Pinkie or Fluttershy? Who is cuter?

[Pinkie4eeeever 38]

No! I can't answer! It's too difficult!!!!! They are both too cute! And you have Sweetiebell as an option? That's not fair!!!!! 

Well I am going to have to say Fluttershy mainly because she is so cute when she blushes.  But Pinkie Pie and Sweetiebell are way beyond cute too.   

Edited July 16, 2013 by Pinkie4eeeever

[smokebomb 9]

This question rages an unholy war in my head every day lol

 

My fav is Fluttershy, but Pinkie keeps trying to claw her way into that top spot... but I have to say Fluttershy's quietness somehow out-cutes Pinkie's craziness every time. That's not to say Pinkie won't do a Solid Snake (again) and sneak her way into that #1 spot...

 

 

Also: Pinkie Pie as Sam Fisher/Solid Snake? Genius! 

[Dark Horn 430]

Pinkie Pie is fun, but when it comes down to a contest of cuteness, no one can match Fluttershy... except for maybe Luna and Twilight Sparkle.

[Vay 175]

Pinkie Pie but I know I'm on the losing team. I find Pinkie's brand of cute much more to my tastes. When she rolls around on the floor in "Pinkie Keen" I think it's the most adorable thing.

[CT-1138 3,182]

Between the two, it's a difficult choice, but I think Fluttershy is cuter while Pinkie Pie is more adorable. Sweetie Belle was the one I voted for tho.  

 

However, Rainbow Dash is cutest! 

[They call me Loyalty 1,948]

Pinkie Pie. Beautiful, isn't she?

 

 

So yes, My answer, as you may have noticed, is... Pinkie pie. Yeap, I think she is the cuttest in mlp, when she smiles she looks so cute!

Edited July 28, 2013 by They call me Loyalty

[NothingIsEverything 1,243]

That's a funny way of spelling Tom the Rock.

 

But seriously, even though I love both, Fluttershy has the slight advantage by 0.000000001%.

 

It's a tough choice between Fluttershy's caring nature and Pinkie's party nature. With Fluttershy, it just comes naturally to her. Even though Pinkie Pie does care, I think she would get wound up to fast. I just find careness to be an attractive feature for me.

 

Plus, Fluttershy's mane is just so beautiful.

Edited July 28, 2013 by Mentally Blind

[Nah 3,182]

Pinkie Pie is much much cuter than Fluttershy by a long shot, Fluttershy isn't even cute in the slightest and has no character to her, she is incredibly dull and generic and truthfully, Pinkie is full of character and is cute and funny at the same time.

[The Blades Shadow 444]

Great, making me choose between two of my favorite characters!

Um... I'm gonna have to say Fluttershy, just because I've always considered her the cutest pony ever, but Pinkie get's a close second

[ShadowRose2k 271]

While I Love Pinkie Pie , Fluttershy wins this vote.   Cute Sooo much Cute.  Sweetie Bell is kinda cute , I guess, but I don't count youth in my cute calculations, lol.   Seems like it would just give the Foal's and unfair advantage.

[xblackrosesx 81]

As much as I love Pinkie, Fluttershy is the definiton of cuteness.

I mean come on her voice and personality... it's just adorable. ^^

[They call me Loyalty 1,948]

I was joking about Pinkie's picture, but in fact my vote was meant to help Pinkie Pie, indeed. I really think she is cutest when she smiles, even more than Fluttershy. Which I think could be due to I have personality pretty much similar to Fluttershy's one.
So, by the way, that could be the explanation why I don't find her nature as cute, as most people do.

Though of course Fluttershy would be my second option.

Apologies for my english.
 

[TailsIsNotAlone 3,695]

In a blog I acknowledged that Fluttershy was created to ooze cuteness from the get-go.  I also admitted that they go overboard sometimes and it rubs some people the wrong way.

Exactly 

 

It's gotta be Pinkie!They're different kinds of cute and I like hers a lot better. The pink menace wrote the book on how to achieve cuteness through comedy.

 

 

See?

[Fridge 382]

I have to say as much as I love Pinkie (being my favourite and all), Fluttershy is cuter even if she's my second least favourite of the main six.

[RrVPfX9cPtw59FpC 1,304]

Who's cuter, Pinkie or Fluttershy? Obvious answer. Sweetie Bell. Duh. However, if I had to choose between the two, it'd have to be Fluttershy. Although they're both cute, shyness just seems really cute to me. If Derpy Hooves was as shy as Fluttershy, she'd instantly be the cutest.