes her a fraud (not what you were saying)...is that she's isn't the most powerful. 

 

 

Confidence and pride are perfect illusions when it comes to convincing others. It's what makes lies seem like truth even if you're lying to yourself. But even as a Fraud, that doesn't make her a bad character or a joke. "Frauds" are more common than "The real deal" including people like you and me. Some are frauds because that's all they know. None of us know TRixie's talent yet. From her cutiemark it could be one of the following: 

 

1. Magic. But she's hasn't reached her peak yet. Because magic is all that she dedicates her life on, she has no choice but to use that as her profession even if it's still weak. 

 

2. Illusions and Tricks. You cannot judge a unicorn because she's destined to perform magic tricks, but not destined to possess real powerful magic. Perhaps her profession really was her calling. But anyone with REAL sense will know that claiming "hey I can do magic tricks" will NOT impress any pony. Which can still explain why she upsells herself as a powerful unicorn. It's called marketing. It's called business. It's called life. And yes....it is also called Fraud. When you go to an interview for a job, you upsell yourself in hopes to get the gig and make the money. Facts are great and all, and people do look for truth, but they also want to see how well you can sell yourself and convince them why they should pick you. 

 

 

And that's similar to what Trixie does, Why should ponies go see some normal unicorn perform tricks? What's special about her? And that's when Trixie executes her confidence and pride which is seen as arrogance to others: "I am the great and powerful Trixie!!!! More powerful than any other unicorn in Equestria! AND THAT'S why you should come see me"!