Which monster would Fluttershy be most successful at taming?

[KillerKingBakudan 702]

We know she can handle lots of different monsters from the Everfree Forest, as well as dragons. But what about these?

- An Alien xenomorph

 

 

- A Cacodemon from Doom

 

 

- A Hunter from Resident Evil

 

 

- The Blob

 

 

- The Thing

 

[Hazy Skies 1,010]

Probably the blob because it's the least scary

[Ashen Pathfinder 16,161]

@

 

Just letting you know as this was dealing with a character it was moved to Show Discussion.

 

Thanks.

[FlootahBabby 265]

Fluttershy could tame Satan if she wanted to.

Edited March 31, 2016 by FlootahBaby

[KillerKingBakudan 702]

Fluttershy could tame Satan if she wanted to.

But not Tirek? Not by a long shot.

[Luminance 2,186]

Why not herself as Flutterhulk? She's pretty terrifying.

[CrystalCarol 16]

I'd say she'd do best with the Blob (It could be Smooze's sister O.O) or an Alien xenomorph.

[Unlikeable Pony 2,698]

But not Tirek?

SEASON SEVEN SEASON FINALE.

[cmarston1 5,959]

None of them.

She would be way out of her league.

[captainborgue 343]

Blob is like Schmooze's cranky stepdad, lol!

 

I think she could tame everything except the Blob and Xenomorph. Those two don't have eyes, so the Stare is useless. Also, the Blob just eats and eats and eats, it has no capacity for thought or feeling or pity or anything. And xenomorphs do whatever it takes to make more xenomorphs, so even if she tamed ONE the hive would murder that one with extra violence before adapting to her taming capacity so she can't use it twice.

Edited April 1, 2016 by captainborgue

[Buck Testa 5,505]

The girl stared down a friggin Cockatrice and won.... a Cockatrice, a being that can turn you to stone by STARING at you... 

 

I say she'd be able to tame all of them, although it would be questionable with the Xenomorph since they don't have eyes and thus have nothing to stare into. 

[sombertempest 20]

Not gonna lie, probably the Alien Xenomorph. It is already an intelligible creature (debatable), therefore it can be convinced by Fluttershy's powerful kindness. Not to mention her stare. 

 

The girl stared down a friggin Cockatrice and won.... a Cockatrice, a being that can turn you to stone by STARING at you... 

 

I say she'd be able to tame all of them, although it would be questionable with the Xenomorph since they don't have eyes and thus have nothing to stare into. 

Buck Testa, you were pretty much on point with your explanation. The Xenomorph does not have eyes, however I do think that it does see in a way (again debatable). If Fluttershy had the power of a Cockatrice, she would be freaking unstoppable.

 

Warmest of Breezes,

 

ST 

[KillerKingBakudan 702]

Blob is like Schmooze's cranky stepdad, lol!

 

I think she could tame everything except the Blob and Xenomorph. Those two don't have eyes, so the Stare is useless. Also, the Blob just eats and eats and eats, it has no capacity for thought or feeling or pity or anything. And xenomorphs do whatever it takes to make more xenomorphs, so even if she tamed ONE the hive would murder that one with extra violence before adapting to her taming capacity so she can't use it twice.

None of them do. And while I think the consensus so far seems interesting, there are some things that aren't being taken into account.

 

Fluttershy obviously couldn't pull the stare on any of the MLP villains like Tirek or Chrysalis, so what about a less powerful monster that's an actual demon from Hell? 

 

Hunters are B.O.W.s that are genetically programmed to kill by definition. Could a stare possibly undo all of that?

 

The rest are parasites. They can't thrive without killing other life forms, and Fluttershy would not begin to understand that until she sees them kill one of her animals or even other ponies. The stare might not work on the xenomorph or the Blob, but if it could work on the Thing (no doubt the scariest fucking one of the bunch) would she have the courage to even look at it? Or anybody else for that matter?

 

 

I can't imagine what would happen if this thing had the head of a rabbit, and Fluttershy found Angel's digested carcass on the ground next to it.

Edited April 3, 2016 by Lord-Pomegranate

[Scootaloo9074090 501]

On 2016-04-03 at 4:29 AM, KillerKingBakudan said:

None of them do. And while I think the consensus so far seems interesting, there are some things that aren't being taken into account.

 

Fluttershy obviously couldn't pull the stare on any of the MLP villains like Tirek or Chrysalis, so what about a less powerful monster that's an actual demon from Hell? 

 

Hunters are B.O.W.s that are genetically programmed to kill by definition. Could a stare possibly undo all of that?

 

The rest are parasites. They can't thrive without killing other life forms, and Fluttershy would not begin to understand that until she sees them kill one of her animals or even other ponies. The stare might not work on the xenomorph or the Blob, but if it could work on the Thing (no doubt the scariest fucking one of the bunch) would she have the courage to even look at it? Or anybody else for that matter?

 

 

I can't imagine what would happen if this thing had the head of a rabbit, and Fluttershy found Angel's digested carcass on the ground next to it.

 what about Sauron? he is Intelligent and Manipulative Villain, would Fluttershy  stare would on Sauron because Sauron have eye and also wear battle armor, so Fluttershy might be able to tame him.